AZ Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[submarine7]

.

No offense, but is she a typical stalker's type? She's neither a singer nor a star. People can get obsessed with anyone, but i imagine her audience being of a different type. Am I missing something?
Are we sure it's her and not money?

Tbf David Letterman had a stalker. You never know with that type of nutter.

 

[shonyakay]

I do not claim to be any sort of forensics expert, and I certainly think that LE and the FBI have their reasons, but wouldn't you think that the front porch Mat would be in some sort of evidence? I mean, like everything else, it is too late, but the perp was obviously standing on it. Like someone else mentioned, he could have drooled while using the flashlight. Couldn't his shoes have fibers or something from his house/car that may have possibly been left behind? That is stuff that can be compared to a potential perps actual home/car after they've been caught. Not to mention that there is a good chance there was blood on it. Maybe they just did a luminol test on site and figured that it wasn't important.

The only thing that I can think of why they didn't take the doormat is they might have assumed that it had tons of DNA from various individuals' shoes and maybe that made it an unlikely item to collect and test. Just a thought.

I do believe that they still should have collected it though.

They didn't collect the branches in Delphi at first because they said the type of surface made it difficult to test.

 

[No it's not]

Here is a link from Pima County with the Property Record for NG’s property, if anyone is interested:

https://www.asr.pima.gov/ParcelData/prc/10810/0960.pdf

Cheers,
Nin

And this is the Pima County GIS map. You can select different layers of information of which one is the parcel code. With that you can access all recorded information here:

Pictometry Aerial Photos

With the parcel code you can now access properties here:

Pima County - Parcel Detail

Cheers,
Nin

 

[slowpoke]

Earlier I was talking about the marks seen in the driveway.

Picture source: Page Six

View attachment 646699

“She couldn’t walk 50 yards by herself,” Nanos said at the news conference, noting that while Nancy Guthrie had mobility issues because of her age, she had no cognitive issues.

https://www.azcentral.com/story/news/local/arizona-breaking/2026/02/02/savannah-guthrie-mom-missing-tucson/88470747007/

On the website Calc maps I put in a travel of Nancy that line up with the marks and go to where the marks stop.

It is exactly 50 yards.

View attachment 646700

Map Distance calculator, Google Maps Distance Calculator

Use the distance calculator map to find the distance between multiple points along a line. Map distance calculator is a simple tool that allows you to draw a line on a map and measure the distance.

www.calcmaps.com

I am not claiming that this is what happened, or that the drag marks are from Nancy, only that it is a possibility.

Well, unless the investigators missed those tracks, the sheriff replied no to a reporter asking about footprints or tire tracks at an early press conference.

Post in thread 'Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026'
AZ - Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

 

[tricia]

WE ONLY NEED 4 MORE PEOPLE TO SIGN UP TO BE A GUARDIAN TO MEET OUR GOAL OF 100 NEW MEMBERSHIPS.
Remember, you can gift a Guardian membership.
CLICK HERE for more details.
Thank you for keeping Websleuths strong AND ad-free
Tricia

 

[Katrinepa]

.

No offense, but is she a typical stalker's type? She's neither a singer nor a star. People can get obsessed with anyone, but i imagine her audience being of a different type. Am I missing something?
Are we sure it's her and not money?

Look at the freak that stalked Jodie Foster, or the one who stalked and killed John Lennon. Plenty of obsessed types out there. Forensic Psychologists have a field day analyzing them. Dr. Ann Burgess in MA, and Dr. Gary Brucato in NY , work together on many cases and have written books on characteristics, what to look for ...

 

[shonyakay]

Well, unless the investigators missed those tracks, the sheriff replied no to a reporter asking about footprints or tire tracks at an early press conference.

Post in thread 'Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026'
AZ - Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

With respect, those aren't foot prints or tire tracks. They are two lines that look like something or someone was dragged through there.

 

[lohrtabitha]

Not for us to decide, and the reason they don't have lights all over is they confuse wildlife, especially birds. Very sad, but in somewhat isolated, overall calm areas, crime will eventually rear its ugly head. Certainly, all this attention will bring all kinds to the neighborhood. Hoping for the best outcome for all, especially the family.

