TX TX - Cheryl Henry, 22, & Andy Atkinson, 21, Houston, 21 Aug 1990

  • #701
buehler-houston-1990.jpg


(What time did she have the blowout? Note: How do any of these “times” potentially correlate? What day of the week was it?)

breckenridge-houstonpd.jpg


(Tara was a waitress at the Men’s Club)

crone-1993-houston.jpg


(Re: Jane, which C&W Club I wonder and where? Making note to look up her case)

davis-houston-1993.jpg


(I wonder where Jayne was last seen)

Dallas, Texas:

abbrederis-dallas-1996.jpg


(It appears Angela was a dancer at “various men’s clubs”)

Establishing a serial killer . . .Kolchak Style


—-

I just had a thought. There’s obviously the dance/night club connection, but IF Jane’s case is connected, hers involves a C&W club, which is different from the rest?

I wonder if he’s a cowboy? Normally hangs out at Country bars??
Fwiw, these women all appear to be on the taller side, one woman is 5'11'' wondering if the perp is a big guy?
Cheryl and Andy were athletes and musicians, unsure of each of their heights.

Thinking the perp was into music and muscle,complete speculation, imo.
 
  • #702
Cheryl's Mom posted this on facebook today:

CHERYL, CHERYL, CHERYL. A security guard called our home.
He told me he had found Cheryl’s checkbook and purse in a vacant white car off of Enclave. It seemed like just minutes before Cheryl’s friends, 2 car loads of friends I think, were at our home and they took Shane and me to Enclave where Andy’s car was parked. I could see the blood area on Andy’s back rest of the front
seat, the passengers side only showed Cheryl’s purse and shoes. The visor on Cheryl’s side of the car was pulled off, as if she was trying to use it to keep from being pulled outside the car. There were golf balls and a club outside the car. After making sure no one was going to touch or move anything, I started yelling Cheryl’s name. CHERYL, CHERYL, CHERYL. and walking into an open area between Andy’s car and a fence. This area was in an upscale office park. It was the Sysco Building. I kept calling Cheryl’s name but stopped walking toward the area where HPD found Cheryl. It’s like something, I believe God, was stopping me from taking another step toward her.
Houston Police Dept. and Harris Country Sheriffs Dept. and a K 9 unit were there. An HPD officer walked me back to the street where everyone was congregating. I sat on a curb with Shaney at my side. Shaney loved Cheryl and looked up to her. They were so close. Within an hour after the K-9 unit came, they had found Cheryl. I watched as 2 dogs ran back and forth searching for her.
An ambulance came and we thought they were taking her to a hospital. I had been trying to get to Cheryl but a police officer said I could stay with the others or sit in the back of his car. A police officer walked up to me and said “We’ve found a little blonde hair girl.” My reply was”NO,NO!! You’ve found a tall red haired girl. He kept telling me they found a little blonde hair girl. He asked what Cheryl had been wearing. I knew the exact details of her dress. It was turquoise sleeveless with tiny little red and white roses in it. She had borrowed my red shoes to go with them. She had asked to borrow my white jacket but I said no because you might get it dirty. What a disgusting horrible mother I am. HPD asked us to go down to their offices to talk with them. I declined telling them I had other children at home I needed to make sure were safe. Dan and I went home. I remember telling Chris, Merideth and Jason that Cheryl had been hurt very badly and wouldn’t be coming back home. Cristl was at college and her cousin drove her home rather us calling her. Andy was found the following day. My heart goes out to Andy’s Mother, Dad and loved ones . Our lives were forever changed, our hearts broken and I’m still trying to process how Or why this could have happened. OUR LIVES HAVE BEEN SO MUCH RICHER AND FUN AND LOVING BECAUSE CHERYL WAS OURS!! OUR DAUGHTER, SISTER, GRANDDAUGHTER, NIECE, COUSIN, FRIEND.

