- Joined
- Jul 19, 2023
- Messages
- 68
- Reaction score
- 564
No im surprised that someone who thought they were going to be killed gave zero explanation to the person who could potentially save their life.Shannan had just sprinted after being up all night. And you're surprised that you hear breathing instead of a a lengthy explanation?
Maybe her main agenda was make sure police get the address, and when he was on the phone with 911, she felt like her job was done there, and she did not want Coletti to turn her over to whomever was chasing her.
Indeed, Suffolk police took their time arriving. And the 911 operators were not particularly good at interviewing Shannan. I don't believe Brewer was deposed by police, just interviewed. Pak fell asleep during a lie detector test. Nobody "volunteered" to give depositions, they were compelled to by subpoenas due to Mari's lawsuit against Hackett. The depositions are filled with conversations that indicate Brewer and Pak do not want to give the depositions, and Pak even asks to get paid for his time, lol. Those depositions were pulled like teeth by John Ray, as was the 911 call.
No one is accusing you of being buddies with the police, but to call them the experts in this case is laughable. They were late in response to 3 911 calls. They refused to take missing persons reports. They didn't even ask the HOA to save the security footage in case Shannan is not found, let alone demand it. They chased away the FBI. They refused to release the 911 case, citing an ongoing investigation into what they called "misadventure." Once they did release the tape, they edited it to remove their own dispatchers, interrupted it to insert commentary at times to break the tension; right as things are escalating and right before Shannan screams, they stop the recording, and narrate that
Shannan then runs, getting the audience to picture the running part before hearing that horrific scream. They constantly assert against logic she entered the marsh and crossed it, when it makes so much more sense she was dumped from the road. They, after claiming she entered the marsh nearer her pants, Brennen and Hackett, decided to search for her 5 miles west? "Professionals" publicly argued if there were one or two or more serial killers. They were the interference in this case, especially from the time the FBI was removed and until the task force was formed. They were not the experts. At least not the experts at solving this crime.
MOO
Im surprised that someone that thought they were going to be killed gave zero response after about 30 seconds and multiple questions from the person who could potentially save their life. And when she did respond it was "I need help" then ran off again. I don't care who you are or how far you ran, if you are really in danger and fighting for your life, as soon as that door opens you are blurting every detail out in rapid succession. Instead she said nothing for 30 seconds. Said I need help, in what sounds like a drubk/sleepy tone, the ran off again. That screams hallucinating.
If her agenda was to make sure the police get the address she could have handed the phone to the person who's door she knocked on to save her life and or asked him what his address was to relay it to the 911 dispatcher.
Im sorry , nothing she did was was logical or reasonable for someone who thought their life was in danger and was seeking refuge. Nothing at all. Your theory is full of a bunch of nonsensical maybes while ignoring what any reasonable person would do in that situation. Compare it to the many many 911 calls of people who are sober and clear minded and need police assistance.
You also keep ignoring the fact that she was out there for 19 months including during one of long islands worse hurricanes. Which flooded that exact area bad and likley moved her remains around a lot.
As far as the depositions, you can just plead the 5th to every single question. Nothing compelled them to answer or give a single shred of details. Pak would have packed his bags and left town if he was involved in a murder. Why stick around.