Even considering all this makes me feel very, very strange. Maybe I had best back off from this topic for a bit ...
I have to say, I was majorly intrigued when I first ran across evidence that the writer was likely related to BSL -- before we discussed that on the thread. It just had such shades of Ann Rule spending nights all alone with Ted Bundy on the suicide hotline crew ... "stranger than fiction", yes.
I've thought, like some others, that there is at least an inkling of evidence that BSL's adoptive mother knows his "birth family" background, enough to wonder if maybe it was an in-family or related-somehow-to-family adoption. And yes, I, also, even scrutinized the writer's past for possible clues....
Then a few days ago, I requested Bad Boy from the online book swap to which I belong and, anticipating receiving it, looked over some of the same online sources we've looked at here. And, almost unwillingly, I started thinking about ...well, about the topic of this thread. But I thought, nah, that would be just too weird, better not go THERE on WS! So it feels very strange to be openly discussing it.
I tend to think that BSL is NOT related to McDuff ... but I admit, this time I DO see some resemblance. (At least I'm not stuck with a pic of Sheldon from Big Bang theory in my head, as I was after looking at the sketch of the possible perp in the NOLA murder case some are sleuthing, the one that happened around the time BSL got out of prison.)
If BSL is guilty of that of which he stands accused and if it were to turn out that he is in any way related to McDuff -- I just don't know how to deal with that possibility. It would just be so completely sad and heartbreaking for all concerned, IMO.
I got Bad Boy in the mail today (meaning Saturday) and I almost dread reading it -- I already know it's not a pretty tale. Guess I will try to plunge on in, though -- have promised a few here I will report back in with a "review" of sorts.