CHERYL, YOU ARE CHERISHED.
Mocity. Thanks to your stepmom and you for posting this.
This answers a lot of questions that I had.
For example. I asked you if Cheryl went barefoot a lot. I was trying to figure out if she got out of the car barefoot while Andy was driving golf balls, and were confronted outside of the car.
If I remember right, her bare feet were clean when she was found.
I believe that she was in the car, and were ambushed while in the car, after reading about the blood and the ripped off sun visor. I know that you stated that she did go barefoot often, and after reading that her mother lent her the shoes to wear, I was thinking maybe they were bothering her feet some, so she took them off in the car.
I also believe she was carried into the woods and that's why her feet were clean.
We now know that the dogs started tracking from the car.
I had asked where they started tracking from because if one man was responsible for this , he would have had to take them both in the woods together, possibly at gun point, and the dog(s) would have tracked by Andy first because he would have been tied up first imo . He wasn't found til the next day. If Cheryl ripped off the sun visor, her hands/body were not bound while she taken from the car, so imo he didn't tie Cheryl up, take Andy in the woods first, tie him up, and then walk back for Cheryl.
It's not important, but, I believe those dogs were tracking ground disturbance, (from the abductor) and not Cheryl's scent. If she was carried, she would have left some "raft" to track, but no blood. (there was no blood on her side of the car)
I'm convinced that there were two people involved. One took Andy one way and one took Cheryl the other way. That's why the dogs never found Andy first. IMO once those dogs were tracking one scent, LE never bothered to see if the dogs would pick up/track a second scent. I may have misunderstood, but I believe her Mom stated both dogs were running back and forth in the same area. The reason is because they were tracking the same scent, and the reason that Andy wasn't found til the next day.
 
  • #703
Why was the golf club found outside?
This is my theory.
I may be wrong, but I believe that I read that there was blood on the golf club?
If this is true, then, I believe that that whoever did this enjoyed slowly instilling fear and torture.
I have nothing to base this on, but I believe while one was holding a gun/knife on Cheryl and Andy, the other was hitting golf balls while they were being verbally tormented.
So he took the club and balls out of the hatchback, after demanding that either Andy pop the hatch, (the keys never left the ignition because the switch was in the acc position with the radio on when the Security Guard found the car) or was able to open it from the outside, lined up a bunch of balls, and once he hit a few, he walked over to Andy's side and hit him in the face with the club while standing outside of the car to either shut him up, or to stun him. That's why there was blood on both the club and the head rest.
He may have went back to the golf balls, hit a few more, then dropped the club. (I'm not convinced the club and balls were a sign pointing into the woods but the club was found near the balls) Then he took Andy out of the car soon after,( no blood on the rest of the seat, just the head rest) and the other took Cheryl. They went in separate directions.
All speculation.
I find it hard to believe that they would have hung around the scene after killing them, taking time to remove the golf club/balls from the car.
I also find it hard to believe that 2 people their age after having a few drinks being all alone in a brand new relationship with the seats reclined had driving golf balls on their minds once they got there.
 
  • #704
Did anything ever come of this? It seems like the most logical and easiest way to solve this crime. So unbelievable that after this long, it is not solved.

When he raped the other woman, he knew her boyfriend's name. I wonder if he stalked them beforehand. In other words, I wonder if he knew Andy's name as well.

This crime was brutal, the monster - even after all of these years - needs to be brought to justice.
I agree. It does seem like the easiest way to solve this crime.
So why wouldn't they do it?
There are only two reasons that I can think of.
1. LE is trying to protect someone, and wants to make sure that this case is never solved.
2. Egos are getting in the way, someone wants to make a name for themselves, and therefore doesn't want anyone else getting the credit for solving such a high profile case.

IMO, this is nothing but a travesty of justice... a slap in the face.
 
  • #705
Did anything ever come of this? It seems like the most logical and easiest way to solve this crime. So unbelievable that after this long, it is not solved.

When he raped the other woman, he knew her boyfriend's name. I wonder if he stalked them beforehand. In other words, I wonder if he knew Andy's name as well.

This crime was brutal, the monster - even after all of these years - needs to be brought to justice.
Where as Cheryl and Andy only knew each other for a few weeks, IMO I doubt that he/they knew Andy's name. I wouldn't rule out Cheryl being stocked though.
These are my thoughts as far as the rape victim goes...
I would hope that her and her boyfriends friends were all checked out by LE.
I believe that her boyfriend may have gone to visit her while she was working/dancing. The rapist may have walked in, sat down next to the bf, struck up a conversation. got to know his name, and that he was going to be out of town on the night she was raped. In other words, he knew all about the bf while the bf knew nothing about him. It may have been so casual that the bf didn't even remember the event. JMO.
 
  • #706
Rocky1 said:
snipped by me....
The reason is because they were tracking the same scent, and the reason that Andy wasn't found til the next day.

