GUILTY IN - Dominique Allen, 15, found dead, burned behind Indy home, 31 Aug 2014

  • #61
Ah, he was in jail a lot from 1987-1994... but out on parole periodically:

Periods where he was possibly free (roughly..):

1990-1992
1994-1999
2002-2006
2012-2014

Might narrow it down. What I wanna know is, who was this other guy he was arrested with over Sandra Clark-Hobbs. And what's that guy been up to.

I almost went back and edited the arson posts -- but I think I'll leave 'em there for now. Maybe there's something to it, just not him. Too many fires!
 
  • #62
Indiana serial killer, ID'd: http://www.theindychannel.com/decod...-police-about-potential-serial-killer-in-2010

Chief Deputy Coroner George Deliopoulos said among the cases he’s working as part of the Vann investigation is the 2007 strangulation of an unidentified woman found in an abandoned garage that had been set on fire. That killing was part of the Scripps investigation.

Vann, 43, was arrested Friday after Afrikka Hardy, 19, was found strangled in a Hammond, Indiana, motel. After interviewing him, police found the remains of six more women over the weekend, including three from Gary – Anith Jones, Christina Williams and Teaira Batey.

This week’s cases and those from the past bear similarities.

Most of the recent killings that are part of the Vann investigation involved bodies found in abandoned properties. All the victims were women and all identified so far have been in their 30s or younger.

At least seven of the older, unsolved strangulations involved women who were found in abandoned properties, alleyways or empty lots, the same kind of areas police are searching this week. Most of the rest were found killed in or just outside of their own homes.
 
  • #63
Sorry for the mass of posts. Just putting them here as reference material. I *know* there's other crimes this guy has done we don't yet know about -- maybe in conjunction with a partner, some of them... I'm spending today sussing out a short list of possible cases. Info on this guy pre-this crime is hard to find. And I can find *none* in the ID of his partner in the Sandra Clark-Hobbs case. I want that name!

Gholston's mugshots, over the years:

http://tribwxin.files.wordpress.com/2014/11/william-gholston-mugshots1.png?w=1200

A revised list of Indiana unsolveds (no idea how complete this is..) according to the official site, and Gholston's periods of free time:

Pre-87
80 http://www.in.gov/isp/2908.htm - elderly, missing, abandoned car
80 http://www.in.gov/isp/2912.htm - shot while riding motorbike
86 http://www.in.gov/isp/2914.htm - rape arson child, strangled
http://www.wndu.com/hometop/headlines/51937792.html
http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?77990-IN-Brandie-Peltz-11-Argos-11-Dec-1986
86 http://www.in.gov/isp/2930.htm - arson
86 http://www.in.gov/isp/2918.htm - abandoned car, missing
early 87 http://www.in.gov/isp/2928.htm - child, found in railway yard, strangled
http://articles.wsbt.com/2013-05-10/bus-stop_39174808


1990-1992
91 http://www.in.gov/isp/2573.htm - found in ditch
92 http://www.in.gov/isp/2920.htm - found behind truck stop
92 http://www.in.gov/isp/2579.htm - found on roadside, stabbed
http://www.dreamindemon.com/community/threads/the-murder-of-holly-anderson.37014/

1994-1999
94 http://www.in.gov/isp/2936.htm - arson child
94 http://www.in.gov/isp/2935.htm - arson (with above child)
94 http://www.in.gov/isp/2952.htm - mildly disabled, shot
http://www.gcdailyworld.com/story/1268083.html
94 http://www.in.gov/isp/2934.htm - older, missing
95 http://www.in.gov/isp/2542.htm# - older, blunt force, robbery
95 http://www.in.gov/isp/2905.htm - stabbed, dumped on vacant lot
http://www.indystar.com/story/news/...death-of-troubled-mom-johanna-weaver/4582213/
95 http://www.in.gov/isp/2923.htm - found in car, shot
96 http://www.in.gov/isp/2953.htm - elderly
96 http://www.in.gov/isp/2955.htm - elderly
97 http://www.in.gov/isp/2937.htm - found in country ditch, strangled
http://www.14news.com/story/6796271/decade-old-cold-case-warms-up
97 http://www.in.gov/isp/2578.htm - found in car, arson, shot

2002-2006
02 http://www.in.gov/isp/2620.htm abandoned car, found in field, blunt force

Lots of cases don't list COD, maybe something to sleuth later.
 
