Found Deceased UK - Lindsay Birbeck, 47, Accrington, 12 Aug 2019 *Arrest* #3

[Mind your biscuits]

as for Lindsays missing belongings....how likely is it there would be incinerators etc on the caravan site? google maps doesn't zoom all the way in but looks like theres multiple ways of disposing of items

Lol As someone who lived near a 'site' for years, I can tell you that they like to burn stuff. Moo.

 

[Mind your biscuits]

Who do you think killed Lindsay (as in the actual murder, not including any possible cover-up help)?
(please add your username and repost)

The Defendant:
MusicalMonkey, Bampot, Mind Your Biscuits

The Hooded Man:


A Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Sunflower22

Combination of The Defendant and The Hooded Man:


Combination of The Defendant and Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Ann Blyth

Someone else (please state):

 

[Loulou38]

So this case has been stop starting a lot throughout, I can't help but think something more has been going on behind the scenes, what's peoples thoughts on this?

I dont know if people agree but I don't understand how members of the public can be concerned over finding a bin yet the police wasnt? Also lindsay was possibly already in the cemetery by then so how was she not found? I still don't understand how she was just a missing person for so long when it was seriously out of character for her. ☹

 

[Loulou38]

A general purpose police dog, often a German Shepherd, is a ground scenting/trail dog. They are trained to pick up the strongest, freshest human scent and follow it, often with the intention to track an offender and 'detain' them.

If it was a general purpose police dog that was being used then it would have been of limited use in finding a body. Therefore the presence of the dog may have just been coincidental as the officer searched and for community reassurance.

Ideally, a specialist search dog with cadaver scenting skills would be required. If there are any such dogs available in UK police forces they will be few and far between based on the demand/cost curve. Such dogs are used by some search and rescue teams and are available from private companies.

What I do wonder is if a cadaver dog was used to try and identify if/where LB's body was stored in the Whitakers Arms/chicken sheds/coppice area prior to being moved to the cemetery.

And someone dog from the general public found her ☹

 

[Tortoise]

Just wondering if we can have a roll call. Just for interest purposes. The trial will come to a conclusion next week. So based on what we know so far and also your hunches/theories:

Who do you think killed Lindsay (as in the actual murder, not including any possible cover-up help)?
(please add your username and repost)

The Defendant:


The Hooded Man:


A Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Tortoise

Combination of The Defendant and The Hooded Man:


Combination of The Defendant and Family Member or Close Known Associate:


Someone else (please state):


Edit: I'll clean up the tally when I go through the messages and then repost.

see above

 

[Ann Blyth]

So this case has been stop starting a lot throughout, I can't help but think something more has been going on behind the scenes, what's peoples thoughts on this?

I dont know if people agree but I don't understand how members of the public can be concerned over finding a bin yet the police wasnt? Also lindsay was possibly already in the cemetery by then so how was she not found? I still don't understand how she was just a missing person for so long when it was seriously out of character for her. ☹

I know, I couldn’t believe that no-one was missing their wheelie bin, then it was pointed out to me, I think by Alyce that a recycling site which had loads of those bins was nearby!

 

[Loulou38]

I know, I couldn’t believe that no-one was missing their wheelie bin, then it was pointed out to me, I think by Alyce that a recycling site which had loads of those bins was nearby!

I'm not really referring to just a missing bin.. its everything else that's important.

 

[Ann Blyth]

its all a bit of a mess, from day one of the investigation really.