From what I read - and I could have misunderstood it - but I believe it got too dark to search for Andy, so they came back the next day.
 
  • #707
  • #708
From what I read - and I could have misunderstood it - but I believe it got too dark to search for Andy, so they came back the next day.
That makes sense.
My point was that if both were taken into the woods at the same time, to me anyway, it would make more sense that Andy would have been tied up first and then Cheryl led the 100 yards away.
If the dogs started tracking ground disturbance, and everyone was led into the woods at the same time, the dogs would have led LE to Andy first, before Cheryl, and Andy would have been found before Cheryl, rather than Andy being found the next morning.
 
  • #709
That makes sense.
My point was that if both were taken into the woods at the same time, to me anyway, it would make more sense that Andy would have been tied up first and then Cheryl led the 100 yards away.
If the dogs started tracking ground disturbance, and everyone was led into the woods at the same time, the dogs would have led LE to Andy first, before Cheryl, and Andy would have been found before Cheryl, rather than Andy being found the next morning.

I think that is likely right about the male victim being tied up first. A killer of this type would likely always subdue or incapacitate a male victim first as they would work on the basis they posed the greatest physical thread to them. An interesting aspect of this extremely wicked crime is that after tying the male up he was forced to watch the murder of his girlfriend then killed after her.
 
  • #710
Okay - from what I understand - Cheryl was found 200 yards away from the car, and then Andy was found 100 yards away from Cheryl. So assuming Andy was then 300 yards from the car....

I too would believe the killer would tie up the male first.
 
  • #711
I think that is likely right about the male victim being tied up first. A killer of this type would likely always subdue or incapacitate a male victim first as they would work on the basis they posed the greatest physical thread to them. An interesting aspect of this extremely wicked crime is that after tying the male up he was forced to watch the murder of his girlfriend then killed after her.
I read that Cheryl was forced to watch too, but I think somewhere along the way that was added into the story to make it sound more sensationalized.
I don't see how anyone could see someone 100 yards through trees in total darkness, but I may be wrong. That's the length of a football field.
 
  • #712
I read that Cheryl was forced to watch too, but I think somewhere along the way that was added into the story to make it sound more sensationalized.
I don't see how anyone could see someone 100 yards through trees in total darkness, but I may be wrong. That's the length of a football field.

You would likely know more than I do about the exact details of the crime scene but I read it was Andy who was forced to watch the attack on Cheryl and this might have been some perverse 'joke' about the club situation by the killer (I know it is very unpleasant for relatives to read such things but it was a very nasty case and you cannot escape that really. Thanks
 
  • #713
Okay - from what I understand - Cheryl was found 200 yards away from the car, and then Andy was found 100 yards away from Cheryl. So assuming Andy was then 300 yards from the car....

I too would believe the killer would tie up the male first.
Do you think it could be possible that Cheryl may have been 200 yards from the car, but Andy was only 100 yards away from the car?
 
  • #714
Do you think it could be possible that Cheryl may have been 200 yards from the car, but Andy was only 100 yards away from the car?

This is me being honest I do not know about these details but I think it is a possibility the killer made Andy watch the attack on Cheryl as in his mind it was some kind of twisted show. Hence the money balloons, golf balls etc. Cheers.
 
  • #715
You would likely know more than I do about the exact details of the crime scene but I read it was Andy who was forced to watch the attack on Cheryl and this might have been some perverse 'joke' about the club situation by the killer (I know it is very unpleasant for relatives to read such things but it was a very nasty case and you cannot escape that really. Thanks
You may be right, but it got me thinking about not only how hard it would be to see in the dark that far, but also how would anyone actually know what Andy was forced to do?
It's just moo, but I believe that was fed into the story later so some documentary or some podcast could make a more dramatic sounding story.
 
  • #716
This is me being honest I do not know about these details but I think it is a possibility the killer made Andy watch the attack on Cheryl as in his mind it was some kind of twisted show. Hence the money balloons, golf balls etc. Cheers.
You may be right.
 
  • #717
This is me being honest I do not know about these details but I think it is a possibility the killer made Andy watch the attack on Cheryl as in his mind it was some kind of twisted show. Hence the money balloons, golf balls etc. Cheers.
I haven't given the balloons much thought. The reason is because I read they were partially inflated when found, and that made me think that they had been there for a while.
Having said that...going with your thoughts, if it was a "twisted show" do you think the killer brought the balloons? Do you think it was premeditated?
I wonder why, if it wasn't premeditated, anyone would have balloons with them? Did they come from Andy's car? Was someone Andy knew having a birthday?
 
