As if he's doing the family a favour
Exactly! The hubris of the man! I'm practically frothing at the mouth over here
GUILTY UK - Michelle, 36, Demi, 14, Brandon, 8, Lacie, 7, & Lia Pearson, 3, die in arson fire, 11 Dec 2017
- Thread starter DakotaMayi
- Start date
Exactly! The hubris of the man! I'm practically frothing at the mouth over here
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
12:54TODD FITZGERALD
Defendant speaks of his reaction after hearing fire proved fatal
Bolland says when he heard people had died in the fire he sat with 'my head in my hands', and said 'what have I done?'.
He said he decided to hand himself in.
Mr Reid says to Bolland: "The jury in the first trial concluded that you intended to kill anyone who was in the house."
"Yes, but that's not the case," he replies.
13:00TODD FITZGERALD
Lunch break
Bolland has now concluded his evidence.
The jury is leaving court for lunch.
LIVE updates as two men on trial accused of murdering Michelle Pearson
Defendant speaks of his reaction after hearing fire proved fatal
Bolland says when he heard people had died in the fire he sat with 'my head in my hands', and said 'what have I done?'.
He said he decided to hand himself in.
Mr Reid says to Bolland: "The jury in the first trial concluded that you intended to kill anyone who was in the house."
"Yes, but that's not the case," he replies.
13:00TODD FITZGERALD
Lunch break
Bolland has now concluded his evidence.
The jury is leaving court for lunch.
LIVE updates as two men on trial accused of murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
14:20TODD FITZGERALD
Hearing resumes - as David Worrall enters witness box
The jury have now returned to court after the lunch break.
David Worrall is now sat in the witness box.
He is about to start giving evidence under questioning from his barrister, Benjamin Myers QC.
14:33TODD FITZGERALD
'I thought we were just going to cause some damage to the rear of the property, and the people would be able to get out of the front', defendant says
Worrall says he thought there might be people in the house in the early hours of December 11.
He said he thought he and Bolland were going to damage property.
"What on earth did you think you were doing?" Mr Myers asked.
"I thought we were just going to cause some damage to the rear of the property, and the people would be able to get out of the front," he said.
Mr Myers asked: "Were you thinking at all?"
"Not really," Worrall said.
14:34TODD FITZGERALD
'I was terrified of the situation that I was in'
Worrall admitted telling 'quite a lot of lies' in his interview with police after being arrested.
Asked why, he said: "Because I was terrified of the situation that I was in."
Mr Myers asks: "At your last trial, did you tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?"
Worrall says he didn't, he said he couldn't 'accept what I had done'.
"I was scared of losing my life basically."
14:42TODD FITZGERALD
Worrall says he is 'heartbroken'
Worrall says he is 'heartbroken' following what happened at Jackson Street.
Mr Myers asks: "Are you ready to accept your responsibility now?"
"Yes I am," he says.
Worrall says he doesn't accept throwing a petrol bomb into the house.
He says he accepts 'supporting' Bolland in 'what he was doing'.
Jurors are told that at the first trial, Worrall said he thought they would set fire to a bin.
Mr Myers asks if he thought they were going to set fire to a bin.
"No, it was obvious what was going to happen," Worrall said.
Worrall says he is guilty of manslaughter, not murder.
Mr Myers asks: "When you involved yourself in this, did you intend that anyone should die?"
"No, never," said Worrall.
Jurors are told that at the first trial, Worrall was convicted on the basis that he 'intended serious harm'.
"Did you intend serious harm?" asked Mr Myers.
"No, I did not," Worrall says.
"I thought they would be able to make safe passage from the front of the property.
14:51TODD FITZGERALD
Worrall says he was in the pub during the day
Worrall says he had been in the pub with friends watching the Manchester derby on December 10, 2017.
He had been planning on going to another pub to play pool later.
He says one of his friends later contacted Bolland before going to his home.
LIVE updates as two men on trial accused of murdering Michelle Pearson
Hearing resumes - as David Worrall enters witness box
The jury have now returned to court after the lunch break.
David Worrall is now sat in the witness box.
He is about to start giving evidence under questioning from his barrister, Benjamin Myers QC.
14:33TODD FITZGERALD
'I thought we were just going to cause some damage to the rear of the property, and the people would be able to get out of the front', defendant says
Worrall says he thought there might be people in the house in the early hours of December 11.
He said he thought he and Bolland were going to damage property.
"What on earth did you think you were doing?" Mr Myers asked.
"I thought we were just going to cause some damage to the rear of the property, and the people would be able to get out of the front," he said.
