Post your PROFILE

[LikeAHunter]

This is racist.

I agree 110%.

 

[LindsayLohan6]

A completely unremarkable john.

 

[LikeAHunter]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z5mUS9MBE4Y

Explains the why make up is left behind, huh?

What makes you think that it's odd for a woman to leave her makeup behind?? Escort or not, you seem to be under the impression that women can't live without their makeup. That's not true at all.

What IS odd is that she left her phone behind. Most people, particularly younger people, don't even go to the mailbox without their phones.

 

[Mountain_Kat]

I remember I've read something about a scar on her forehead. Maybe it's because of that. But, still, there must be more you can tell about her. Is it just her hair? What's special about her?

I've read countless articles regarding this case over the course of 4+ years, with a specific emphasis on Maureen's case, and I don't recall ever reading that Maureen had a scar on her forehead. Would you happen to recall where you might have read that?

 

[LindsayLohan6]

Bittrolff is the most unremarkable guy you can find. He's so unremarkable but one thing sticks out about him. He did a pretty good job of not appearing out of place at all except you wont find hardly anyone else on all of LI who butchers pigs in the backyard of their home.

 

[Emre E]

I've read countless articles regarding this case over the course of 4+ years, with a specific emphasis on Maureen's case, and I don't recall ever reading that Maureen had a scar on her forehead. Would you happen to recall where you might have read that?

http://www.crimelibrary.com/serial_killers/unsolved/long-island-ripper/maureen-brainard-barnes.html

Are you happy now?

 

[Emre E]

I've read countless articles regarding this case over the course of 4+ years, with a specific emphasis on Maureen's case, and I don't recall ever reading that Maureen had a scar on her forehead. Would you happen to recall where you might have read that?

http://www.crimelibrary.com/serial_killers/unsolved/long-island-ripper/maureen-brainard-barnes.html

 

[LindsayLohan6]

Btw you don't think Bittrolff is the SK emre? What about his 3 murders in 3 months than...nothing? What about the rules ofescalation and post mortem mutilators? He's a serial killer who lived SO CLOSE to the Manorville dump site and bodies started appearing there shortly after he moved there. He probably lived in Mastic Beach before which adds up with the FI legs.

 

[LindsayLohan6]

The dog growling at him with the blood on his shorts from him butchering pigs just out of site of the neighbor....I mean I really don't see how Bittrolff couldnt be the Manorville Butcher thus making him responsible for numerous OP body parts. And that Rita's daughter was friends with Melissa? And he grew up a few blocks from Kim Raffo...how many coincidences before we?

 

[Emre E]

Btw you don't think Bittrolff is the SK emre? What about his 3 murders in 3 months than...nothing? What about the rules ofescalation and post mortem mutilators? He's a serial killer who lived SO CLOSE to the Manorville dump site and bodies started appearing there shortly after he moved there. He probably lived in Mastic Beach before which adds up with the FI legs.

No. Bittrolff is in my opinion have serious issues with himself. He's a sick mind. Probably he's guilty of all three crimes prosecution refers to. More? I'm really not sure. Atlantic City murders. Seems like a completely different case to me. Manorville I guess you mean Jessica Taylor and peaches and some men and the mom and kid .... . Strongly probable, that this is linked to GB4. Same person or two persons? That is a bit tricky. Shannan Gilbert; I believe she died in the hands of Charles Peter Hackett. IMHO

 

[Mountain_Kat]

http://www.crimelibrary.com/serial_killers/unsolved/long-island-ripper/maureen-brainard-barnes.html

Are you happy now?

I'm not at all sure why you are so defensive, nor do I care, to be perfectly honest. It is common practice on this forum to back up our statements of fact with links that support those statements. It is how we operate. If you took a simple request for a link to information as some kind of challenge, that's on you.

But thank you for providing the link. Apparently that information was something I had read numerous times but just never stood out to me as particularly relevant. Information filtering, I guess.

 

[Emre E]

I'm not at all sure why you are so defensive, nor do I care, to be perfectly honest. It is common practice on this forum to back up our statements of fact with links that support those statements. It is how we operate. If you took a simple request for a link to information as some kind of challenge, that's on you.

But thank you for providing the link. Apparently that information was something I had read numerous times but just never stood out to me as relevant.

OK. Please don't get this as personal. I respect each and every person on this forum because I know they are working much more than SCPD to do something about the case. I'm not racist, I have no feeling of competition to crush you or debunk you. What I'm really sorry for is the two kids Maureen left, the little lady Megan gave birth to. If I think the guy is white I say white. If I think he's Asian I say it's Asian. You are being carried away to slap me with comebacks and it's really not necessary. You just come up with your question before typing "Maureen Brainard Barnes + forehead + scar" on Google. Don't you think you're being offensive to me? And I'm really not offended, no hard feelings on my side.

Let's take a good look at the case.

Maureen says she's mugged and somehow she gets her money back. Isn't that the narrative? What part of that story is making sense to you? I mean this guy must be a dropout of Muggers College because he failed Mugging 101. How well is he vetted? The other (?) guy who NYPD finds Melissa's second(??) phone in his possession. How that phone got there? How well is he vetted and cleared from these crimes?

Don't you think these are interesting?

 

[Mountain_Kat]

The dog growling at him with the blood on his shorts from him butchering pigs just out of site of the neighbor....I mean I really don't see how Bittrolff couldnt be the Manorville Butcher thus making him responsible for numerous OP body parts. And that Rita's daughter was friends with Melissa? And he grew up a few blocks from Kim Raffo...how many coincidences before we?

