MN -- woman shot in face and killed by ICE, Minneapolis, 7 Jan 2026

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #201
They are shouting contradictory orders - leave, get out of the vehicle - a guy approaches from her left and tries to yank open the door, meanwhile the other guy has circled around from the right and ends up on her front left. She obviously is trying to get away from the guy trying to open her door so she cranks the wheel hard right and guns it. She likely was terrified and never knew the other guy was there. And he blew her away. 😢

But he'll probably walk, scott free 😡
No way Noem is handing that ICE murderer over to the State of Minnesota. IMO
 
  • #202
She was blocking the road, i heard “ get out of the car” then she sped off in the direction if the ice agent.


Jmo
some of y’all need your eyes checked if you seriously think she was driving in the direction of the agent! Her wheels even tell a different story than the one you’re trying to concoct
 
  • #203
She was blocking the road, i heard “ get out of the car” then she sped off in the direction if the ice agent.


Jmo

Was she actively blocking the road or did she pull out of a driveway and got scared by the agents flying down a neighborhood street at unsafe speeds, and was indecisive about whether she should back-up, continue forward so she could get out of the way, or get out of the car???? These ICE cars and trucks are unmarked. She has multiple people with masks on their face and guns yelling contradicting orders at her with one reaching inside of her car. All this happening in the course of a minute. They didn't need to shoot her in the face regardless.

Even IF she was protesting she didn't deserve to be killed by them. ICE is not judge, jury and executioner!!! And then the shooter leaving immediately from the scene and agents preventing any kind of rescue or help is inexcusable. There needs to be accountability and the lawsuits are going to be large. This can't be happening on our streets and neighborhoods. I'm all for leagl immigration control but if this is the way it's being done, by officers this unprofessional, then this is NOT the way to go about it.
 
  • #204
Video from two angles.
Full Shooting:
Full Shooting Different Angle:
That person videotaping and yelling is Bravery in Action!
 
  • #205
Where are you seeing she “sped off”? She doesn’t accelerate her car until after she gets shot 4 times in the face, which at that point, no longer has control of her car and the car basically goes down the street a few hundred feet before crashing. Since she was dying at that point.

Here.

 
  • #206
I very clearly see an officer in front of the vehicle as the woman very rapidly accelerates into a turn and the camera angle changes. In the two incidents that I cited, the accelerations towards the officers were far slower.

The above aside, I don't think the woman was trying to run over the officer. Rather, I firmly believe that she would have continued to turn, then drove away once she had completed the turn (and cleared the officer).

In the end I think the shooting was "justifiable" in the technical legal sense but not truly justified ethically.

The officer should have noted that the vehicle was tightly turning away from him (while also moving towards him). At the same time, the officer cannot read minds and did not know her true intent.

@Cryptic

The truth is, if I, a woman in a car, find my way being blocked by young man with guns, giving me conflicting orders, I’d panic. Probably drop the wheel and cry. I won’t drive well, either. It is not the most productive way to respond, but the reality is, the presence of ICE on the streets, one more group with guns drawn, who are scared themselves, is destabilizing the community. This is the big picture.

The smaller picture: an untrained impulsive idiot killed a woman, a US citizen, for no reason. There is no other way to view it. Sorry.

And why do things always happen in Minnesota?
 
  • #207
SCOTUS just ruled on Barnes v Felix and rejected the ‘moment of threat’ doctrine. ‘Moment of threat’ used to only take into consideration the moment the officer perceived danger. SCOTUS’ rejection means excessive force claims must be judged by the ‘totality of the circumstances’, meaning courts must consider all events leading up to the use of force, and not just the moment of the perceived threat.

In other words, if an officer steps towards a moving vehicle and places himself in the path, he cannot then claim he has justification to shoot in the ‘moment of danger’, as he created the moment of danger.

JMO

 
  • #208
SCOTUS just ruled on Barnes v Felix and rejected the ‘moment of threat’ doctrine. ‘Moment of threat’ used to only take into consideration the moment the officer perceived danger. SCOTUS’ rejection means excessive force claims must always be judged by the ‘totality of the circumstances’, meaning courts must consider all events leading up to the use of force, and not just the moment of the perceived threat.

In other words, if an officer steps towards a moving vehicle and places himself in the path, he cannot then claim he has justification to shoot in the ‘moment of danger’, as he created the moment of danger.

JMO


He didn’t step in the path, she backed up to get around and headed straight towards him, i would have shot too.

Jmo
 
  • #209
Noem said there was bad weather and an ICE vehicle was stuck, but the road and skies look clear in the videos. Was a vehicle stuck?

She says ICE agents conducting an operation got stuck in the snow and were attempting to push out their vehicle when a woman attacked them.

jmopinion

Funny how fast their vehicle came unstuck when a murderer drove off in it at speed Ms. Noem 🙄
Pull the other one, its got bells on!
 
