AZ Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[Gr3yW0lf78]

Yes

I can only think of one, very brief capture on video as he and AG are driving away from their property. Beard color and length can provide quite a quandary.

 

[KellySleuth]

I’m thinking the SIL had help. Possibly he took NG home and the crime took place then. He and a buddy came back later to remove her and stage the kidnapping.

 

[Strangeworld]

Does Mr. Entin ever sleep?

He has done a great job covering this investigation, from what I've seen. I don't really know his work but as far as I've seen, he seems professional and not overly dramatic as some have been in their coverage

 

[CandyKiss]

For clarity: If they are currently treating AG's house as a crime scene (or at the least, investigating it now) what would be the purpose of including her in the two videos asking for Nancy's release? Is there any precedence here?

Innocent until proven guilty....
Also, it is not confirmed the ransom notes are a hoax or not... family united to talk to that perp

 

[cady]

Maybe only if the homeowners said that it was OK, but I don't really know.

LE was there last night maybe to ask permission, but back tonight probably with a warrant

 

[Beans]

Has the SIL been seen since this entire thing began?

Yes, briefly, but now hasn't been spotted in public since around Tuesday or Wednesday to my knowledge.

 

[MCB1151]

I believe the ransom is a separate matter.

I'm glad I'm not alone in this suspicion lol It just does not add up for me. Not saying its impossible they're connected to one individual/group, but it seems overly complex with too many moving parts that are too close to home for this to be one solitary undertaking.

 

[Fromeaster]

Recently or in the very beginning?

At the beginning are photos taken by journalists in front of their house, showing them both hiding their faces.

 

[TIGER0822]

My mind is on overdrive and may soon explode.
I'm thinking now, was SG's video today staged, as in SG knows more than she is saying? Trying to think this through...or discard the thought.

Yes. It was a carefully directed message, likely crafted by LE.

 

[Cebavl]

Has law enforcement returned AG/SIL’s car yet? If not, the family must know what’s going on here.

 

[emigrate]

Well Well Well…

Seems like something is finally happening.

I wondered if Nancy ever came home. That camera they removed may have finally put some pieces together.

Oh boy.

MOO

We have been sure something big was happening a few times this week and then nothing. This is weird to me them going in and out of the houses and then why would they just now be using luminol? SIL has been MIA for days I think he is being held, I think we all have to be prepared for something really shocking with this one. I can't take it, I was holding out so much hope for a happy reunion between NG and her kids.

 

[ttjo]

It won’t last here, it is from Fox News, they have been covering this 24/7, but Verboten.

I know, I thought of that after, I’ll try to find it somewhere else.

 

[truecrimel]

Do AG and the SIL have children? I’m asking because if NG came over for dinner and games, I’d imagine the kids would’ve joined them. I’d be interested in knowing their version of events (what time NG showed up, what time she left, how was the mood during the visit, etc.)

 

[cathathorse]

That's exactly what I'm driving at. Once they had that data, things would have turned much faster than they did.

Not all Apple Watches have cell capability-- some models rely on connection to iPhone for that. The ones that do have that capability you have to pay like $15 extra per month for it. iPhone could have been put on airplane mode to disable GPS. With bluetooth still on, pacemaker keeps synching.

 

[Napoli]

Anyine think its possible they were informed shes deceased and they want her body returned and are willing to pay to get body back. This video seemed more somber. Anyone??? Celebrate= celebration of life service as many religious people call a funeral

i did notice savannah was wearing a black shirt, if that means anything.......

 

[MassGuy]

What is your thinking for how the ransom writer, if not the same person involved in her disappearance, knew the mentioned sensitive details about the crime, like about the destroyed flood light and watch location?

I mean, it all depends on if this person couldn't possibly have known those things. Like my opinion completely changes if this person knew something they couldn't possibly know.

The first picture I ever saw of Nancy was here wearing an Apple Watch on the today set. So this person could have said it was near her nightstand.

Some people have said they could see a busted light from news coverage.

So what other details did they provide? That's what I'd need to know.

This ransom thing appears to have been an afterthought, so I think it is unrelated, or an effort to deflect.

Only one person really would need a deflection like that, but it's incredibly hard to do with law enforcement scrutiny.

 

[armchairagatha]

There is a slightly positive explanation if AG is involved. What if AG and her husband were resentful that they had responsibility for her old mom while SG was free and rich and famous. They may have felt they were owed something in that scenario. A part of SG’s fortune as ransom. In this scenario, NG is alive - they are just hiding her to make it look like a kidnapping. They may not have expected this case to blow up like it has. If AG is involved, I hope it is something like this and NG is recovered alive.

 

[Marzipan]

For clarity: If they are currently treating AG's house as a crime scene (or at the least, investigating it now) what would be the purpose of including her in the two videos asking for Nancy's release? Is there any precedence here?

Kyron Horman’s stepmother in similar videos. She (Terri Moulton) was never charged but is the defacto suspect.
Ughh. Not only have I said it is not SIL, but I have not WANTED it to be him or AG. Still hoping tonight’s events mean something else, but see I may have been wrong. Whatever happens this will be solved.

 

[acutename]

Could have been opened and closed remotely via cell phone. So possibly when all were still at AG’s.

if she wasn't actually there, did they take her blood and drip on the front porch? that is- sorry- insane. And how did her car get damaged? Is that why she took an Uber? this case has more oddities daily.

 

[MassGuy]

Not all Apple Watches have cell capability-- some models rely on connection to iPhone for that. The ones that do have that capability you have to pay like $15 extra per month for it. iPhone could have been put on airplane mode to disable GPS. With bluetooth still on, pacemaker keeps synching.

And any funny business like that would likewise cause issues. Her devices are phone as she's traveling to her in-laws, and then there's a massive change before she supposedly gets home.

So either way you game this out, it's quick exposure.