IN - Aliahna Maroney Lemmon, 9, Fort Wayne, 23 Dec 2011 - #1

New Posts

  • #261
The whole thing stinks. If I (and most responsible parents I know) suddenly reclaimed my child I would certainly make sure the babysitter knew about it because I would expect any babysitter I would entrust my children with to be concerned if one was suddenly not there. It shouldn't matter to the babysitter what the six year olds said; he should have had questions for mom andmom should have had questions for him; but instead no one asks anything? Doesn't sit well with me. Either they are lying or they both view children as "after thoughts" who are not among their highest priority.
 
  • #262
the seeker said:
>> snipped <<. ..... he should have had questions for mom andmom should have had questions for him; but instead no one asks anything? Doesn't sit well with me. Either they are lying or they both view children as "after thoughts" who are not among their highest priority.
Click to expand...

Not saying this is the case here, but this is fairly typical behavior for substance abusers.

Do we know anything about that in this case??
 
  • #263
momtective said:
What!? That makes no sense at all!

6:30am He goes back to sleep after smoking cigar.

10:00am Aliahna's mother calls him to what? Check on her daughter who is supposedly in his care?

After the call from Aliahna's mother when he most likely told her everything was fine???? Then he notices the child is missing???? No freaking way!:banghead:

Why would Aliahna's mother have called him if Aliahna had already left with her mother?
Click to expand...

Yes, if he really said these things as reported, there HAVE to be some lies in there somewhere, because there is no way all of this makes sense when you put it together.

I am going to say that he is lying about the report that the younger sisters said she left with their mother (unless we want to assume that 3- and 8-year-old were lying to cover for their run-away 9-year-old sister). Because we know that the mother never saw her--"friend" tacitly admits to that in going along with the "miscommunication" theory.

Do we have the link to the statement about the girls' saying she left with her mom? I am going to check upthread, but if it isn't already posted, could someone locate it?

ETA: Found it (http://www.journalgazette.net/article/20111226/LOCAL07/312269944). Thanks.
 
  • #264
It's here Etilema
http://www.journalgazette.net/article/20111226/LOCAL07/312269944/-1/LOCAL11

He said he smoked his cigar and went back to sleep about 6:30 a.m. He woke up about 10 a.m. when Aliahna&#8217;s mother called. After that call, he realized the door to the home was unlocked and that Aliahna was gone. He said Aliahna&#8217;s sisters, both 6 years old, told him that Aliahna had left with her mom.
 
  • #265
  • #266
  • #267
  • #268
The only way I can make this story make sense is to imagine that when the mom spoke to the friend, she told him she would be picking Aliahna up later to take her to the party (or whatever), so that when she was discovered to be gone a little later, the sisters said she must have gone with mom, and the friend assumed they actually saw her leave.

Just speculating.
 
  • #269
One of the first articles I read said there were 30 trailers and 15 registered sex offenders where she lives.
 
  • #270
Dr.Fessel said:
One of the first articles I read said there were 30 trailers and 15 registered sex offenders where she lives.
Click to expand...

I read that too, and was amazed that a family would willing live in such a place. Can only assume there are reasons...
 
  • #271
MsFacetious said:
Maybe because he doesn't have a job to be at that night? Stepfather NEEDS to sleep in order to work?

Or maybe just simply because Mr P doesn't have a woman with the flu living with him???
Maybe they were simply worried the girls would get sick, about not exposing them to the flu... less about who took care of them.

I also have to say that the "why didn't she leave them with the STEPfather?" line is throwing me a bit. It's odd.
Usually we are saying "Another stepfather??? When will women learn that the boyfriend/stepfather is the most dangerous person to their child?"

But this time... people are angry that she left the kids (including her stepdaughter) with a family friend instead of the father/stepfather.
Yet, if they had been left with the stepfather... it'd be the usual... "another stepfather, when will women learn...." situation.

My poor brain can't handle the contradictions... it's spinning. :banghead:
Click to expand...

If people are uncomfortable about stepfathers, how is a totally unrelated male a better choice?
 
  • #272
  • #273
Etilema said:
Yes, if he really said these things as reported, there HAVE to be some lies in there somewhere, because there is no way all of this makes sense when you put it together.

I am going to say that he is lying about the report that the younger sisters said she left with their mother (unless we want to assume that 3- and 8-year-old were lying to cover for their run-away 9-year-old sister). Because we know that the mother never saw her--"friend" tacitly admits to that in going along with the "miscommunication" theory.

Do we have the link to the statement about the girls' saying she left with her mom? I am going to check upthread, but if it isn't already posted, could someone locate it?

ETA: Found it (http://www.journalgazette.net/article/20111226/LOCAL07/312269944). Thanks.
Click to expand...

Get out your salt because I don't have a link. IIRC, there was an apparent post from a neighbor in a news article comment section. The post went into great detail on how Aliahna had a nightmare, the girls calmed her down, then later she told the girls she was going to the party. Now the comments are gone and the comment section is disabled.
 
  • #274
  • #275
Etilema said:
If people are uncomfortable about stepfathers, how is a totally unrelated male a better choice?
Click to expand...

At least if the mother is living with the guy she can have some idea what's going on in the home.

But maybe her illness was a force majeure or this guy is really beyond all suspicion if you know him personally.

“He’s never been inappropriate or out of line. I mean, I would trust the man with any of my grandkids,” said David Story, the husband of Aliahna’s grandma.
Click to expand...
http://www.journalgazette.net/article/20111226/LOCAL07/312269944/-1/LOCAL11

It's just that I wouldn't trust my children with someone who just up and leaves while the kids are asleep to go get some smokes and then sleeps through the day and is blithely unaware where all three kids even are.
 
