- Joined
- Jan 24, 2024
- Messages
- 1,747
- Reaction score
- 12,669
Totally agreed on the isotope analysis issue in terms of testing for actual human beings, there's no way I trust it. In any case I look at it, but warily, jmo.Sort of suspicious that it matches the isotope analysis, lol. That is proof that this may be a made up identification.
I mean, possible she may be identified by now and european LE is very slow to confirm identification but isotopes are and were very regularly wrong.
jmoo
I'm reading, though, that isotope analysis on an inanimate object can be considerably more accurate as there are fewer variables involved. So I really am wondering if isotope analysis on her jewelry might yield some reliable information. Based on what I saw, they could even perform it for costume jewelry.
I'd say "some information is better than no information," but I won't. Because agreed the isotope analysis is notoriuosly unrelaible with human beings, and bad information is worse than none at all sometimes, jmo. So unless it were confirmed this isotope testing's more reliable with something like a piece of jewelry, it seems as dubious as the full isotope testing of an actual human being.
Apologies on misleading anyone, I totally agree with this, with what you just said I think that's an older piece of jewelry both in its manufacture/craftsmanship and design. And think the earrings are Ottoman rose design. Now, is the earring design kind of "timeless," because @Sor Juana mentioned the Mumbai pieces... where someone could come by something "like that" (the earrings) in the 60s and incorporate it into the swinging groovy outfit overall? Possibly. But IW doesn't have anything particularly hip or groovy on that day jmo, and I don't see anything hip or groovy about either the ring or earrings by themselves. They look old school, old world, and conservative. I'm guessing Ottoman rose style jewelry/southeast Europe. Turkey/Romania/Slovenia (?), picture that jewelry in line with someone in tune with Istanbul or Bucharest, but there's so, so much speculation about where IW came from.While I love your analysis I have to say that the ring strikes me as rather Viking-like with a cruel streak. More goth than hippie to me. Right down my alley.
Looking at the original picture it is also clear the stone is quite unsymmetrical- the stone is not perfect - which makes me think it’s custom made.
And agreed, I think that ring is much older and quite possibly the earrings as well, I don't think there's anything hippie chic about it in and of itself. But at the same time, have to agree that this Ottoman rose design with the earrings-- it's sort of classic and timeless. But again, that aside, when I look at IW's ring, I am getting old world vibes for sure, and my guess is the pieces are older, but jmo. And that ring looks large and heavy, which is channeling "older" in my mind, but again, jmo. And while I definitely get stylish from IW's overall ensemble that day, I'm in no way getting "hippie."
Last edited: