Madeleine McCann: German Prisoner Identified as Suspect, #41

[RichardKimble]

More observations from the ch5 docu, CB in a letter tells MWT that after his release in Dec 06 he never went back to Luz, instead selling drugs in Praia Da Barranco.
Also CB told MWT he driving and got stopped at a police roadblock after 3/05/07 where a man was taking photos, CB challenged and was told it was SY, so if true they had his photo.
Another thought although the pepper spray incident was on the 10th, even if CBs name was not on the docket, how would he know if it if not with the girl.

 

[Davieson]

More observations from the ch5 docu, CB in a letter tells MWT that after his release in Dec 06 he never went back to Luz, instead selling drugs in Praia Da Barranco.
Also CB told MWT he driving and got stopped at a police roadblock after 3/05/07 where a man was taking photos, CB challenged and was told it was SY, so if true they had his photo.
Another thought although the pepper spray incident was on the 10th, even if CBs name was not on the docket, how would he know if it if not with the girl.

No access outside UK

Valid point. I doubt they kept in touch once she went home.

 

[RichardKimble]

Ch5 link, not available out side the uk.
Well worth a read visit imo.

No access outside UK

Synopsis from the mail.

Madeline McCann investigator sure Christian Brueckner didn't do it

An investigator for the case of Madeline McCann says convicted paedophile Christian Brueckner (pictured) is a monster, but that he isn't responsible for the young girl's disappearance.

www.dailymail.co.uk

 

[tedtink]

A good read imo, from a brilliant sleuth, for those who missed the extensive discussion about the MWT docu, 3 years ago.

Post in thread 'Madeleine McCann: German prisoner identified as suspect #30'

Jun 2, 2022

I thought it might be worth documenting exactly what was said about CB's 'alibi' during the course of the MWT documentary so it's down in black and white for those who haven't watched it or just want to recap. The stories in the Press have been grossly confused and don't reflect what was actually said altogether. Below are some brief transcript extracts, covering the sections of the doc where MWT talks about the alibi. I'll try to keep the sarcasm to an absolute minimum.


So... after failing to impress HCW with the results of his enquiries and just when it seemed like he'd hit a...

• Dlk79

• 
• 

Post in thread 'Madeleine McCann: German prisoner identified as suspect #30'

Jun 2, 2022

So other than the non-existent 'alibi', the other main "revelation" of the MWT doc concerened the two phone numbers that the BKA appealed for information about. Again, reports in the press (via MWT's findings) suggested the -680 number did not belong to CB at all, and that multiple people had claimed it was being used by another man in Portugal. And also that the -683 number that called it on the 3rd, belonged to a darkweb paedophile at the time. The reality though is quite different. Below is an analysis of what was actually said about it all.


MWT talks with a cyber analyst. They are...

• Dlk79

• 

 

[C.greek]

I suppose so. Seems a lot, but spread over a decade and a half it only amounts to a handful a year

Which is definitely creepy

 

[frank-cole]

CB doesn't need to scream from the roof tops of his innocence, all that he's heard is through news media, I doubt his defence is constantly in touch, the time for talking is when or if he ever reached court, he never said anything in his recent trial , look how that turned out.

The right to silence.

nemo tenetur se ipsum accusare​

​

The prosecutors have a duty to rule their suspect out if they uncover reason to do so, including anything passed over by the defence. Easy win.

 

[Davieson]

Which is definitely creepy

Sure, clearly has a swimsuit fetish.

 

[frank-cole]

A good read imo, from a brilliant sleuth, for those who missed the extensive discussion about the MWT docu, 3 years ago.

Post in thread 'Madeleine McCann: German prisoner identified as suspect #30'

Jun 2, 2022

I thought it might be worth documenting exactly what was said about CB's 'alibi' during the course of the MWT documentary so it's down in black and white for those who haven't watched it or just want to recap. The stories in the Press have been grossly confused and don't reflect what was actually said altogether. Below are some brief transcript extracts, covering the sections of the doc where MWT talks about the alibi. I'll try to keep the sarcasm to an absolute minimum.


So... after failing to impress HCW with the results of his enquiries and just when it seemed like he'd hit a...

• Dlk79

• 
• 

Post in thread 'Madeleine McCann: German prisoner identified as suspect #30'

Jun 2, 2022

So other than the non-existent 'alibi', the other main "revelation" of the MWT doc concerened the two phone numbers that the BKA appealed for information about. Again, reports in the press (via MWT's findings) suggested the -680 number did not belong to CB at all, and that multiple people had claimed it was being used by another man in Portugal. And also that the -683 number that called it on the 3rd, belonged to a darkweb paedophile at the time. The reality though is quite different. Below is an analysis of what was actually said about it all.


MWT talks with a cyber analyst. They are...

• Dlk79

• 

Thanks that’s great sleuthing.

An alibi that can’t give him an alibi, his number but he wasn’t using - it’s quite nonsensical. Being pro CB, taking everything in isolation & pretending everything is a coincidence is daily chatter here but it’s hard to fathom why channel 5 tried to make a programme out of it.

 

[C.greek]

As far as I've understood, the GPS data they got from inadmissible evidence together with pictures and witness statements placed CB in the Arade dam. The same could be said for the recent search. If they can prove via other means he was there, the perhaps they can say this witness is trustworthy for the court. Jmo

 

[C.greek]

Sure, clearly has a swimsuit fetish.

