Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[SRWCF]

Yes perhaps. I still don't think he did it, because I also can't imagine the perp bringing this kind of attention to himself. I just think it was a bad decision by LD

I don't think so either. Simply because he has a criminal felony record, so we know his DNA is in CODIS and the FBI was unable to find a match to the unknown DNA discovered in NG's home.

 

[TIGER0822]

What is it?

Please! Pass along your moo!!

 

[Napoli]

How do you suppose LD and that Rio Rico guy were selected to be swat teamed and rounded up? Probably some "concerned citizen" with a tip. What made their tip stand apart from the 20,000 other tips? I see a cautionary tale here. Even if you "think" your Uncle Ralph is the perp because underneath 3 layers of disguise the porch guy kinda looks like him and you dont know where Uncle Ralph was January 31, it produces chaos, diverts assets, and can ruin someone's life. LD giving an interview makes me think he was damned if he did and damned if he didn't.

No doubt in my mind, someone has already called in the name of the right person. The name is lost in the pile. We, the well meaning public, still can't do the work for LE. How specific can a person calling in be? Absent seeing your cousin Joe's bloody sneakers, every call is only "impression". LE doesnt want theory or "he looks like thus and so, the guy who works at the convenience store. So, what's a person to do?

After 2 alpha male, guns a blazing, sirens blaring, black cars converging and helicopters circling spectacles that were apparently fruitless, what next?

I don't think it's fair for the media to hound LD or deride the mom. This is what "well meaning, overzealous tipsters" created. I don't have an answer but this is my observation and I hope LE is going to be a lot more discerning before they pounce again.. JMO

 

[Eli9]

Oh wow, I had not heard that. I have followed the JBR case since it happened. And I have done a fair amount of amateur analysis on various aspects of the case. I keep being reminded of JBR lately.

Some names/phrases seem to grow legs on line IYKWIM. I'm still hopeful, until I sense it going cold. Our complicated or clumsy porch guy needs to be caught if he is still out there. Sadly, it's been too long for NG I'm afraid. JMOO

 

[SMK777]

How do you suppose LD and that Rio Rico guy were selected to be swat teamed and rounded up? Probably some "concerned citizen" with a tip. What made their tip stand apart from the 20,000 other tips? I see a cautionary tale here. Even if you "think" your Uncle Ralph is the perp because underneath 3 layers of disguise the porch guy kinda looks like him and you dont know where Uncle Ralph was January 31, it produces chaos, diverts assets, and can ruin someone's life. LD giving an interview makes me think he was damned if he did and damned if he didn't.

No doubt in my mind, someone has already called in the name of the right person. The name is lost in the pile. We can't do the work for LE. How specific can a person calling in be? Absent seeing your cousin Joe's bloody sneakers, every call is only "impression". LE doesnt want theory or "he locks like thus and so, the guy who works at the convenience store. So, what's a person to do?

After 2 alpha male, guns a blazing, sirens blaring, black cars converging and helicopters circling spectacles that were apparently fruitless, what next?

I don't think it's fair for the media to hound LD or deride the mom. This is what "well meaning, overzealous tipsters" created. I don't have an answer but this is my observation and I hope LE is going to be a lot more discerning before they pounce again.. JMO

Agree with all.

And I can recall a few true crime books I read in the past, where the right person was tipped in but got lost in the pile.

Let's hope that name will resurface soon.

 

[cherryleaf]

Is this the point where we all turn to acknowledge the really nasty elephant in the room, the biggest 'career ending/dampening mis-conduct' story of the 21st century?

We know SG has not been working due to surgery in December, but we've also seen an explosion of that nasty story in the last three months, and we're in the very earliest stages of reprecussion, with resignations starting to flutter down like the first leaves of fall. Any interviews or investigative reporting SG did on that story is already out there, maybe scheduled to be re-aired, maybe not. Maybe the point wasn't to silence *her*, as much as send a warning to other journalists who might be considering joining the elephant hunt?

Dropping in to just post something related to this angle. I admit what I’m posting, well it’s a bit of a stretch but, you never know.

Giuffre
Guthrie
Spelling is close. Did someone get something mixed up? IMO Giuffre didn't kill herself, she was systematically taken care of.

