How could he have given these items to the cabbie ... the shirt pictured here is the same as he was wearing when caught......
OR Did joran just give him the 'shirt right off his back'......pardon me for leaving a little humor here......LOL
I'm a little confused on the Peru-to-Chile timeline, but I figure he probably stayed overnight somewhere and changed his shirt again, thus not wearing the red striped shirt anymore.
I would like to know what that leather-appearing book with "W" on it is.
Once again, you move right past the answer that fits the facts toward the answer you want. We need to some some evidence that Joran was set up. Your "theory" requires that someone would plan to murder another young woman to set Joran up, that someone would follow Joran to not only Peru, but to a hotel room with a security camera right outside his door, that someone would lie in wait for the moment when he would bring a woman back to that hotel, then wait again until Joran left her alone; that someone would somehow gain entrance to that room without breaking down the door. Then the unknown person would have to kill Stephany, attempt to clean up the blood, and Ninja his or her way out of the room without being seen by the camera, all the while not knowing where Joran is or when he was coming back...
(Snipped by me for space) This is me sort of putting words in another's mouth, but I've gotten the impression from past posts that the theory is (or at least was, maybe it has been revamped) that Stephany was working with the FBI (or someone) on the extortion sting but had second thoughts. She then went with Joran to his room and tipped him off. He left the hotel, leaving her still in room 309 alive. Then at some point some people came (don't know who) and killed Stephany, then framed Joran. So that the original plan was only to "entrap" Joran for extortion, not kill Stephany and frame Joran for murder, but that's the way it ended up.
Needless to say, I do not believe this scenario, but it would at least explain that Stephany's death was not what was originally intended, if indeed a conspiracy was planned. However, I find it hard to believe that a 21 YO Peruvian woman with little life experience, by her own father's account ('I did not teach her about the bad side of life' - not exact quote), and still living at home, was secretly working with an American espionage group of some kind to bring down Joran and then squealed to him and sat in his empty hotel room waiting to be murdered for her betrayal. Would also have to be some pretty rough American agents to decide to murder a young woman because she didn't cooperate with charging Joran for extortion. I'm sure all kinds of crazy truth-is-stranger-than-fiction stuff is going on in the world somewhere, but I just don't think this was it. IMO, it is what it looks like.
doobiedoo and flny, I really appreciate the well-thought out scenarios. I don't recall seeing a clear timeline, although with 14 threads I may well have missed it. Do we have a timeline of Joran's movements that clearly limits the times when a phantom killer would have had access to the crime scene alone?
I'll admit I have some questions about a young woman having her period being willing to take off her pants in front of a relative stranger or just willing to sit in her panties. Maybe I'm showing my age, here.
Me either! I just don't buy that Stephany started ripping off her clothes once she got to his room, intent on taking a bath, sleeping, hanging out, surfing the Web, with some guy she hardly knew, especially with her period. I guess it happens, but she doesn't look that relaxed in the footage of her going up to Joran's room.
I've seen posts on other web sites to the effect that Stephany was parked in a "quick parking" spot, indicating that she was not intending to stay with Joran for long. Do we have any confirmation of this other than the hotel receptionist telling Joran that he would have to move "his girl's" vehicle?
Re: SF changing seats. My impression is that when she first approaches Joran at the table, she's not sure where to sit since there is a drink in front of the seat next to him (seat #7). She seems to stall around and then is seated at #8. I think Joran then tells her there is no one at #7. So, she moves to seat #7, while placing the drink at #8.
I agree. She fingers the seat next to him briefly as if considering sitting there, unsure whether or not to do so.
It's very weird to me, the more I look at it, that she takes his drink and moves it over. Before that, she grabs another bottle that is sitting there and twists the cap on more tightly (anybody know what that bottle is?), then moves it over, then moves Joran's drink, then orders her own drink.