 

[Niner]

Poll by MusicalMonkey:

Who do you think killed Lindsay (as in the actual murder, not including any possible cover-up help)?
(please add your username and repost)

The Defendant:
MusicalMonkey
Bampot
Dcflag
Mind your biscuits
Niner

The Hooded Man:


A Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Sunflower22
Rosegold68
Tortoise

Combination of The Defendant and The Hooded Man:


Combination of The Defendant and Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Ann Blyth

Someone else (please state):

 

[SpursGyal]

Poll by MusicalMonkey:

Who do you think killed Lindsay (as in the actual murder, not including any possible cover-up help)?
(please add your username and repost)

The Defendant:
MusicalMonkey
Bampot
Dcflag
Mind your biscuits
Niner
SpursGyal

The Hooded Man:


A Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Sunflower22
Rosegold68
Tortoise

Combination of The Defendant and The Hooded Man:


Combination of The Defendant and Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Ann Blyth

Someone else (please state):

 

[Legally Bland]

Poll by MusicalMonkey:

Who do you think killed Lindsay (as in the actual murder, not including any possible cover-up help)?
(please add your username and repost)

The Defendant:
MusicalMonkey
Bampot
Dcflag
Mind your biscuits
Niner
SpursGyal
Legally Bland

The Hooded Man:


A Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Sunflower22
Rosegold68
Tortoise

Combination of The Defendant and The Hooded Man:


Combination of The Defendant and Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Ann Blyth

Someone else (please state):

 

[Roostercat]

Lol As someone who lived near a 'site' for years, I can tell you that they like to burn stuff. Moo.

There was evidence of a man made fire in the outbuildings during the search which took place on Friday 23rd. But I have seen youths in those buildings before LB went missing and after do could be attributed to ASB

 

[Roostercat]

Poll by MusicalMonkey:

Who do you think killed Lindsay (as in the actual murder, not including any possible cover-up help)?
(please add your username and repost)

The Defendant:
MusicalMonkey
Bampot
Dcflag
Mind your biscuits
Niner
SpursGyal
Legally Bland
Roostercat

The Hooded Man:


A Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Sunflower22
Rosegold68
Tortoise

Combination of The Defendant and The Hooded Man:


Combination of The Defendant and Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Ann Blyth

Someone else (please state):

 

[Ann Blyth]

I’m in the minority then!

 

[Sara20]

MusicalMonkey:

Who do you think killed Lindsay (as in the actual murder, not including any possible cover-up help)?
(please add your username and repost)

The Defendant:
MusicalMonkey
Bampot
Dcflag
Mind your biscuits
Niner
SpursGyal
Legally Bland
Roostercat
Sara20
The Hooded Man:


A Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Sunflower22
Rosegold68
Tortoise

Combination of The Defendant and The Hooded Man:


Combination of The Defendant and Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Ann Blyth

Someone else (please state):

 

[Roostercat]

Lindsay Birbeck murder trial: Teachers, CCTV and the evidence from week 2
Not sure if this has been posted already. Full update of week 2

 

[Ann Blyth]

Next week will be interesting.....

 

[Alyce]

MusicalMonkey:

Who do you think killed Lindsay (as in the actual murder, not including any possible cover-up help)?
(please add your username and repost)

The Defendant:
MusicalMonkey
Bampot
Dcflag
Mind your biscuits
Niner
SpursGyal
Legally Bland
Roostercat
Sara20



The Hooded Man:



A Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Sunflower22
Rosegold68
Tortoise
Alyce



Combination of The Defendant and The Hooded Man:


Combination of The Defendant and Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Ann Blyth


Someone else (please state):

 

[Loulou38]

MusicalMonkey:

Who do you think killed Lindsay (as in the actual murder, not including any possible cover-up help)?
(please add your username and repost)

The Defendant:
MusicalMonkey
Bampot
Dcflag
Mind your biscuits
Niner
SpursGyal
Legally Bland
Roostercat
Sara20
LouLou38


The Hooded Man:



A Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Sunflower22
Rosegold68
Tortoise
Alyce



Combination of The Defendant and The Hooded Man:


Combination of The Defendant and Family Member or Close Known Associate:
Ann Blyth


Someone else (please state):

 

[Bampot]

This poll is very encouraging for me. I really believe the evidence in the court room will sound a lot more compelling than it does to us. Zoe in the stand for instance , just reading the text wasn't really hard hitting. But I believe it would be in the court room, as with all the other evidence.