Found Deceased NY - Joseph Comunale, 26, Manhattan, 12 Nov 2016 #1 *Arrests*

[Anonymous123]

I was reading the internet clippings on this case and I believe the new suspect was brought in because James was telling the truth and he may have been misidentified on the surveillance video. GM said he changed from his clothes into some clothes of James Rackovers! Those watching the tape may have saw the clothes, hair, and assumed it was him. Rackover said he came down at 7am from Jeffrey's and went in his room to bed. The girls and guys left. The video showed Dilion and Comunale arriving together in the morning. Either GM and Dilione killed Comunale or Dilion did and called his friend over to clean it up and discard of body.

I think they are framing James!

Sorry but MG and JR look nothing alike. Different build, different coloring. Even basic security footage could see that.

I would definitely not be quick to think JR is the innocent one out of all three. In my opinion he is a seasoned criminal just lying and denying. His lawyer is Mr. Sercarz who is named among the best criminal defense lawyers in New York in the “Super Lawyers,” and he has received the AV rating from Martindale-Hubbell. He has been elected a Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers (an honor limited to only 1% of the attorneys in America).

So whose paying his lawyer bill again?

And yes didn't they report JR was the one asking for luggage, how long security tapes exist-- although I believe they wound up manipulating the cameras in the basement anyway- and the one driving the body to the burial place. But yeah he didn't even see the victim. Sure.

 

[Dogface]

Wow what a twisted, sad case.

On a side note, I have a friend who looks very similar to JR, ie young, handsome, tattooed. He moved to New York to pursue modeling and arts, moved in affluent circles. But very much so a good, kindhearted person. After he abruptly left NYC for SAN Diego, I was speaking to him and asking him why the sudden move, he described his experience in New York as seeming so beautiful but when the mask was peeled back everything was ugly. He referenced the Kanye West lyric saying "the most beautiful people do the ugliest things". Lots of stories about drugs, married men with young male lovers, said many people would sell a pound of flesh or a bit of their soul for a instagram or Twitter tag from the right person, and so much of it was smoke and mirrors. Not sure how that exactly relates, other than, we shouldn't trust the image of ANY of these players and that the truth may be uglier than we can even imagine.

 

[Momoffourboys]

Sorry but MG and JR look nothing alike. Different build, different coloring. Even basic security footage could see that.

I would definitely not be quick to think JR is the innocent one out of all three. In my opinion he is a seasoned criminal just lying and denying. His lawyer is Mr. Sercarz who is named among the best criminal defense lawyers in New York in the “Super Lawyers,” and he has received the AV rating from Martindale-Hubbell. He has been elected a Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers (an honor limited to only 1% of the attorneys in America).

So whose paying his lawyer bill again?

And yes didn't they report JR was the one asking for luggage, how long security tapes exist-- although I believe they wound up manipulating the cameras in the basement anyway- and the one driving the body to the burial place. But yeah he didn't even see the victim. Sure.

Agreed. MG also doesn't appear to be as tall as JR. LE would have no problem figuring out who it was that asked for the luggage cart and about surveillance footage.

And I, certainly, don't buy MG or JR's statements that everything appeared normal in the apartment. Nope.

 

[Salsa]

Snip

CBS2’s Magdalena Doris reported that witnesses said they saw a man who lived at the apartment building “stuffing garbage bags into his car” after the party was over. The police recovered at least one of the garbage bags and “K-9 dogs found pants and sheets covered in human blood inside.” Doris added that the man who had stuffed the bags into his car “also reportedly asked the doorman about how long video surveillance is kept by management.”

http://cdanews.com/2016/11/son-of-c...d-trump-suspect-in-murder-of-connecticut-man/

MG was called in and the reason and was the only evidence leaked about MG was he had changed into LR's clothes. JR's anger and frustration and confusion of being charged with a murder is many many times the key of what is missing from killers denials and makes them even more suspect.

I am not implying he didn't help discard. I could be very wrong, but it is very odd the charge of murder has reduced and another man never accounted for suddenly is called in, Dilion's buddy.

Not all with past crime are capable of murder as well as look how many with no criminal charges in their life are capable of killing a gf, bf, spouse,.......

I am probably very wrong, but I am not sensing cold blooded with JR, I do see oh " " am I in a dream, what is going on, I am in deep....from Rackover.

Who knew and spent the most time with Comunale to stab him 12 times with such hate and intensity?