Not to be a pain in the or anything (I know, too late), but I think it's important not to state this friendship as an established fact. It would be more accurate to say that Rita's daughter has said that she was friends with Melissa.

 

[LindsayLohan6]

Not to be a pain in the or anything (I know, too late), but I think it's important not to state this friendship as an established fact. It would be more accurate to say that Rita's daughter has said that she was friends with Melissa.

Any why should lie? A friendship takes two parties. With one half deceased only Amanda can verify. If your not willing to accept Rita's daughter's statement as a fact then you can't consider anything any of the families said. Sorry but it is an established fact to me or Amanda wouldn't have said it.

 

[LindsayLohan6]

No. Bittrolff is in my opinion have serious issues with himself. He's a sick mind. Probably he's guilty of all three crimes prosecution refers to. More? I'm really not sure. Atlantic City murders. Seems like a completely different case to me. Manorville I guess you mean Jessica Taylor and peaches and some men and the mom and kid .... . Strongly probable, that this is linked to GB4. Same person or two persons? That is a bit tricky. Shannan Gilbert; I believe she died in the hands of Charles Peter Hackett. IMHO

So bitrollf killed 3 people one winter in the early 90's then gave up killing for a normal life? And the fact that he lives right down the road from the Manorville dump site is only coincidence...he takes out his violent urges to kill on the piggies in his backyard?

 

[Mountain_Kat]

OK. Please don't get this as personal. I respect each and every person on this forum because I know they are working much more than SCPD to do something about the case. I'm not racist, I have no feeling of competition to crush you or debunk you. What I'm really sorry for is the two kids Maureen left, the little lady Megan gave birth to. If I think the guy is white I say white. If I think he's Asian I say it's Asian. You are being carried away to slap me with comebacks and it's really not necessary.You just come up with your question before typing "Maureen Brainard Barnes + forehead + scar" on Google. Don't you think you're being offensive to me? And I'm really not offended, no hard feelings on my side.

Let's take a good look at the case.

Maureen says she's mugged and somehow she gets her money back. Isn't that the narrative? What part of that story is making sense to you? I mean this guy must be a dropout of Muggers College because he failed Mugging 101. How well is he vetted? The other (?) guy who NYPD finds Melissa's second(??) phone in his possession. How that phone got there? How well is he vetted and cleared from these crimes?

Don't you think these are interesting?

1. I never said or even implied that you were a racist, Em. Where is THAT coming from?
2. I am not at all thin skinned, nor am I particularly sensitive. It never even occurred to me that you were trying to "crush" me or "debunk" me.
3. I am not being "carried away" with anything, and I'm certainly not trying to slap you with "comebacks". I am here for the same reason I have always been here...to research the FACTS of this case, and discuss those facts with other forum members. That is what I am doing. If you have an issue with something I post, feel free to click on my post and bring it to the attention of one of the mods. Those are rules of this forum.
4. No I don't think I'm being offensive to you by asking you to post a link. If you find that offensive, that's on you. That is what we do here. Simple as that.
5. I respectfully repeat...Maureen never said she was mugged. She said she was robbed. There is a difference.

 

[Emre E]

So bitrollf killed 3 people one winter in the early 90's then gave up killing for a normal life? And the fact that he lives right down the road from the Manorville dump site is only coincidence...he takes out his violent urges to kill on the piggies in his backyard?

I don't know. He's sitting in the jail right now and probably will remain there for the rest of his life. If there are other crimes he committed, who do you think is responsible to find out?

 

[LindsayLohan6]

What are the odds that a serial killer would end up living right by a second serial killers dump sites. And they both target sex workers. Then a third separate serial killer of sex workers in NJ kills a girl who grew up only a few blocks from Bittrolff in Mastic Beach. By this rationale, every third person in the metro area is a serial killer.

 

[Emre E]

1. I never said or even implied that you were a racist, Em. Where is THAT coming from?
2. I am not at all thin skinned, nor am I particularly sensitive. It never even occurred to me that you were trying to "crush" me or "debunk" me.
3. I am not being "carried away" with anything, and I'm certainly not trying to slap you with "comebacks". I am here for the same reason I have always been here...to research the FACTS of this case, and discuss those facts with other forum members. That is what I am doing. If you have an issue with something I post, feel free to click on my post and bring it to the attention of one of the mods. Those are rules of this forum.
4. No I don't think I'm being offensive to you by asking you to post a link. If you find that offensive, that's on you. That is what we do here. Simple as that.
5. I respectfully repeat...Maureen never said she was mugged. She said she was robbed. There is a difference.

Quote from Robert Kolker's Lost Girls
Back in Connecticut that night, Sara got a call from Al, the big Italian guy she’d met at Tony’s office on her first weekend in the city. “You hear from Maureen?” he asked.

“No.”

“She called me.”

“Why?”

“ ’Cause she couldn’t get ahold of you. She got robbed. She said that guy you guys met last night—the guy with the dreads—robbed her for five grand.”


Maybe you should continue that discussion with Mr. Kolker

 

[Mountain_Kat]

Quote from Robert Kolker's Lost Girls
Back in Connecticut that night, Sara got a call from Al, the big Italian guy she’d met at Tony’s office on her first weekend in the city. “You hear from Maureen?” he asked.

“No.”

“She called me.”

“Why?”

“ ’Cause she couldn’t get ahold of you. She got robbed. She said that guy you guys met last night—the guy with the dreads—robbed her for five grand.”


Maybe you should continue that discussion with Mr. Kolker

That's hardly necessary, since the exerpt you quoted said exactly what I said...that Maureen was robbed.

ETA: And now, I'm done with this, Em.