  • #718
I haven't given the balloons much thought. The reason is because I read they were partially inflated when found, and that made me think that they had been there for a while.
Having said that...going with your thoughts, if it was a "twisted show" do you think the killer brought the balloons? Do you think it was premeditated?
I wonder why, if it wasn't premeditated, anyone would have balloons with them? Did they come from Andy's car? Was someone Andy knew having a birthday?

The killer may have brought the balloons of course it is difficult to say for certain. As I say to me this is one of the most staged crime scenes out there particularly for an outside crime scene. Although most of it could be improvised to a degree with the golf stuff etc. I can only give my thoughts based on research and I think the killer stalked from the club and eaved dropped on conversations so who know what bits of information he found out. In my opinion the killer was certainly searching for people to kill. Thanks
 
  • #719
Re post of some details.. rbbm.
New clues in grisly Lover's Lane Murders
May 16, 2013
"Cheryl Henry was a blond bombshell; a fun loving college student with a contagious laugh.

Andy Atkinson was the one for her; an aspiring model with piercing green eyes and a smile his Mom once said you couldn' t forget."

"They were found the next evening, not in their car, but in the woods. She had been raped and then killed. Her throat was slashed. Afterward the killer covered her naked body up with boards.

Andy was found tied to a tree, his throat also slashed.

Andy, oh my goodness, he was almost decapitated
... it s just horrific, said Colvert.

That was my son tied to that tree, said Andy s father Garland Atkinson. What was he saying? Was he calling me? Was he calling his mother?

Atkinson also recalls what police investigators told him: They surmised that Andy let them tie him to a tree and that they know that the girl was killed first which means he was tied to a tree and listened to her scream, listened to her being murdered knowing that they were going to do the same thing to him and he couldn' t do anything about it. "


"..police found a golf club in a field and three golf balls, one lined up after the other, pointing the way to Cheryl s body. Were they left by the unknown suspect and if so, why?

Or how about the four partially-deflated balloons they found tied to the tree above Cheryl s body? There was also a crisp $20 bill next to her. Did the killer leave these, too?

In the meantime, Belk muses.

Sometimes I think they were targeted he says. Cheryl was tied up more than Andy was even though he was tied to a tree. She put up a fight.

Sometimes I wonder if there are two or three suspects, Belk said."
 
Last edited:
  • #720
rbbm.
New clues in grisly Lover's Lane Murders
"The KHOU 11 News I-Team dug up a suspect profile that the FBI put together several years ago. It reveals that profilers believed the suspect may have known Cheryl or Andy or both.

It also states that the covering of Cheryl s body speaks of a prior personal relationship and that the suspect may not have intentionally meant to kill Andy.

Other suggestions from the report include:

*The unknown suspect was about the age of the victims

* He has an above average intelligence level, but is a low achiever.


*The suspect may have been interviewed by police at one time."

"But about five years ago, the Harris County Sheriff s Department entered a DNA profile found at an unsolved burglary/rape that had actually been committed months BEFORE the killings of Cheryl and Andy."
"In her first-ever interview, this rape victim revealed the details of her attack to the KHOU 11 News I-Team.

It was probably 2:30am and I walked upstairs and this guy was up in my bedroom, said the victim. He was wearing a blue uniform of some type.

The woman, who had just returned home from her job at Gigi s nightclub, said her attacker was asking for her boyfriend and said he owed him money.

Meanwhile, her rapist put her hands behind her back and wrapped them with duct tape. He placed a bag over her head and put a gun to her throat.

He kept pulling the trigger. He cocked it. He d uncock it and then 🤬🤬🤬🤬 it, she said. He had a black fishnet thing over his head. He was probably six foot two, 200 pounds, olive complexion and black hair.

Eventually, the woman s attacker took $250 from her home and left.

The victim said she s always thought it could be connected to her moving company. She said one of her movers had recently threatened her life.

I think it had to do with this moving company I had an altercation with, she said.

That theory has never been proven by police."
 

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
142
Guests online
3,022
Total visitors
3,164

Forum statistics

Threads
632,115
Messages
18,622,316
Members
243,026
Latest member
JC_MacLeod
Back
Top