This case is very bizarre. I would like to know if any took a lie detector test and the results.

 

[Salsa]

I would like to add a possible scene with the little info that has been released. We now know James was not hanging with this crowd much throughout the evening. He wasn't at the club communicating and developing reasons to have vengeance and and anger toward Comunale. He was up watching movies with Jeffrey while the men and women were partying and crashing at his place (a staple of what Jeffrey had a problem with when James lived with him).

James goes downstairs and crashes in his bedroom, door closed and possibly locked. Dilion and victim return together to residence. If James slept in until really late, passed out tired. Between Dilion, MG (in James clothes), MG, and Comunale, someone murdered the poor boy and stabbed him 12 times. Someone cleaned the blood and mess, disposed of body, took available keys of car and placed body where it was found.

It is possible James came out and felt he had no choice to help get rid of body, or if he slept soundly, woke up later, came out (in back of mind things may have been disorganized, but could be made sense of from partying), and had no idea what took place. Weirder things have happened and this is a really weird case.

 

[Salsa]

Wasn't it James who asked the doorman how long surveillance is kept?

I have to look for the link, but, I remember reading that.

You can buzz or call a doorman, was it someone pretending to be James? What seasoned criminal is going to call his doorman and front desk asking for damning evidence against them, unless it was someone pretending to be him (so the care of doing so was much less).

 

[Salsa]

'Wheeled him out of the building? There was no body.
'There was no dolly. I was never even seen on camera with this kid. I have no idea who he is.
'I can’t explain what happened at all. I didn’t do anything.'
But Rackover fiercely denies this, claiming: 'I have no reason to hurt this kid. I’ve never hurt anyone. I’ve never killed anyone. I didn’t do any of this.'

I may be very very wrong, but this is how an innocent man should react, angry-upset-fiercely denying the charges. Not the usual I am not guilty with no other exclamations or being really quiet, hiding behind a lawyer, not protesting, keeping a low profile= Dilion.

 

[LovelyB]

I would like to add a possible scene with the little info that has been released. We now know James was not hanging with this crowd much throughout the evening. He wasn't at the club communicating and developing reasons to have vengeance and and anger toward Comunale. He was up watching movies with Jeffrey while the men and women were partying and crashing at his place (a staple of what Jeffrey had a problem with when James lived with him).

James goes downstairs and crashes in his bedroom, door closed and possibly locked. Dilion and victim return together to residence. If James slept in until really late, passed out tired. Between Dilion, MG (in James clothes), MG, and Comunale, someone murdered the poor boy and stabbed him 12 times. Someone cleaned the blood and mess, disposed of body, took available keys of car and placed body where it was found.

It is possible James came out and felt he had no choice to help get rid of body, or if he slept soundly, woke up later, came out (in back of mind things may have been disorganized, but could be made sense of from partying), and had no idea what took place. Weirder things have happened and this is a really weird case.

I had posted a similar possible scenario earlier on in the thread, that maybe JR left his apartment open to his friends to party, and went to Jeffrey's to crash... maybe he came into a crime scene later and felt he had to help clean up the scene. Not a smart thing to do if true, but it's a possibility.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Salsa]

I had posted a similar possible scenario earlier on in the thread, that maybe JR left the his apartment open to his friends to party, and went to Jeffrey's to crash... maybe he came into a crime scene later and felt he had to help clean up the scene. Not a smart thing to do if true, but it's a possibility.

I agree. The facts keep changing and now with MG and the, 'change of clothes,' being highlighted into the case, it has more to do with the case then a chnge of clothes to get comfortable. It is possible he did that, but: Where are his original clothes? Were they bloodied and spattered to such an extent he needed to change? The person who stabbed Comunale will be the one with blood spatters on shirt. Was the blood spatter on the original shirt GM wore or the shirt he borrowed? Did the police question James by bringing a blood spattered shirt into the interrogation room and James was Whoa, GM had that shirt on or responded in believable anger he was not wearing that shirt that led to cops to hammering Dilion until the fact MG was wearing the shirt, AND THIS would explain the sudden new suspect being brought in. It is also possible MG's original shirt in the garbage bag had blood all over it and could not be identified. These officers sure have a whodunit? case like the old movie Clue.

 

[Donna7777]

In the beginning Max wasn't even mentioned at being at the club. Could Larry have called him to go to NYC to help. We're just assuming Max helped with the shallow grave but I think Larry could have gotten him out of the car with a lot of effort.