  • #210
He didn’t step in the path, she backed up to get around and headed straight towards him, i would have shot too.

Jmo
He draws his weapon while she’s in reverse.

ETA: if he thought she may hit him, he had plenty of time to move to the right. Instead he draws his gun while taking a step towards the vehicle.
 
  • #211


It is a lie to claim she was not allowing anyone to pass.

In the first second of this video, you can see another ICE vehicle pass in front of her car. The pick-up truck could have done the same.
 
  • #212
Here.

I don’t know how or why there’s such a disparity in the thread of people watching the same videos yet seeing different things. I’ve watched all the videos from every angle (even a slow mo version), I never saw her speed up, accelerate or drive towards an officer until after the first shot was fired directly into her face. At that point, she’s dead/dying/injured and no longer has control of her vehicle. I do agree that is a dangerous situation - which was caused BY the ice officer when he started shooting her.

When I watch the video at your link, I see the officer literally continuing to walk/jog next to her car after he fires the first shot and fire 3 more shots directly into her drivers side window. There was absolutely zero justification or need for him to fire 1 shot, much less 4.
 
  • #213
The FBI said this afternoon that it is investigating today’s fatal shooting by an ICE agent in Minneapolis.

“Consistent with our investigative protocol, the incident is under review, and we are working closely with our law enforcement partners,” the agency said in a statement...


ICE officers are trained to never approach a vehicle from the front and instead to approach in a “tactical L” 90-degree angle to prevent injury or cross-fire, a senior Department of Homeland Security official told NBC News.

Officers are also instructed not to shoot at a moving vehicle and only to use force if there is an immediate risk of serious injury or death, the official said.

ICE officers are also instructed that firing at a vehicle will not make it stop moving in the direction of the officer.

 
  • #214
  • #215

“Renee Nicole Good, the 37-year-old woman fatally shot by an ICE agent on Wednesday morning, had a young son whose father died in 2023, according to the Minnesota Star Tribune.

“There’s nobody else in his life,” Timmy Ray Macklin Sr., the boy’s grandfather, told the paper. “I’ll drive. I’ll fly. To come get my grandchild.””
That’s genuinely so heartbreaking. This was so unnecessary and awful.
 
  • #216
I just hate that being incredibly aggressive, hostile and antagonistic is encouraged for them. Unhappy with protesters? Find a way around her. Turn around. Go a different way. They obviously terrified her, running up to her 5 to 1 with their weapons drawn and screaming. She was attempting to leave as they asked, not intentionally trying to run anyone over. The one agent was to the side of the grill as she was turning away, not in danger of being mowed down.

It's just incomprehensible.

Whether happy or not, protesters are not ICE target group, even. Protesters are usually US citizens, they are not afraid. (Unless ICE illegally detains someone in the Hispanic community, then there may be a local protest, but they usually use lawyers.)

But in general, protesters are the group the police is handling. And nowadays, police has learned not to create havoc.

ICE created havoc, and they need to learn how to diffuse such situations. Now they are in a bad, bad spot. You can hardly imagine worse advertising for them. Killing a US citizen, a 30+-year-old woman, and not a minority. And it doesn’t matter what she did wrong or where she turned. What matters is how it looks to the country.
 
  • #217
I have seen comments online that this shooting occurred less than a mile from where George Floyd was killed in 2020. Are there any MSM sources that confirm this?

With the obvious video footage, and the statements from both Kristi Noem & Donald Trump, tensions are going to rise tonight.

The next few hours are crucial. The city of Minneapolis might be in for a long night.
 
Last edited:
  • #218
A thought, deadly force has to be reasonable at the time *each* shot is fired. Absolutely 0 need to triple tap as he’s alongside the vehicle. JMO

ETA: maybe it’s better said, officers must constantly reassess the situation to determine if use of force is reasonable, and force must stop once the threat subsides.
 
Last edited:
  • #219

“Renee Nicole Good, the 37-year-old woman fatally shot by an ICE agent on Wednesday morning, had a young son whose father died in 2023, according to the Minnesota Star Tribune.

“There’s nobody else in his life,” Timmy Ray Macklin Sr., the boy’s grandfather, told the paper. “I’ll drive. I’ll fly. To come get my grandchild.””
Oh no. What a tragedy. My heart goes out to Grandpa and the boy.

jmopinion
 
  • #220
Look at the video:
1) The officer who killed her was to the left front of the vehicle. Her wheels were turned to the right, turning AWAY from the officer trying to get in her door. So the shooter was NOT in the path of the vehicle. It's likely she never saw the shooter, she was likely focused on getting away from the one at her door.

2) Look at the windshield. One bullet hole in the very leftmost corner. One. The other ones hit her from the side.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Guardians Monthly Goal

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
70
Guests online
2,113
Total visitors
2,183

Forum statistics

Threads
637,457
Messages
18,714,162
Members
244,130
Latest member
haydiana
Back
Top