Virginia Giuffre - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

SG interview of Giuffre

FULL EPISODE: Reckoning

In her first network television interview, Virginia Roberts Giuffre talks about getting introduced to Jeffrey Epstein and his world of abuse when she was just a teenager.

www.nbcnews.com

I can't be the only one who thinks he looks a bit too... chunky to be the perp, right? JMO

dropping into say I’m not sure of the perps weight other than average build. Imo, LD doesn’t appear to have that much extra weight compared to the perp.. given the slight fish eye kinda angle of the video..( it’s hard to tell) but I do notice a few things that stand out to me. I am NOT implying anything other than this…
All available pictures of LD ONLINE prior to NG disappearance he has a beard and a mustache, sometimes stubble, slightly grown in, sometimes a little more. He’s cleanly shaven in this interview. Maybe trying to appear more clean cut. Maybe not and wanted to alter his appearance a bit.

His haircut in the interview, imo is also fresh and recent, which I understand, he’s trying to appear a bit more “professional” for lack of a better word. It would be harder to tell if he had lighter hair. Dark hair makes it very obvious.

His use of the term “hive mind” is a tad aggravating to me. He’s implying people pointed fingers at him and alerted LE because of how he lived his life in the past and his vicinity to NG,… and maybe they did, …but You don’t get a federal warrant issued on the home you live in and vehicle seized because of past drug arrest at Walmart.

Not once does he ever offer any type of empathy to the family. Just, “if I knew I would say so” …”it’s not me, I don’t see the resemblance”…I want Nancy to come home too but I don’t have anything to do with it” …kind of deal.

Not once does he say, he understands the public’s focus on him because of his past. He doesn’t own up or imply any understanding of the past transgressions that some people are questioning. Just “hive mind”

Also ask yourself what 40+’year old man has his mom at a interview with them…unless there’s some type of disability or neurodivergence or something going on, it’s not normal for her to be present in this particular interview. I know it’s her home that SWAT busted into but still, a 40 yr old man with his mom at an interview “clearing his name” is a huge red flag to me.

Does that make him the perp, idk. But after hearing him talk I don’t personally like his demeanor, ..whatever, that’s on me. Moo

FYI, my son is autistic so if LD is actually neurodivergent or disabled
In some way I would understand his mothers presence a bit better.

 

[Miss Poovy]

So glad her husband was with her, not only to support her but to show the public he isn't hiding out somewhere. All the people complaining about not seeing him support them and also them not visiting the memorial site, like how do people know they haven't visited it? They may have gone many times before and after media had come and gone for the day. I hope people don't give SG their opinions on her leaving to go home when she does. I don't think any of them can make everyone happy. If she goes back too soon "how could she, how heartless" and if she stays gone longer they would have something to say about that as well. I have yet to meet a perfect person and people need to leave them alone and let them do it their way.

I think that would be weird to criticize SG for returning home. Folks mention her job, but she also has children & she’s been away from them for over a month.

 

[moonglow123]

How do you suppose LD and that Rio Rico guy were selected to be swat teamed and rounded up? Probably some "concerned citizen" with a tip. What made their tip stand apart from the 20,000 other tips? I see a cautionary tale here. Even if you "think" your Uncle Ralph is the perp because underneath 3 layers of disguise the porch guy kinda looks like him and you dont know where Uncle Ralph was January 31, it produces chaos, diverts assets, and can ruin someone's life. LD giving an interview makes me think he was damned if he did and damned if he didn't.

No doubt in my mind, someone has already called in the name of the right person. The name is lost in the pile. We, the well meaning public, still can't do the work for LE. How specific can a person calling in be? Absent seeing your cousin Joe's bloody sneakers, every call is only "impression". LE doesnt want theory or "he looks like thus and so, the guy who works at the convenience store. So, what's a person to do?

After 2 alpha male, guns a blazing, sirens blaring, black cars converging and helicopters circling spectacles that were apparently fruitless, what next?

I don't think it's fair for the media to hound LD or deride the mom. This is what "well meaning, overzealous tipsters" created. I don't have an answer but this is my observation and I hope LE is going to be a lot more discerning before they pounce again.. JMO

Yeah. Sad, but seems they may have just detained LD based on tip + him being most prolific criminal in her neighborhood, versus concrete evidence tying him to the crime. And C just based on tip + phone pings. I don't blame LE, they're trying to find Nancy and get this crime solved, but I don't think either of them is the guy now. Of course, I may be wrong.