It may not be for us to decide but it is very much up to the voting citizens there to decide. There has been updates in lighting technology such as sheilds to be put over street lights where they beam down and not up. It is common sense that more violent crime takes place at dark. Star gazing and wildlife can be protected and more importantly the AZ citizens if the right technology is sourced. IMO

Tucson, Pima County Consider Changes To Outdoor Lighting Code - AZPM

news.azpm.org

 

[K9Enzo]

With respect, those aren't foot prints or tire tracks. They are two lines that look like something or someone was dragged through there.

I wonder if NG took her trash to the curb, if not, who did for her? IMO

 

[Toroba]

I know we can beat the APS horse to death, but my hope is the call was investigated beyond "neighbor phoned in to report missing person." Who knows if Nancy may have confided something in her prior to her disappearance and that was the real motivation behind the call.

I’ve seen different things posted about adult protective services and I was wondering if anyone has ever thought about the fact that someone called them on her as way of getting her out of her house or to somehow make her family look bad.

My grandparents were a lot like her. In their 80s, with limited mobility, and lived in a house that was far too big for them to take care of. They would not leave for various reasons that they never explained. They had a nosy neighbour that complained to APS they were being neglected and that triggered a visit from a social worker who determined they were not fit to live in their home and that was the catalyst for them moving into a home.

They had to sell their house and a lot of people in the area with relatives who were looking for a home or we’re looking to relocate to the area to be closer to family were interested in it… assuming they could get it at a very discounted price. The nosy neighbour also made it a point to tell anyone who would listen how terrible her children were because they wouldn’t help my grandparents with cooking, cleaning, etc.

 

[SaraSmile]

There are benefits, if one is being realistic. A poster laid out a compelling overview many many pages ago.

You have cheap and accessible medical care and medicine (many Americans go over the border to buy drugs and steroids at unregulated pharmacies). Easy to find a female older caretaker for an elderly medically compromised woman. You have a cultural concept of no snitching and minding your business much more so, local police and political corruption, bribes, far less regulation and surveillance state. You have far less heat and investigation on you and jurisdictional and resource complications. Much easier to lay low and disappear overall.

As I said, 1,000s of Americans cross over and back every day. Border towns have many dual nationals and it's much more casual and in some areas less monitored than most think.

JMO, agreed, you are right about the no snitching culture. That could stop people from turning in.

Agreed, about extra layer bringing a perp back to USA, but it’s really not a big hurdle at all. My experience with CA criminals that were recently caught( all found in Rosario Beach), when caught, brought back to USA, it’s only an extra day or two at most, have to send US Marshalls to escort across border. Of course more bureaucracy, but it’s not a long process. US and MX work together on border crossing criminals.

Re Meds, yes, I am aware of meds in Mexico, easy access. Sadly, I don’t think NG is alive, so meds not necessary.

I can see a criminal heading to Mexico , thinking they are going to enjoy freedom there. If they go
way south, better chance of hiding. Think of Ryan Wedding, 10 years( of course he had cartel helping protect him). Others have gone deep into s MX and avoided capture longer than along N border.

all JMO

 

[tbgo]

I am surprised they left the mat. That mat was not a random object. It's a primary contact surface. To counter my comment, they probably fully documented the mat with photos and swabs. IMO

I have heard this brought up before. It’s odd that they didn’t collect it.

 

[shonyakay]

I wonder if NG took her trash to the curb, if not, who did for her? IMO

Great question.

 

[Katrinepa]

Not for us to decide, and the reason they don't have lights all over is they confuse wildlife, especially birds. Very sad, but in somewhat isolated, overall calm areas, crime will eventually rear its ugly head. Certainly, all this attention will bring all kinds to the neighborhood. Hoping for the best outcome for all, especially the family.

I have heard this brought up before. It’s odd that they didn’t collect it.