Of female children as well! Even creepier and frightening

 

[Davieson]

Ch5 link, not available out side the uk.
Well worth a read visit imo.

No access outside UK

Synopsis from the mail.

Madeline McCann investigator sure Christian Brueckner didn't do it

An investigator for the case of Madeline McCann says convicted paedophile Christian Brueckner (pictured) is a monster, but that he isn't responsible for the young girl's disappearance.

www.dailymail.co.uk

While I have nothing against MWT, he's just another investigator with an opinion and a living to make.

 

[Mex]

<modsnip - quoted post was removed>

Not saying this to be a dick but I do think a circumstantial case is based on a narrative. It’s a story based on facts that makes any other way the crime could be committed impossible.

In this instance, it’s possible for the sat nav to indicate he was heading in the direction of PDL but then a gap during the critical time period.

If the link below is to be believed, they have him heading from somewhere to this place 12km from PDL, stationary for six hours, then his onward journey.

It seems likely that he was in or around PDL before this stop and if so bingo! It’s another part of the story.

However, the sat nav will also likely show that he was travelling in and around these areas at all hours every other day - he lived there and committed crime there… even in one of his letters he mentioned travelling at night on back roads or similar… that might be incriminating.

No doubt the BKA’s story puts him in the frame across different pieces of evidence - cell phone data, sat nav trips, emails etc. But, I think there are alternative, equally compelling, narratives that can also explain when, where and why he was at these places.

It might be worthwhile us listing all the evidence we think they have on him and then looking at these more closely to see if we can put some more of the pieces together.

“She was there for 6 hours”: satellite data uncovers an unmarked stop made by Christian Brueckner between 2:41 AM and 8:56 AM — 12 km from where Madeleine McCann vanished - News

The disappearance of Madeleine McCann, the three-year-old British toddler who vanished from a holiday apartment in Praia da Luz, Portugal, on May 3, 2007,

newstvseries.com

Unlike the phone evidence which proves only that CB's phone was in the area at a relevant time, does the sat-nav provide proof of where he was backed up by his own statement?

 

[Davieson]

Of female children as well! Even creepier and frightening

He doesn't seem interested in boys

 

[Davieson]

As far as I've understood, the GPS data they got from inadmissible evidence together with pictures and witness statements placed CB in the Arade dam. The same could be said for the recent search. If they can prove via other means he was there, the perhaps they can say this witness is trustworthy for the court. Jmo

If he was a frequent visitor to these places, that may not be very helpful.

 

[Davieson]

Thanks that’s great sleuthing.

An alibi that can’t give him an alibi, his number but he wasn’t using - it’s quite nonsensical. Being pro CB, taking everything in isolation & pretending everything is a coincidence is daily chatter here but it’s hard to fathom why channel 5 tried to make a programme out of it.

Money

 

[tedtink]

If he was a frequent visitor to these places, that may not be very helpful.

CB said he never went back to PDL after Dec 2006. So I assume it'll be very helpful.

No access outside UK

 

[Anxala]

While I have nothing against MWT, he's just another investigator with an opinion and a living to make.

He and Clarke are in it entirely for their own self-serving interests imo, always full of puff, full of their own importance, always looking to be first with the 'bombshells' that never land and pretty much always turn out to be damp, click-baity squibs that never amount to anything that adds anything useful to the bigger picture.

I have zero interest in anything either one of them has to say.

 

[Davieson]

CB said he never went back to PDL after Dec 2006. So I assume it'll be very helpful.

Only if his presence in PDL after that date can be proved.
Perhaps he was meaning the town itself, rather than the surrounding area.

 

[Anxala]

A good read imo, from a brilliant sleuth, for those who missed the extensive discussion about the MWT docu, 3 years ago.

Post in thread 'Madeleine McCann: German prisoner identified as suspect #30'

Jun 2, 2022

I thought it might be worth documenting exactly what was said about CB's 'alibi' during the course of the MWT documentary so it's down in black and white for those who haven't watched it or just want to recap. The stories in the Press have been grossly confused and don't reflect what was actually said altogether. Below are some brief transcript extracts, covering the sections of the doc where MWT talks about the alibi. I'll try to keep the sarcasm to an absolute minimum.


So... after failing to impress HCW with the results of his enquiries and just when it seemed like he'd hit a...

• Dlk79

• 
• 

Post in thread 'Madeleine McCann: German prisoner identified as suspect #30'

Jun 2, 2022

So other than the non-existent 'alibi', the other main "revelation" of the MWT doc concerened the two phone numbers that the BKA appealed for information about. Again, reports in the press (via MWT's findings) suggested the -680 number did not belong to CB at all, and that multiple people had claimed it was being used by another man in Portugal. And also that the -683 number that called it on the 3rd, belonged to a darkweb paedophile at the time. The reality though is quite different. Below is an analysis of what was actually said about it all.


MWT talks with a cyber analyst. They are...

• Dlk79

• 

It is a good read. Dlk79 has MWT down to a tee.

 

[RichardKimble]

He and Clarke are in it entirely for their own self-serving interests imo, always full of puff, full of their own importance, always looking to be first with the 'bombshells' that never land and pretty much always turn out to be damp, click-baity squibs that never amount to anything that adds anything useful to the bigger picture.

I have zero interest in anything either one of them has to say.

Only one is likely to be right though.