I hate that whoever it is is still going free and I really do hope his name is lost in the tips somewhere, waiting to be found.

 

[Trish51]

When he said he went to his friend's house and sat on their patio, I was like WRONG ANSWER

That being said, you could definitely tell that he was nervous, and he openly admitted that. I have no idea what to make of him to be honest.

MOO.

Agree! I thought something similar. Add in the contradictions and I’m not so sure about him.

 

[Eli9]

How do you suppose LD and that Rio Rico guy were selected to be swat teamed and rounded up? Probably some "concerned citizen" with a tip. What made their tip stand apart from the 20,000 other tips? I see a cautionary tale here. Even if you "think" your Uncle Ralph is the perp because underneath 3 layers of disguise the porch guy kinda looks like him and you dont know where Uncle Ralph was January 31, it produces chaos, diverts assets, and can ruin someone's life. LD giving an interview makes me think he was damned if he did and damned if he didn't.

No doubt in my mind, someone has already called in the name of the right person. The name is lost in the pile. We, the well meaning public, still can't do the work for LE. How specific can a person calling in be? Absent seeing your cousin Joe's bloody sneakers, every call is only "impression". LE doesnt want theory or "he looks like thus and so, the guy who works at the convenience store. So, what's a person to do?

After 2 alpha male, guns a blazing, sirens blaring, black cars converging and helicopters circling spectacles that were apparently fruitless, what next?

I don't think it's fair for the media to hound LD or deride the mom. This is what "well meaning, overzealous tipsters" created. I don't have an answer but this is my observation and I hope LE is going to be a lot more discerning before they pounce again.. JMO

Agree with all.

And I can recall a few true crime books I read in the past, where the right person was tipped in but got lost in the pile.

Let's hope that name will resurface soon.

I remember calling in a tip in the Bryce Laspisa case. Reached a deputy, spoke with him, gave my info and the case I was referring to and was thanked personally. It led to nothing obviously as he has not been found but I found out from the deputy their unidentified was older that BL.

In large cases such as NG and even in the general public I would be willing to bet that many citizens would be interested in becoming tip vetting volunteers. The online crime community is huge. Offer some training and get your community involved in validating and placing a hierarchy on tips that are submitted. IDK??

 

[cherryleaf]

It's interesting that when he was pulled over he says he thought, 'oh this must be about the Nancy Guthrie case.' Why would he think that? If I were pulled over by sheriffs deputies and detained I would think, 'they must have me mixed up with someone else!'

100 percent and I was just gonna edit my previous post to say that. Have a great night

 

[SMK777]

It's interesting that when he was pulled over he says he thought, 'oh this must be about the Nancy Guthrie case.' Why would he think that? If I were pulled over by sheriffs deputies and detained I would think, 'they must have me mixed up with someone else!'

On the other hand, when I lived in New Jersey in the 1980s there was a big case in the news where a couple of young women had been killed in close proximity on different nights. Police and state troopers were pulling cars over for random spot checks, and most assumed it was related to the case in the news.

 

[Sakura2Sophia4Lucia]

It's interesting that when he was pulled over he says he thought, 'oh this must be about the Nancy Guthrie case.' Why would he think that? If I were pulled over by sheriffs deputies and detained I would think, 'they must have me mixed up with someone else!'

Bizarre and actually quite interesting that he thought he was pulled over for something about NG's case. JMO

 

[shonyakay]

I had to rewatch LD’s interview again. He contradicted himself a little in regards to his past. Did anyone else notice that?

The one instance he says over two years and the next one he says 1 1/2 years ago with the alleged gf, the girl he got arrested with a little over a year ago. We can’t mention her here, I believe. He does talk about her though.

ADMIN NOTE:

Members may discuss what has been said about them in MSM and LE or what they themselves have said in MSM, but sleuthing out their personal details (i.e. address, criminal records, business associations, friends, etc etc) is not allowed.