Well, the Sheriff has bungled much...Those doing the collection should have known better. IMO

 

[moonglow123]

I do not claim to be any sort of forensics expert, and I certainly think that LE and the FBI have their reasons, but wouldn't you think that the front porch Mat would be in some sort of evidence? I mean, like everything else, it is too late, but the perp was obviously standing on it. Like someone else mentioned, he could have drooled while using the flashlight. Couldn't his shoes have fibers or something from his house/car that may have possibly been left behind? That is stuff that can be compared to a potential perps actual home/car after they've been caught. Not to mention that there is a good chance there was blood on it. Maybe they just did a luminol test on site and figured that it wasn't important.

Odd they left the lantana behind too.

Yes, in normal circumstances you'd assume it was blown there by the wind or something. But NOT when you're at a crime scene, it's directly under the door and right next to the blood droplets. I would've assumed it would be procedure to at least grab it for evidence.

When this case first broke and Brian showed us the door/blood droplets, I saw people comment on the lantana and what it was doing there. If WS can notice it just from photos, surprised LE didn't. Not knocking on LE, I'm just curious what their thought process was at first.

 

[tbgo]

JMO, agreed, you are right about the no snitching culture. That could stop people from turning in.

Agreed, about extra layer bringing a perp back to USA, but it’s really not a big hurdle at all. My experience with CA criminals that were recently caught( all found in Rosario Beach), when caught, brought back to USA, it’s only an extra day or two at most, have to send US Marshalls to escort across border. Of course more bureaucracy, but it’s not a long process. US and MX work together on border crossing criminals.

Re Meds, yes, I am aware of meds in Mexico, easy access. Sadly, I don’t think NG is alive, so meds not necessary.

I can see a criminal heading to Mexico , thinking they are going to enjoy freedom there. If they go
way south, better chance of hiding. Think of Ryan Wedding, 10 years( of course he had cartel helping protect him). Others have gone deep into s MX and avoided capture longer than along N border.

all JMO

It is bringing back memories of the McStay family and the belief that they went to Mexico. I understand why they’re checking out that theory but my gut tells me she’s still in the US. The perp, however, may have fled. Unfortunately, they don’t know who they’re actually looking for. I wonder if they can look at records of who crossed the board the day she vanished or a day later. That could take forever. They’d have to track down people living in Mexico or tourists who could live anywhere in the US.

 

[SaraSmile]

It may not be for us to decide but it is very much up to the voting citizens there to decide. There has been updates in lighting technology such as sheilds to be put over street lights where they beam down and not up. It is common sense that more violent crime takes place at dark. Star gazing and wildlife can be protected and more importantly the AZ citizens if the right technology is sourced. IMO

Tucson, Pima County Consider Changes To Outdoor Lighting Code - AZPM

news.azpm.org

We have “dark sky” here( CA), but it does not seems as dark as NGs neighborhood, maybe not as strict.
In my area, I think people who already had lighting in place, could leave it, still use. new construction ( after the ordinance started) had to specify downlighting only.

I know a neighboring house, for Sale for 2 years, they constantly leave the lights on, very bright, no consequences.

I don’t think they issue tickets here for too much light, it’s up to each individual to do the right thing to try to maintain a dark sky.

JMO

 

[cait2007]

I wonder if NG took her trash to the curb, if not, who did for her? IMO

Based on looking up her address on google earth, I don’t believe the trash can would be dragged through that spot. The trash is most likely kept near the garage and brought to the entrance of the driveway. The photo shown shows the driveway exit based on where the garage is.

 

[SaraSmile]

It is bringing back memories of the McStay family and the belief that they went to Mexico. I understand why they’re checking out that theory but my gut tells me she’s still in the US. The perp, however, may have fled.

Agreed.

 

[shonyakay]

When was this picture taken? The foot traffic must have been significant since the scene was released the first time (3x total) and pizza guys and pool cleaners were walking and driving since then. The night of the SWAT raids Tucson had some decent rain as well.

I initially wondered if they tested tire tracks/soil samples seeing the type of driveway it was and assuming he'd pull the car up out of sight, but at some point after the scene was released and there was so much foot traffic that scene was cooked.

On February 2, 2026 when the scene was still a sealed off crime scene by LE before they first released it those lines were visible.