Mr Myers asked: "Were you thinking at all?"
"Not really," Worrall said.
14:34TODD FITZGERALD
'I was terrified of the situation that I was in'
Worrall admitted telling 'quite a lot of lies' in his interview with police after being arrested.
Asked why, he said: "Because I was terrified of the situation that I was in."
Mr Myers asks: "At your last trial, did you tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?"
Worrall says he didn't, he said he couldn't 'accept what I had done'.
"I was scared of losing my life basically."
14:42TODD FITZGERALD
Worrall says he is 'heartbroken'
Worrall says he is 'heartbroken' following what happened at Jackson Street.
Mr Myers asks: "Are you ready to accept your responsibility now?"
"Yes I am," he says.
Worrall says he doesn't accept throwing a petrol bomb into the house.
He says he accepts 'supporting' Bolland in 'what he was doing'.
Jurors are told that at the first trial, Worrall said he thought they would set fire to a bin.
Mr Myers asks if he thought they were going to set fire to a bin.
"No, it was obvious what was going to happen," Worrall said.
Worrall says he is guilty of manslaughter, not murder.
Mr Myers asks: "When you involved yourself in this, did you intend that anyone should die?"
"No, never," said Worrall.
Jurors are told that at the first trial, Worrall was convicted on the basis that he 'intended serious harm'.
"Did you intend serious harm?" asked Mr Myers.
"No, I did not," Worrall says.
"I thought they would be able to make safe passage from the front of the property.
14:51TODD FITZGERALD
Worrall says he was in the pub during the day
Worrall says he had been in the pub with friends watching the Manchester derby on December 10, 2017.
He had been planning on going to another pub to play pool later.
He says one of his friends later contacted Bolland before going to his home.
LIVE updates as two men on trial accused of murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
15:07TODD FITZGERALD
Worrall said he wasn't expecting trouble
Worrall said he had drank five or six pints before arriving at Bolland's house, and they carried on drinking.
He said he wasn't expecting any trouble.
Worrall said he didn't have any personal involvement with the dispute between Bolland and the Pearson family before December 11.
He said he knew Bolland was having 'trouble' with someone but didn't know who.
15:12TODD FITZGERALD
Worrall says Bolland told them 'some lads owed him some money for his car'
Worrall said that Bolland told them 'some lads owed him some money for his car'.
He admitted using cocaine as well as drinking.
He said Bolland asked him to go to Jackson Street with him, at around 12.40am on December 11.
Worrall said he hit the door of the house with a metal pole.
He said Bolland was telling Michelle Pearson to get her sons outside, but she said they weren't there.
15:16TODD FITZGERALD
'I was becoming extremely drunk', Worrall tells court
Worrall said he had drunk five or six pints at the pub and 'near enough' 10 bottles of Budweiser by the early hours.
"I was becoming extremely drunk," he said.
He said back at Bolland's home, Bolland was 'quite angry' about damage to his property.
Abigail Toone arrived looking for her boyfriend at about 2am.
Worrall says he wasn't expecting any further trouble involving the Pearsons.
He said he decided to stay carry on drinking, buying up more alcohol from a petrol station.
15:31TODD FITZGERALD
'I assumed it was just going to be another addition to the petty tit for tat stuff'
Worrall said Courtney Brierley started making phone calls having an argument with a woman said to be connected to the Pearsons.
Brierley was 'shouting' and 'raising her voice', he said.
He said at times Bolland was 'getting hold of the phone'.
Worrall says they got the impression that Kyle (Pearson), Lewis (Pearson) and Luke (Fleming) were at Jackson Street.
He said Bolland produced a green petrol can and asked Abigail Toone to 'run him to the petrol station'.
"I knew it was going to be some kind of fire," Worrall said.
"I assumed it was just going to be another addition to the petty tit for tat stuff."
Worrall said he was 'really drunk' and was 'just going along with it'.
15:34TODD FITZGERALD
'I just thought he was going to do some damage to the property'
They went to a petrol station in Farnworth.
Worrall said Bolland asked him to come with him on the petrol station forecourt.
Bolland bought £1.50 worth of petrol.
Back at Bolland's home, Worrall said he saw Bolland 'decanting petrol into a bottle'.
Worrall said: "I just thought he was going to do some damage to the property."
LIVE updates as two men on trial accused of murdering Michelle Pearson
Worrall said he wasn't expecting trouble
Worrall said he had drank five or six pints before arriving at Bolland's house, and they carried on drinking.