LD is up for reasonable discussion as he was in fact detained in the SWAT deployment but subsequently released. Obviously he was a person of interest, and has not been publicly cleared by LE. He can still be discussed within reason, and bear in mind that his lawyer has stated (paraphrased by me) that LD had no involvement in Nancy's disappearance.

KD has not been detained or treated by LE as a POI in this case, so casting aspersions, making direct or indirect accusations her way, regardless of her relationship within the family or to LD, is not allowed.

Some of their criminal records were shared by Fox News. I guess we can share MSM articles but we can't personally sleuth them out ourselves. At least for the time being since they haven't been listed as a POI, Suspect, nor have been charged in relation to this case.

Arizona man detained in SWAT operation denies link to Nancy Guthrie abduction

Two Tucson ex-cons face online scrutiny in Nancy Guthrie case despite no official accusations. Luke Daley detained in SWAT raid, released without charges.

www.foxnews.com

 

[Cassie P]

Some names/phrases seem to grow legs on line IYKWIM. I'm still hopeful, until I sense it going cold. Our complicated or clumsy porch guy needs to be caught if he is still out there. Sadly, it's been too long for NG I'm afraid. JMOO

Yes. Justice for JB means understanding what happened to her. The same for NG.

 

[Sakura2Sophia4Lucia]

The LD interview makes no sense. The news about this case is quieting down, everyone is distracted with the war, LE has gone quiet, and the public scrutiny of LD is fading.

IMO, MOO, LD's interview was either really bad advice, or an attempt to get out ahead of things. Why put him back in the spotlight?

Your average good attorney wouldn't want their client -- whose house a SWAT team searched -- being interviewed about this experience. He's technically still a suspect. Unbelievable.

Perhaps the attorney thought that he'd come across as somebody not capable of this crime and the interview would cause people to lose interest in him. Makes no sense to me.

JMO

 

[SlimPickens]

Totally agree, 400 FBI was a bad look. I think the FBI thought they would swoop in, solve case, save the day! But since it’s dragged on, I’m glad they went back to Phoenix. I’m sure the Sheriff or FBI will solve this over time. JMO

I disagree on the FBI's motive, but totally understand how that could be the prevailing notion at this point. I sway back and forth on motive and 'local yokel vs. organized and from wherever', but this has many of the components of being a big crime that likely warrants that many agents. Not a big crime because of who the victim's daughter is, but big because of who or even perhaps what the perpetrator(s) might be.

JMO.

 

[Cryptic]

How do you suppose LD and that Rio Rico guy were selected to be swat teamed and rounded up? Probably some "concerned citizen" with a tip. What made their tip stand apart from the 20,000 other tips?

Apparently, the Rio Rico guy(s), had a general resemblance to the video , but one was also a delivery driver who had made deliveries at least in the area, and maybe closer. There may of been other supporting information that was not made public ( its a high burden of proof to search a home).

 

[Napoli]

DBM

 

[SlimPickens]

How do you suppose LD and that Rio Rico guy were selected to be swat teamed and rounded up? Probably some "concerned citizen" with a tip. What made their tip stand apart from the 20,000 other tips? I see a cautionary tale here. Even if you "think" your Uncle Ralph is the perp because underneath 3 layers of disguise the porch guy kinda looks like him and you dont know where Uncle Ralph was January 31, it produces chaos, diverts assets, and can ruin someone's life. LD giving an interview makes me think he was damned if he did and damned if he didn't.

No doubt in my mind, someone has already called in the name of the right person. The name is lost in the pile. We, the well meaning public, still can't do the work for LE. How specific can a person calling in be? Absent seeing your cousin Joe's bloody sneakers, every call is only "impression". LE doesnt want theory or "he looks like thus and so, the guy who works at the convenience store. So, what's a person to do?

After 2 alpha male, guns a blazing, sirens blaring, black cars converging and helicopters circling spectacles that were apparently fruitless, what next?

I don't think it's fair for the media to hound LD or deride the mom. This is what "well meaning, overzealous tipsters" created. I don't have an answer but this is my observation and I hope LE is going to be a lot more discerning before they pounce again.. JMO

Profiled as latino men of average build living in a home with strong maternal figures, and who perhaps have a recent criminal record and drive silver compact SUVs? That's about all I can deduce. (LD is listed as Latino in court/police records. He is adopted from what I've read).