REVISIT Caylee's biological father/Reverse DNA Profile**MERGED**

[Whome?]

well, hypothetically, if the father found out 20 years from now, he might be upset that he wasn't told earlier

so for that reason, I believe he & his family have a right to know (if they don't already)

I agree it doesn't have much relevance to the trial, except to show KC's character if she doesn't know or care who the father of her baby is

but I also think that if anyone suspects they might be the dad, they should come forward and get dna testing and claim Caylee as their own

she deserves no less than to at least be honoured & grieved in death by one parent since the other one's IMO her murderer and her grandmother thinks she's still somehow alive :waitasec:

ITA If they know who the family is,and tell
them,maybe they will want to come to the
trial to lend their support to the prosecution.

If this were my son's child,I would want to
sit behind the prosecution to show my support
for what they were doing for my grand-
daughter in death.

It could also possibly stop CA from getting
some of her Big Deals with the TV networks
because,more interest would be with this
part of the family,that was never told,about
their daughter/g-daughter.

IMHO

:twocents:

 

[Gypsy Road]

Dr. Baden said A LOT of things before his wife signed on to the case. I don't know if I believe anything he says or if LE really knows who the father is. Also, Baden sure changed his tune to what he thought about Casey's guilt AFTER his wife signed on. Just saying.

 

[sleuthy sleutherson]

I agree it should be known, if he is even known by CA or any of her family, I would not doubt she doesn't exactly know who the father is.

But this little girl deserved a father, far more then the A's deserved her and I hope it is known and brought out so the father or at least his family can support Caylee and help bring her justice.

 

[I Din Doot]

As soon as CA finds her, the Father could get custody. (sarcasm)

 

[kushka]

I
If this were my son's child,I would want to
sit behind the prosecution to show my support
for what they were doing for my grand-
daughter in death.


:twocents:

and if I found out Caylee had been my son's child, I believe I would die of grief. I do not believe any good would come of knowing -

 

[Dear Prudence]

I don't think anybody knows who Caylee's father is. Maybe KC knows, but if she does know she will never tell. If she was willing to bring out the truth, I feel she would have done it long ago in order to get child support. So, either she has no idea or it's a secret she will take to the grave. But, oh man, if it did come out during the trial, what a bombshell!!

 

[Tuffy]

and if I found out Caylee had been my son's child, I believe I would die of grief. I do not believe any good would come of knowing -

At this point, I don't think anything good could come from knowing either. I think the guy would get his name trashed and dragged through the mud.

 

[Nore]

I don't think anybody knows who Caylee's father is. Maybe KC knows, but if she does know she will never tell. If she was willing to bring out the truth, I feel she would have done it long ago in order to get child support. So, either she has no idea or it's a secret she will take to the grave. But, oh man, if it did come out during the trial, what a bombshell!!

-------------------------

Hi, suppose the Dad did come out at trial.Wouldnt that give him the rights to Caylees ashes? If kc. never told him about Caylee he could hardly be faulted for not helping with Caylee after birth.He should have rights!

 

[Dear Prudence]

-------------------------

Hi, suppose the Dad did come out at trial.Wouldnt that give him the rights to Caylees ashes? If kc. never told him about Caylee he could hardly be faulted for not helping with Caylee after birth.He should have rights!

No, I would never fault him if he wasn't ever told he had a child. If his name did come out at trial I would hope it would not lead to a fight over Caylee's remains. That would be horrible!

 

[RR0004]

I agree with both sides (pros and cons)...but to answer the question, I sure hope so.

 

[jandkmom]

If the SA office knows, I feel like they would have already told him that he is the dad. It would be cruel for him to find out during testimony if they already know. If he knows and hasn't made it public, he may want to stay out of this circus as long as possible. If it has to be made public during the trial, I hope he is given his privacy if he so desires it. How awful to have this happen to your child.

 

[ZsaZsa]

-------------------------

Hi, suppose the Dad did come out at trial.Wouldnt that give him the rights to Caylees ashes? If kc. never told him about Caylee he could hardly be faulted for not helping with Caylee after birth.He should have rights!

I just hope it does.

 

[Whome?]

-------------------------

Hi, suppose the Dad did come out at trial.Wouldnt that give him the rights to Caylees ashes? If kc. never told him about Caylee he could hardly be faulted for not helping with Caylee after birth.He should have rights!

You might have a point here,this maybe
the reason CA had Caylee cremated and
has never divulged where the ashes are.

If I remember correctly,ICA did not want her
cremated,it was CA who did this. IMM she is
evil enough to think "If I could not have her
nobody will have her"

This is just too terrible to think about,but
it may well be a reality to someone out there.