He said he wasn't expecting any trouble.
Worrall said he didn't have any personal involvement with the dispute between Bolland and the Pearson family before December 11.
He said he knew Bolland was having 'trouble' with someone but didn't know who.
15:12TODD FITZGERALD
Worrall says Bolland told them 'some lads owed him some money for his car'
Worrall said that Bolland told them 'some lads owed him some money for his car'.
He admitted using cocaine as well as drinking.
He said Bolland asked him to go to Jackson Street with him, at around 12.40am on December 11.
Worrall said he hit the door of the house with a metal pole.
He said Bolland was telling Michelle Pearson to get her sons outside, but she said they weren't there.
15:16TODD FITZGERALD
'I was becoming extremely drunk', Worrall tells court
Worrall said he had drunk five or six pints at the pub and 'near enough' 10 bottles of Budweiser by the early hours.
"I was becoming extremely drunk," he said.
He said back at Bolland's home, Bolland was 'quite angry' about damage to his property.
Abigail Toone arrived looking for her boyfriend at about 2am.
Worrall says he wasn't expecting any further trouble involving the Pearsons.
He said he decided to stay carry on drinking, buying up more alcohol from a petrol station.
15:31TODD FITZGERALD
'I assumed it was just going to be another addition to the petty tit for tat stuff'
Worrall said Courtney Brierley started making phone calls having an argument with a woman said to be connected to the Pearsons.
Brierley was 'shouting' and 'raising her voice', he said.
He said at times Bolland was 'getting hold of the phone'.
Worrall says they got the impression that Kyle (Pearson), Lewis (Pearson) and Luke (Fleming) were at Jackson Street.
He said Bolland produced a green petrol can and asked Abigail Toone to 'run him to the petrol station'.
"I knew it was going to be some kind of fire," Worrall said.
"I assumed it was just going to be another addition to the petty tit for tat stuff."
Worrall said he was 'really drunk' and was 'just going along with it'.
15:34TODD FITZGERALD
'I just thought he was going to do some damage to the property'
They went to a petrol station in Farnworth.
Worrall said Bolland asked him to come with him on the petrol station forecourt.
Bolland bought £1.50 worth of petrol.
Back at Bolland's home, Worrall said he saw Bolland 'decanting petrol into a bottle'.
Worrall said: "I just thought he was going to do some damage to the property."
LIVE updates as two men on trial accused of murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
15:37TODD FITZGERALD
Worrall says he was given an axe by Bolland
Worrall denies asking Bolland for one of the two bottles.
He said he was given an axe by Bolland and thought it would be used to 'frighten people'.
15:44TODD FITZGERALD
'I was drunk and was being an absolute idiot, and it has had tragic consequences'
Worrall said that when they arrived at Jackson Street it became 'apparent' that Bolland was 'going to throw the petrol bombs into the kitchen.
He said he thought it would 'frighten people' and that people in the house would be able to 'run out of the front'.
"I was drunk and was being an absolute idiot, and it has had tragic consequences," Worrall says.
LIVE updates as two men on trial accused of murdering Michelle Pearson
Worrall says he was given an axe by Bolland
Worrall denies asking Bolland for one of the two bottles.
He said he was given an axe by Bolland and thought it would be used to 'frighten people'.
15:44TODD FITZGERALD
'I was drunk and was being an absolute idiot, and it has had tragic consequences'
Worrall said that when they arrived at Jackson Street it became 'apparent' that Bolland was 'going to throw the petrol bombs into the kitchen.
He said he thought it would 'frighten people' and that people in the house would be able to 'run out of the front'.
"I was drunk and was being an absolute idiot, and it has had tragic consequences," Worrall says.
LIVE updates as two men on trial accused of murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
15:47TODD FITZGERALD
Worrall says he was 'shocked'
Worrall said he began to leave after he said Bolland threw the first petrol bomb.
He said he then realised it was 'serious' and was 'shocked'.
15:55TODD FITZGERALD
Worrall says he was 'terrified' and 'panicking'
Worrall says he was 'terrified' and 'panicking' when he got back to the car.
He denies saying 'that was real weren't it' and saying it like he 'enjoyed it'.
"I most definitely didn't," Worrall said.
Worrall said Bolland called him a 'sh** bag' because he had 'run away'.
16:12TODD FITZGERALD
Defendant emotional in the witness box
The next day Worrall had agreed to help his friend's girlfriend move house.
In the car he heard on the radio that there had been a 'serious fire' in Walkden.
He said he was 'terrified' and 'started to cry'.