  • #64
  • #65
  • #66
Now, that report says they were all "strangled to death" but earlier reports say two of the women were so badly decomposed as to make cause of death impossible to judge. So how they're suddenly all strangled, I don't know.

http://wishtv.com/2014/10/19/three-bodies-found-in-five-months-have-several-similarities/


And also:

Although these bodies were found in the same neighborhood, there is no evidence to suggest that they are connected, Wilburn said.

http://www.indystar.com/story/news/...-northside-identified-missing-woman/17574043/
 
  • #67
Article on Selese Goss.. omg her poor kids.


On Mother’s Day weekend, Goss asked her son to call her a cab to take her from the home where she lived on North Berwick Avenue.

“The only thing that was unusual was that she took almost $10,000 with her than day,” said D’Arthur. “That was the first time I saw her walk around with that much money in her purse.”

On May 23rd, a week after the Goss children last saw their mother, Indianapolis firefighters were called to put out flames at her home.

On June 4th Goss was reported missing. The next day her body was discovered.

http://fox59.com/2014/06/11/son-says-mother-carried-10000-before-death/


So there's multiple possible suspects there, DV and 10 grand cash, drug dealers, etc....
 
  • #68
  • #69
Loy Ofsthun, nee Rimmer, may have been married to a pedophile.. the only man I can find with her hubby's name has several child sex charges and is a registered offender. Can't see any DV though.

http://www.homefacts.com/offender-detail/NV1000014833/David-Wayne-Ofsthun.html
http://www.cityofhenderson.com/police/offenders/6850.php
http://www.mocavo.com/David-Ofsthun...e-Record-Index-1993-2005/05823324676163079120
2011 'David Ofsthun was arrested on suspicion of annoying children': http://www.applevalley-review.com/node/211
 
  • #70
  • #71
  • #72
Cheers, blondy. I have no real idea why I'm so glued to this case other than my daughter was recently Dominique's age and the thought of losing her, let alone in such a way, just is unthinkable. Maybe too because I do believe there's more victims of this man out there, dead or otherwise.

I am not sure the three 'strangled' victims mentioned above are his handiwork, however. Aside from there being multiple possible perps for those (at least two of them definitely were working girls, one with a violent ex, and there were other killer/s in Indiana killing those at the time), we should keep in mind that there was a knifing case also, for which the charges were dropped - and we don't know why. He's also had armed robbery convictions and weapons charges against him, so I think it's a mistake to focus on strangulation as a "signature" - also, to assume that he confined his victim pool to black women.

In fact, it seems the victims we know about are either quite young, or older and white. There was the rape of the 8yo when he was 15, and Dominique was only 15 and quite petite. Then Sandra's murder, for which he was acquitted due to a technicality.

If I am looking at the right family, this guy's folks are pretty much all crackheads and other assorted criminals. Not pretty. I need to make sure it's the right family before I say anything more on them, though. Two of his girlfriends I've tracked down have prostitution and drug charges, among other things.

The way he bound that poor girl was an act of sadism. That was just for his own viewing pleasure, the sick freak. If there's a pattern to his crimes at all, I'd look for that sort of thing. Possibly the burning too, but that's not even a complete thought until another burned victim shows up. But the binding - yeah. That was him enjoying his power. He'd have done that before, for sure.
 
  • #73
  • #74
http://wishtv.com/2016/04/15/sentencing-friday-for-convicted-murderer-of-15-year-old/

A judge sentenced William Gholston to 84 years in prison Friday for the murder of 15-year-old Dominique Allen.

Last month, a jury convicted Gholston of killing the 15-year-old.

Marion Superior Judge Marc Rothenberg spoke firmly as he addressed Gholston just before his sentencing. Rothenberg called the 48-year-old a “destroyer,” saying Gholston’s actions were “monstrous.”
 
  • #75
Cheers, blondy. I have no real idea why I'm so glued to this case other than my daughter was recently Dominique's age and the thought of losing her, let alone in such a way, just is unthinkable. Maybe too because I do believe there's more victims of this man out there, dead or otherwise.

