- Joined
- Nov 11, 2013
- Messages
- 13,534
- Reaction score
- 89,186
From Linda7NJ in the now-closed thread:
Interesting thought experiment - made me think.
It would affect my overall regard of JR but it wouldn't change my belief that he needs to be removed from the community. Some research indicates a correlation between frontal lobe injuries and acquired sociopathy while other studies conclude that the evidence is too weak.
As for the DP, a lot would hinge on whether or not the damage is repairable in his case. If not, then he poses an ongoing lethal threat to prison personnel and other inmates and I'd accept death as a reasonable solution. If it is repairable, I'd be willing to consider LWOP as long as there was solid, incontrovertible supporting evidence.
It's moot in JR's case anyway, because he showed indications of awareness that he got himself in trouble, removing the possibility that he had no control whatsoever over his actions. Plus, such extreme violent behavior would have landed him in jail (or dead) a long time before he met HR and Teghan.
Aw hell, just burn him. Grr. :furious:
I'd love them to get MRIs of this guys brain... Before he's executed
My money is on frontal lobe damage.
Would that make a difference to any of you regarding your personal feelings about him?
For me it doesn't. He's still defective and needs to be put down like a rabid dog. For him as much as us.
He would be equal to the rabid dog where as I thought less of him than the dog.
Interesting thought experiment - made me think.
It would affect my overall regard of JR but it wouldn't change my belief that he needs to be removed from the community. Some research indicates a correlation between frontal lobe injuries and acquired sociopathy while other studies conclude that the evidence is too weak.
As for the DP, a lot would hinge on whether or not the damage is repairable in his case. If not, then he poses an ongoing lethal threat to prison personnel and other inmates and I'd accept death as a reasonable solution. If it is repairable, I'd be willing to consider LWOP as long as there was solid, incontrovertible supporting evidence.
It's moot in JR's case anyway, because he showed indications of awareness that he got himself in trouble, removing the possibility that he had no control whatsoever over his actions. Plus, such extreme violent behavior would have landed him in jail (or dead) a long time before he met HR and Teghan.
Aw hell, just burn him. Grr. :furious: