You are right in the laws eyes he is a child, however I am sure he will be tried as an adult, isn't it funny that the 17 year old soldier is not a child, or the 16 year old mother! We sure have a double standard in this country!:waitasec:
There have been numerous studies that support just the opposite. Teenage frontal lobe development is not only undeveloped , it's actually hindered. Predicting consequences for their actions isn't a given. So knowing "right from wrong" is subjective. With a horrible upbringing.... maybe not.
Here is a comprehensive article from National Geographic that I just read a couple days ago, coincidentally. It explains in very, specific and scientific detail, the teenage brain, and why it is vastly different from the adult brain:
http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2011/10/teenage-brains/dobbs-text
This process of maturation, once thought to be largely finished by elementary school, continues throughout adolescence. Imaging work done since the 1990s shows that these physical changes move in a slow wave from the brain's rear to its front, from areas close to the brain stem that look after older and more behaviorally basic functions, such as vision, movement, and fundamental processing, to the evolutionarily newer and more complicated thinking areas up front.
Stronger links also develop between the hippocampus, a sort of memory directory, and frontal areas that set goals and weigh different agendas; as a result, we get better at integrating memory and experience into our decisions. At the same time, the frontal areas develop greater speed and richer connections, allowing us to generate and weigh far more variables and agendas than before. When this development proceeds normally, we get better at balancing impulse, desire, goals, self-interest, rules, ethics, and even altruism, generating behavior that is more complex and, sometimes at least, more sensible. But at times, and especially at first, the brain does this work clumsily. It's hard to get all those new cogs to mesh.
The article explains that teen brains are not done developing. In fact, the brain does not fully mature until about the age of 25. From 10-25, it is evolving, fast, but areas such as impulse control, the desire to take risks, the inability to properly balance risks versus rewards and the deep, almost obsessive need to be liked by peers and to socialize with age-mates, are not up to par until the 20's. The article explains that, while it allows for dangerous behavior, it also allows the species to survive. But I will leave that part to whoever wants to read the article. It's too in-depth to explain.
I disagree that teen moms are thought of as adults. They may have to take on the responsibilities of an adult but it doesn't make them one and few people who have known a teen mom would ever consider them adults.
But it's true, soldiers are not thought of as children even if they are too young to smoke, or drink or vote. We have a double standard when it comes to soldiers because we need to. Soldiers tend to be younger because the older we become, the less enchanted we are by risk and the more weight we give to adverse consequences as opposed to possible benefits. Teens and young adults are the opposite. If it wasn't for them and they way they think, we would have far less wars, IMO. Because we'd have too few people to fight them.
Nevertheless, the teen brain doesn't always explain these things. It may explain in part, why a kid ultimately acted but there obviously has to be something else involved. In some cases, that something else is despair, pain, torment. In other cases, it's mental illness. And in yet others, it's just plain old evil.
I will have to wait and see what comes out about this case before I can decide. The initial reports by some friends that this kid was horribly bullied, quiet and sad, point to desperation to me. I didn't hear anything about his FB that alarmed me except the poem he wrote. That was a huge red flag. But it doesn't necessarily mean he's evil. Could be, or could be crazy or just at his wit's end. Kids that age are dramatic and write things and think things they would not as adults.
So, let's see what comes out.
But we need to do better in this country, either way, about bullying. Not just how to stop it or prevent it, but how to help our kids deal with it, without hanging themselves, killing someone or suffering for years, isolated and in silence.
And yes, I say "kids". I'm 43. They are babies to me. And IMO, anyone around teenagers this age should be struck by the immature, silly and foolish things they say and do that differentiate them from adults. Try to teach a high school class for a day or two and you'll see what I mean.