I am not sure the three 'strangled' victims mentioned above are his handiwork, however. Aside from there being multiple possible perps for those (at least two of them definitely were working girls, one with a violent ex, and there were other killer/s in Indiana killing those at the time), we should keep in mind that there was a knifing case also, for which the charges were dropped - and we don't know why. He's also had armed robbery convictions and weapons charges against him, so I think it's a mistake to focus on strangulation as a "signature" - also, to assume that he confined his victim pool to black women.

In fact, it seems the victims we know about are either quite young, or older and white. There was the rape of the 8yo when he was 15, and Dominique was only 15 and quite petite. Then Sandra's murder, for which he was acquitted due to a technicality.

If I am looking at the right family, this guy's folks are pretty much all crackheads and other assorted criminals. Not pretty. I need to make sure it's the right family before I say anything more on them, though. Two of his girlfriends I've tracked down have prostitution and drug charges, among other things.

The way he bound that poor girl was an act of sadism. That was just for his own viewing pleasure, the sick freak. If there's a pattern to his crimes at all, I'd look for that sort of thing. Possibly the burning too, but that's not even a complete thought until another burned victim shows up. But the binding - yeah. That was him enjoying his power. He'd have done that before, for sure.

This case has always bothered me terribly, too. For some reason, and I have no facts to support this, I always felt this case did not get the attention it deserved. It might be my imagination.
 
  • #76
This case has always bothered me terribly, too. For some reason, and I have no facts to support this, I always felt this case did not get the attention it deserved. It might be my imagination.


I'm with you on this (bbm) --- I remember seeing her family pleading for information and action -- rightfully so. One hopes that this conviction will bring a shred of peace for them

RIP Dominique
 
  • #77
Memorial installed in Haughville in honor of woman abducted, murdered in 2014

http://fox59.com/2016/09/03/memorial-installed-in-haughville-in-honor-of-woman-abducted-murdered-in-2014/

Two years later, Poindexter and her sisters all say they haven’t stopped thinking about how and why their younger sister was killed.

“We still don’t know how he got her and we still don’t know why,” said Poindexter. “We can’t say, ‘Oh my God, let’s just rewind this and go back in time and reverse what happened.’ We can’t do that. She’s gone forever.”

With Dominique’s killer now behind bars, the family is now focusing on helping others.

“We want the community to have some type of light on it and some type of beauty in this community,” said Dominique’s sister Mareeka Allen.

A new bench with Dominique’s name now sits facing the spray park.
 
  • #78
As he started raping so young, I thought this might be relevant. Strangulation + fire:

Brandi Peltz 12/11/1986

Unsolved Cold Case Homicide
Case Number 24-29966

Age: 11 Sex: Female Race: Caucasian

Case Date: 12/11/1986 County: Marshall

Location of Offense: Residence on Old US 31, South of Argos, IN

Circumstances: Brandi Peltz, 11 years old, was found dead in her home floating face down in a bathtub full of water. An upstairs bedroom of the residence was set on fire. Cause of death was strangulation. The victim was found by a passerby who noticed the second story of the residence on fire, and stopped to see if anyone was inside. Peltz was sick the day the incident took place, and was home alone from school.
I was best friends with Brandy Peltz. We had went to Argos elementary since kindergarten. Her murder has haunted me my whole life. There have been so many suspects and accusations since it happened and even a book written called the "Passerby" yet it's still a cold case. Unfortunately I have a hard time believing it could have been someone so young that did this. This is due to #1. her home being a long ways from anything. Even our small town of Argos would have been a long walk. #2. it was in the middle of a school day. #3, her being home by herself during school hours was a first time thing. Her mom had to work that day and had made the last second decision to let her stay by herself so very few knew she was there. So for a 14 or 15 year old to just stumble upon a home in the middle of nowhere, on a school day ( in mid winter in Indiana, I might add) on what happened to be the only day a 11 year old girl was home alone and manages to rape and strangle her and then set fire to her house without anyone seeing him escaping, most likely on foot since he probly couldn't drive yet, seems almost impossible. But, anything is possibly I guess.
 

Guardians Monthly Goal

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
138
Guests online
1,962
Total visitors
2,100

Forum statistics

Threads
635,351
Messages
18,674,319
Members
243,172
Latest member
TX Terri
Back
Top