OH Pike Co., 8 in Rhoden Family Murdered Over Custody Issue, 4 Members Wagner Family Arrested #53

[Merrygirl]

MG, can you please give initials? I find none on PC list that's also on Ross where G4 is. Thanks.

‘I’m sorry, I meant G3. Butler Co.

 

[Merrygirl]

MG, can you please give initials? I find none on PC list that's also on Ross where G4 is. Thanks.

‘I’m sorry, I meant G3. Butler Co.

 

[Loomis124]

‘I’m sorry, I meant G3. Butler Co.

Well, that makes alot more sense. Lol. Of course, half the PC list is at Butler. If you're talking about Rusty, no big surprise there. He was checked out early on and is not a suspect. JMO

Otherwise, need more info as there are lots of names.

 

[Loomis124]

One thing may be significant, or not. CO (initials) is listed on PC inmate list, and he is also listed on AW's Dicovery with all the phones checked by BCI.

 

[Loomis124]

February 27, 2014 is a photo of a cow, but in the back corner by the barn it looks like it could be the red truck. JMO

JMO, that truck looks like a Dodge, and I don't think it's HR's. The Wagners drove Dodge RAMS. If you're speaking of the Red truck in the JM arrest, it was a Chevrolet and looked nothing like this one. JMO

 

[Tiff23fr]

I see it! Could be. She didn't have cows so if that's her truck she drove it over there.

Jake reference:
Love getting pictures of her when she's at her daddy's. Nothing like a ole beagle to be her best friend

JMO, that truck looks like a Dodge, and I don't think it's HR's. The Wagners drove Dodge RAMS. If you're speaking of the Red truck in the JM arrest, it was a Chevrolet. JMO

I didn't think it was hers, but wondered about the Wagners.
However referring back to notes since I made that post I can agree it’s unlikely. It was still registered in Montgomery County during the time window.

 

[Johnny B Bad]

Defiance Farms

 

[Johnny B Bad]

Wh

Defiance Farms

What do you Sleuthers think about these 2 brothers with their hit dyed black on 4-30-2016

 

[Loomis124]

I didn't think it was hers, but wondered about the Wagners.
However referring back to notes since I made that post I can agree it’s unlikely. It was still registered in Montgomery County during the time window.

To the Brooks guy?

 

[Loomis124]

Well, I must be blind. I looked and read through HR's entire Instagram account and never did see the supposed pic of JW with 2 guns threatening HR. Signing off!

 

[Merrygirl]

Well, that makes alot more sense. Lol. Of course, half the PC list is at Butler. If you're talking about Rusty, no big surprise there. He was checked out early on and is not a suspect. JMO

Otherwise, need more info as there are lots of names.

That was the one. I knew he was dismissed early in the investigation but I would like to be a fly on that wall. I’m sure they’re sharing some interesting “war” stories.

 

[Johnny B Bad]

Well, I must be blind. I looked and read through HR's entire Instagram account and never did see the supposed pic of JW with 2 guns threatening HR. Signing off!

Loomis there is no guns on HR instagram, the only time I ever saw a gun was a reply to HR and CG was in a relationship status on FB and then it was only a picture of a gun, nobody was holding it, JMO

 

[Merrygirl]

One thing may be significant, or not. CO (initials) is listed on PC inmate list, and he is also listed on AW's Dicovery with all the phones checked by BCI.

‘I completely missed that one. Lol Guess the other threw me for a loop and I was totally absorbed. I need to check that out. Thanks.

 

[Johnny B Bad]

L

Well, I must be blind. I looked and read through HR's entire Instagram account and never did see the supposed pic of JW with 2 guns threatening HR. Signing off!

Loomis
Did you get my post to open of the picture of George and Jake on 4-30-2016 and both brothers hair was dyed

 

[Merrygirl]

Well, I must be blind. I looked and read through HR's entire Instagram account and never did see the supposed pic of JW with 2 guns threatening HR. Signing off!

I thought I was the only one missing it.

 

[Merrygirl]

L

Loomis
Did you get my post to open of the picture of George and Jake on 4-30-2016 and both brothers hair was dyed

I did. I’ve read a lot about it but now I’ve finally seen it. I definitely think it was part of the plan—camoflage!

 

[OhioBlues]

That was the one. I knew he was dismissed early in the investigation but I would like to be a fly on that wall. I’m sure they’re sharing some interesting “war” stories.

They are not at the same location.

IF they were (which they are not) they would be in separate pods.

BW has to be in the high profile/high risk group.

Jail and Facilities » Butler County Sheriff's Office

 

[Merrygirl]

They are not at the same location.

IF they were (which they are not) they would be in separate pods.

BW has to be in the high profile/high risk group.

Jail and Facilities » Butler County Sheriff's Office

‘Yes he is, your link shows he was booked on 1/9/20. He also shows up on the VINELink as being in Butler. That’s how I made this discovery.

 

[OhioBlues]

‘Yes he is, your link shows he was booked on 1/9/20. He also shows up on the VINELink as being in Butler. That’s how I made this discovery.

Did you look at the 'complete' location of each person?

I don't want to violate TOS by discussing a person not indicted in this case.

One is at one address and one is at the other address.

Butler County Jail - 705 Hanover Street

Butler County Resolutions - 442 S Second Street

This link gives more specific information about locations.
Miami Valley Jails - Persons Currently In Custody

That is completely different locations. NO talking etc could possibly be happening.

 

[StrangeOne]

Agree, but coroners did attend the crime scene and declared the victims of the Rhoden Family Massacre deceased. The first TOD's given were based on those times.

I'm not sure why everyone is discussing this again, it's been discussed dozens of times here and TOD on the death certificates confirmed, along with links to the deposition of the Pike County Coroner. I'm not going to bother to provide links, I've done so dozens of times. Refer to the Case Timeline on page 19 of this thread for information and links.

TIA

ETA: Because it keeps coming up, the next version of the Case Timeline that I publish will include a statement in all bold caps that the first TOD mentioned on death certificates is based on time of discovery and later revised. Will that help?

I am not here everyday but from now on I'll make sure not to ask questions other people have asked.