  • #276
  • #277
I can't get past why Ana was sleeping in a chair....
why wasn't she in a bedroom? even single wide trailers i've been in have at least 2 bedrooms, usually 3, a master at one end, and then past the kitchen dining and living room area there is a hallway with a bathroom and 1 or 2 bedrooms down there......

When my friends kids spend the night, we put all boys in one room and let the girls take over another bedroom.... and the girls all sleep together sometimes spread out 2 in a bed, 1 on the floor or all 3 in 1 bed together, slumber party style....
Grandpa had just passed away... so i'm going to ASSume that g-pa still had a bed in his bedroom...
I dunno.. her sleeping in the chair bugs me...
 
  • #278
MOM -- Tarah Souders, 28
MISSING -- Aliahna Lemmon, 9
FAMILY FRIEND / NEIGHBOR -- Mike Plumadore,

TIMELINE:

Saturday, Dec 3
Aliahna's Grandfather, a RSO, died on 12/3/11. He lived in the trailer with Mike Plumadore who cared for him until he passed away. Here is some info on the grandfather: http://www.homefacts.com/offender-de...-E-Lemmon.html​


Tuesday Dec 20

Afternoon -- the last time Tarah Souders saw her daughter​
Wednesday Dec 21

Thursday Dec 22

Aliahna Lemmon and two younger sisters spend the night at family friend Mike Plumadore&#8217;s mobile home​
Friday Dec 23

MP wakes at 6:00am, sees the children sleeping, deadbolts the door and goes to a nearby C-store for a cigar. Video confirms his presence.​
MP returns to find the kids still asleep. He smoked his cigar and went back to bed.​
MP woke again at about 10:00am when Alianhna&#8217;s mother called. Sometime after the call MP observed that the deadbolt was unsecured and that Aliahna was gone. He claimed Aliahna&#8217;s sisters, both 6 years old, told him that Aliahna had left.​
MP believed them. He relocked the door and went back to sleep until about 1:30 p.m.​
He said that when he woke up, he and the two other girls went about their day until about 8:30 p.m, when he talked to Aliahna&#8217;s mom and learned that Aliahna was not with her.​

Authorities were notified.​
Reportedly, Souders agreed with Plumadore&#8217;s version of what happened, labeling the mixup a miscommunication.​
Several family members have come forward to vouch for Mr Plumadore.​
Family member statements indicate a belief that she left MP&#8217;s home. &#8220;They're not quite sure where she went or what was in her mind at the time&#8221; (http://www.indianasnewscenter.com/n...ng-for-Missing-9-Year-Old-Girl-136207958.html)​
Saturday Dec 24

FBI, fire departments, city, county, and state police agencies searched a five-mile-radius for the missing girl. No Amber Alert was issued. &#8220;Justifiably so, if they put Amber Alerts out for every missing child or possible run away or anything, nobody would pay attention to them. So there's certain criteria that have to be met for an Amber Alert,&#8221; Sheriff Fries said. http://www.indianasnewscenter.com/n...ng-for-Missing-9-Year-Old-Girl-136207958.html​
Neighbors reported that police had stopped searching by 5pm​
Sunday Dec 25

No searches conducted​
Monday Dec 26

???
 
  • #279
peeples said:
I can't get past why Ana was sleeping in a chair....
why wasn't she in a bedroom? even single wide trailers i've been in have at least 2 bedrooms, usually 3, a master at one end, and then past the kitchen dining and living room area there is a hallway with a bathroom and 1 or 2 bedrooms down there......

When my friends kids spend the night, we put all boys in one room and let the girls take over another bedroom.... and the girls all sleep together sometimes spread out 2 in a bed, 1 on the floor or all 3 in 1 bed together, slumber party style....
Grandpa had just passed away... so i'm going to ASSume that g-pa still had a bed in his bedroom...
I dunno.. her sleeping in the chair bugs me...
Click to expand...

I am not sure how her sleeping location would have any relevance. Aliahna and her two siblings were spending the night / week staying with a family friend -- so, three guest kids in one small trailer. Perhaps Aliahna was creeped out to sleep in grandfather's bed, or perhaps the two younger girls were sleeping there and she grabbed a couch. Lot's of possible explanations, and yet I cannot think of even a single one that raises any alarm bells with me.

Other parts of this story, sure, but not this.
 
  • #280
Because she's special needs, she has a history of sleep walking and if she's in a chair, i'm assuming it's in a living room, which in trailers is by the front door.. not very smart if you're a responsible adult

those are just a couple reasons..
But it's MOO which i'm entitled to
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

U
NC NC - Dennis Wayne Bailey, 67, last seen in area of Mizpah Rd, known to walk in that area, Rockingham, 28 Dec 2024
Replies
1
Views
328
mlhenn
mlhenn
Pennysmom2
IN IN- Loutonia Anthony Alexander, 46, Fort Wayne, 1 Dec 2006
Replies
2
Views
263
Pennysmom1
Pennysmom1
I
ND Missing Kids in North Dakota
Replies
0
Views
244
infinity_r0se
I
Niner
Trials & Sentencing in May, 2023
2
Replies
23
Views
5K
Niner
Niner
Niner
Trials & Sentencings set to begin in November, 2021
2
Replies
28
Views
4K
Niner
Niner

Staff online

Members online

... and 78 more.
Total: 2,745 (members: 79, guests: 2,666)

Online statistics

Members online
79
Guests online
2,666
Total visitors
2,745
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
632,099
Messages
18,621,976
Members
243,019
Latest member
22kimba22
Back
Top