 

[Donna7777]

Wasn't it James who asked the doorman how long surveillance is kept?

I have to look for the link, but, I remember reading that.

I read that also. They might just be assuming it was James when whomever asked for the cart for that apt

 

[Momoffourboys]

Snip

CBS2’s Magdalena Doris reported that witnesses said they saw a man who lived at the apartment building “stuffing garbage bags into his car” after the party was over. The police recovered at least one of the garbage bags and “K-9 dogs found pants and sheets covered in human blood inside.” Doris added that the man who had stuffed the bags into his car “also reportedly asked the doorman about how long video surveillance is kept by management.”

http://cdanews.com/2016/11/son-of-c...d-trump-suspect-in-murder-of-connecticut-man/

@Donna, yes. Anyone could have called. But the above said the same man that stuffed the bags(the man who lived at the apartment bldg) also asked the doorman about the surveillance. So...witnesses.

 

[Donna7777]

I keep forgetting that Joey wasn't found until 16 or 17th They definitely had all day Sunday to do more cleaning. Initially, I strongly remember James saying he and"Daddio" watched football in HIS apt.. Please correct me if i'm wrong

 

[Donna7777]

@Donna, yes. Anyone could have called. But the above said the same man that stuffed the bags(the man who lived at the apartment bldg) also asked the doorman about the surveillance. So...witnesses.

I almost believe James might not have killed him but he can't deny knowing early in that he was dead. Could Larry The Rat have just reversed the roles they each played in this? Imo Larry has a sneaky, gulity look. James looks confused and truly stunned.. Thank God for video cameras, otherwise it would all be hear say with these 3 Stooges. Mo, Larry and Quirky

 

[Salsa]

@Donna, yes. Anyone could have called. But the above said the same man that stuffed the bags(the man who lived at the apartment bldg) also asked the doorman about the surveillance. So...witnesses.

They might have seen a man in James clothes he is known to wear placing stuffed bags and assumed it was him. They did not suspect a murder at these points, the memories may not have been diligent in picking up who is who, just assuming it was the guy who lived in the building. I believe for now that GM and Dilion are more suspect than James. I read a post about a safe but have seen no other reference. Was there a safe in JR's apartment?

 

[Salsa]

I almost believe James might not have killed him but he can't deny knowing early in that he was dead. Could Larry The Rat have just reversed the roles they each played in this? Imo Larry has a sneaky, gulity look. James looks confused and truly stunned.. Thank God for video cameras, otherwise it would all be hear say with these 3 Stooges. Mo, Larry and Quirky

Donna, your reference to Larry as, Larry the Rat, had me LMAO. That was my immediate sense of him while reading the aspects of the case. He is one step ahead of the game, esp. with leading the police to the body. I believe his mind had a few days to manipulate the facts to point toward his friend.

 

[Donna7777]

@Salsa there was a safe wheeled out on yet another luggage cart. No more mention of it anywhere since. Larry may have figured with James backround, he'd just hang the rap on him.. I think he was surprised how quickly they peiced it together. He may have decided to come chean, but only half way. He is in no way smarter than the police or Pat C..

 

[Salsa]

@Salsa there was a safe wheeled out on yet another luggage cart. No more mention of it anywhere since. Larry may have figured with James backround, he'd just hang the rap on him.. I think he was surprised how quickly they peiced it together. He may have decided to come chean, but only half way. He is in no way smarter than the police or Pat C..

I need to read up on the safe later. Any links?

 

[Momoffourboys]

I almost believe James might not have killed him but he can't deny knowing early in that he was dead. Could Larry The Rat have just reversed the roles they each played in this? Imo Larry has a sneaky, gulity look. James looks confused and truly stunned.. Thank God for video cameras, otherwise it would all be hear say with these 3 Stooges. Mo, Larry and Quirky

IMO James is the loose cannon. I will be shocked if he is not the one who stabbed Jc. He seems like a pompus, arrogant, obnoxious, entitled manipulator.
He thinks his "connections" can make this go away. Doubt it and really hope nobody puts up the money for him.

 

[Momoffourboys]

I think you are giving any of these shlubs way too much credit. No one here was smart or a master planner. They are fools. They took away a life and will pay for it with their freedom. Even if they walk out. This will follow them and their families wherever they go. This is not a drug charge or a burglary. They were, in one way or another, involved in Joey's murder.