I don't recall if anyone even looked at his car? I thought it was "new" during the trial last year? In the video you can definitely see his car move, so she definitely bumped it that morning.
This is one of the pieces of the puzzle I'm having trouble with. What are the chances that the very tail light that she backed into JOK with at 12:30ish, she also backs into his car hours later both of which could result in a cracked/broken tail light? I think the odds of that happening within hours of each other are slim.
A few winters ago, my husbands work van was parked on the street and was bumped when a car slid into it and misjudged how much room they had, it knocked hubby's van bumper off (plastic) but I had a bag full of front light pieces from the other car that I picked up off the street! Our security footage showed hubbys van tires moving maybe a bit more then JOK's, but not much. Colder weather can also make it easier to crack/break. JMO