JMHO:waitasec:

 

[joypath]

HYPOTHETICAL: IF there was REASON to do a DNA search in CODIS because the skeleton remains could NOT be identified as Caylee, THEN the "match" parental individual would be released as discovery material to the defense (and the world as FOI material). Since the Anthony family could provide primary sample material to use as a comparison exemplars AND since the laboratory had biological samples of the mother and other first degree relatives, there were many loci "checks and balances".

If the defense wants to play SODDI by announcing that the sperm donor is the perp, then they better pony up the DNA/CODIS match, the laboratory test results (hopefully, Dr. Spitz took bone marrow samples!) and the LIVING second family. NOW, THAT WOULD open up one heck of a can of "worms"

 

[christee]

If KC can keep quiet about how her child died I have no doubt she could keep the father's identity to herself. I *absolutely* believe she knows exactly who the father is.
I don't think the father should be a part of this case, but I do hope the father knows that Caylee was his child.

 

[Infojunkie]

The father coming into knowledge would be awful for the prosecution. They would be left in the position of defending an unkown person's character for what purpose? The only reason to bring in Caylee's daddy would be to cast doubt on the murder charge, other than that it would serve no purpose other than to satisfy curiousty.

 

[hroark2112]

I'm leaning more towards KC having a rough pool of guys to have guessed to be the DNA donor. I think she made up the story of the "dead father" to keep from having to attempt to list all the guys she was sleeping with.

Even if she did know, it wouldn't do much good. There's nothing in her "estate" that could be obtained in a wrongful death suit. 18 cents an hour in prison labor wages won't pay much towards that.

 

[LinasK]

Dr Baden stated on a Fox News show one day- ages ago, before he signed on with the defense, that LE KNEW who the Father was, by DNA testing. The interviewer did not pursue his statement, so that's all there was to it- I wish I had saved a copy of that interview now.....

I would want to know if I had a daughter.

well, hypothetically, if the father found out 20 years from now, he might be upset that he wasn't told earlier

so for that reason, I believe he & his family have a right to know (if they don't already)

I agree it doesn't have much relevance to the trial, except to show KC's character if she doesn't know or care who the father of her baby is

but I also think that if anyone suspects they might be the dad, they should come forward and get dna testing and claim Caylee as their own

she deserves no less than to at least be honoured & grieved in death by one parent since the other one's IMO her murderer and her grandmother thinks she's still somehow alive :waitasec:

I totally agree with LadyL. It just breaks me heart that her 'family' is still acting the way they are... I wish her dad would come out/find out who he is. Maybe he has half a heart. Who knows.

I think this is completely relevant. It is one more symptom of the strange family dynamics that brick by brick led to this poor child's demise. An unacknowleged pregnancy and then an unacknowledged father. And now an unacknowledged murder. It goes to show, in a crazy kind of way, the long slow path to motive.

I just don't see how it could help or hinder the trial, HOWEVER . . . . . like the family of Nichole Brown Simpson, Caylee's father/fraternal family should have the right to file for wrongful death. JMO.

ITA If they know who the family is,and tell
them,maybe they will want to come to the
trial to lend their support to the prosecution.

If this were my son's child,I would want to
sit behind the prosecution to show my support
for what they were doing for my grand-
daughter in death.

It could also possibly stop CA from getting
some of her Big Deals with the TV networks
because,more interest would be with this
part of the family,that was never told,about
their daughter/g-daughter.

IMHO

:twocents:

I agree it should be known, if he is even known by CA or any of her family, I would not doubt she doesn't exactly know who the father is.

But this little girl deserved a father, far more then the A's deserved her and I hope it is known and brought out so the father or at least his family can support Caylee and help bring her justice.

I so agree with all of the above posts, especially what I bolded!:clap::clap::clap:

 

[Whisperer]

I always thought it odd that Caylee probably died on Father's Day.

 

[TorisMom003]

No, I would never fault him if he wasn't ever told he had a child. If his name did come out at trial I would hope it would not lead to a fight over Caylee's remains. That would be horrible!

If it came to that (a fight over Caylee's ashes) there really shouldn't be to much of a fuss coming from Cindy since she believes that Caylee is still alive. But then I'm sure that Cindy would still find a way to raise heck about it while claiming that while they aren't Caylee's ashes (since she's alive) that the dad has no right to them. This is one screwed up family.

I personally believe that Casey has a pretty good idea who Caylee's dad is. She's great at counting backwards so she can figure out what month and approximate what day and recall who she was sleeping with at the time.