TX - Former NFL Antonio Armstrong & wife Dawn, both 42, fatally shot, Houston, *son charged* 29 Jul 2016 *Mistrials, 3rd trial in 2023 Guilty*

  • #181
Courtney Fischer‏Verified account @CourtneyABC13
STANDBY: The jury has just alerted the judge. After nearly 20 hrs of deliberation. It’s been abt 4 hrs since Judge Kelli Johnson read the jurors the Allen Charge, asking them to keep deliberating.
 
  • #182
Waiting to go live on ktrk.com......just got alert that the jury has returned to the courtroom.....
 
  • #183
  • #184
Well, can’t say they didn’t try.....
I wonder what the prosecution will do now.
I suppose it depends on how the vote went.
They will let us know what the vote was, right?
 
  • #185
Courtney Fischer on Twitter

Judge reminds AJ’s attorneys AJ is still under house arrest and must be back at court on Monday @ 9am. #abc13 #breaking
 
  • #186
This is BS

@CourtneyABC13
Judge reminds AJ’s attorneys AJ is still under house arrest and must be back at court on Monday @ 9am. #abc13 #breaking
 
  • #187
So is this

Courtney Fischer‏Verified account @CourtneyABC13
STATEMENT FROM PROSECUTOR WHO TRIED THE AJ ARMSTRONG CASE: “We appreciate the tremendous effort by the jury. Antonio Armstrong Jr. murdered two citizens of our county and we will continue to fight for justice and bring him to trial again,” ADA John Brewer said. #abc13 #breaking
 
  • #188
  • #189
I dont know how anyone could say beyond a reasonable doubt that he did it.
 
  • #190
I hope the prosecution will rethink the statement that they will retry this based on the split.
I know this is disappointing to AJ and his family, but perhaps they can be encouraged that the majority of the jurors had reasonable doubt.
 
  • #191
  • #192
You know, if the prosecution is so sure he did it, I would be willing to consider it if they can SHOW me evidence of an evil conniving son with a questionable character. But the people they put on the stand did not even hint at that. And having his family support him said a lot to me. The most the state offered were text messages that sounded like a family with problems, but not unlike 80% of the families I know, mine included, at some point in their children’s lives.
 
Last edited:
  • #193
In my opinion, the text messages showed a typical teenager. The messages are like of any of us with teenage children. It sounded so typical to me that it seemed unimportant.
 
  • #194
  • #195
  • #196
  • #197
Looks like their "source" last night had the NG and G backwards. That sucks.

Oh wow. I skipped right over there. Even if people think he is probably guilty there is reasonable doubt and the case hasn't been "proven".
 
  • #198
  • #199
Well I applaud the 4 that stuck to their beliefs that there was reasonable doubt in the case presented if that split is accurate. So many times we hear about cases that evidence LE brings to the DA is deemed ‘not enough’ to go to trial. The old adage of getting just one bite at the apple to convict is bandied about and the cops are asked to go get more evidence. And yet we occasionally see trials where not much evidence is presented to make a case. It has surprised me that the son was accused and arrested quickly and this case went to trial when so little pointed to the accused. I am glad there was a mistrial, but I wonder what will be different if they try it again.
 
  • #200
When I heard the prosecution's opening statements, I thought it was an open and shut case proving AJ's guilt because they emphasized that no one else could have entered the house; the security alarms were set. I didn't even listen to the defense's statements because I was convinced they didn't have a case.

At first, I was also disgusted that the defense was pointing at Dawn's older son as a suspect. Then, I read the reasons they were pointing to him: he didn't get along with his mother and stepfather; he was jealous of his half-siblings; he moved out of the house only a couple of weeks before the murders due to the tension there. Have LE looked at him thoroughly? Did he still have a key to the house? Did he know how to disarm the security alarm?

I think the defense did raise reasonable doubt as to AJ's guilt, so I'm also relieved by the mistrial. I hope this other angle is investigated further before the case goes to trial again. I don't think the "prostitution ring" angle is credible, though.

I also want to know more about the bullet hole in AJ's closet. I initially understood that the bullet went through a pillow and a comforter in the closet. More recently, I read that there was a pile of socks covering the bullet hole. Did investigators find the bullet? Did it penetrate the floor and the ceiling below (did they determine the shot couldn't have been fired from below)? Is it possible the killer was looking for AJ and thought he was hiding in the closet?

Still so man questions, and AJ does seem like a nice kid (young man now). I agree with other posters that there wasn't enough evidence to convict him.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
90
Guests online
1,632
Total visitors
1,722

Forum statistics

Threads
632,760
Messages
18,631,349
Members
243,283
Latest member
emilyc1224
Back
Top