Worrall said he told his friend he 'knew who had done it', telling him it was 'Zak'.
His friend asked how he knew, Worrall said he had been with him.
Worrall, appearing visibly emotional in the witness box, says he was 'devastated' after hearing on the news that people had died in the fire.
"Who for?" asks Mr Myers.
Worrall says: "Myself, for being involved in it."
Mr Myers continues: "What about the people in the fire?"
Worrall says: "Obviously I felt for them but at the time I was being selfish and thinking of myself."
16:12TODD FITZGERALD
Jury sent home for the day
The jury has been sent home for the day.
LIVE updates as two men on trial accused of murdering Michelle Pearson
Worrall says he was 'shocked'
Worrall said he began to leave after he said Bolland threw the first petrol bomb.
He said he then realised it was 'serious' and was 'shocked'.
15:55TODD FITZGERALD
Worrall says he was 'terrified' and 'panicking'
Worrall says he was 'terrified' and 'panicking' when he got back to the car.
He denies saying 'that was real weren't it' and saying it like he 'enjoyed it'.
"I most definitely didn't," Worrall said.
Worrall said Bolland called him a 'sh** bag' because he had 'run away'.
16:12TODD FITZGERALD
Defendant emotional in the witness box
The next day Worrall had agreed to help his friend's girlfriend move house.
In the car he heard on the radio that there had been a 'serious fire' in Walkden.
He said he was 'terrified' and 'started to cry'.
Worrall said he told his friend he 'knew who had done it', telling him it was 'Zak'.
His friend asked how he knew, Worrall said he had been with him.
Worrall, appearing visibly emotional in the witness box, says he was 'devastated' after hearing on the news that people had died in the fire.
"Who for?" asks Mr Myers.
Worrall says: "Myself, for being involved in it."
Mr Myers continues: "What about the people in the fire?"
Worrall says: "Obviously I felt for them but at the time I was being selfish and thinking of myself."
16:12TODD FITZGERALD
Jury sent home for the day
The jury has been sent home for the day.
LIVE updates as two men on trial accused of murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
10:14ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall told 'lot of lies' in his police interview after arrest, court hears
The jury has returned to court and the trial is continuing.
David Worrall is in the witness box to give evidence for a second day.
He is being questioned by his barrister Benjamin Myers QC.
Mr Myers is asking Worrall about his interview with police after being arrested.
Worrall says he didn't admit to police that he had 'played a part' in the incident.
Worrall said he was 'scared' and that he 'wasn't ready to admit' his role.
He was crying during the interview, jurors hear.
"I was absolutely devastated about what had happened, I was terrified," he said.
Worrall says it has been 'very difficult' to admit his involvement.
He said: "It is absolutely horrendous what had happened, no one deserved what had happened."
Worrall admits telling 'lots of lies' during the interview.
10:15ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall admits he believed petrol bomb would be thrown into house
In the interview Worrall told officers he believed a bin would be set on fire.
Now Worrall admits when they got to Jackson Street he believed Bolland would throw a petrol bomb into the house.
"I was scared of admitting I knew he was going to throw it into the kitchen," he says.
Mr Myers asks: "Are you suggesting to the jury in this trial that you did things because you were scared of Zak Bolland?"
Worrall says he was acting with his 'own free will'.
Mr Myers continues: "Were you thinking through where your own free will was taking you?"
"Not really, no," Worrall says.
10:30ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall says he was 'following along' but admits persistently lying about his involvement
Worrall says he told the officers the truth when he said he was 'following along like an idiot'.
He tells jurors he didn't intend for anyone to be killed or harmed, and says 'I wasn't thinking straight'.
"I just involved myself in something that had nothing to do with me," he says.
Worrall is now being questioned by Mark Ford QC, Bolland's barrister.
Mr Ford asks: "Do you agree that following the fire, you lied persistently about your involvement?"
"Yes I did," Worrall says.
Mr Ford continues: "Do you agree that in the course of doing so, you tried to blame everything on Zak Bolland?"
"Yes I did," Worrall says.
Mr Ford says: "Do you agree that in order to avoid blame and responsibility for your actions, you did everything you could to give a misleading impression of yourself to the police?"
"Yes I did," Worrall says.
Worrall agrees that at the first trial he denied murder and manslaughter.
10:55ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall denies 'only admitting what he thinks he can get away with'
Mr Ford asks: "Isn't the reality of your position that you admit only what you think you can get away with?"
"No," says Worrall.
Mr Ford asks Worrall why he got out of the car when Bolland went to buy petrol.
"Because I didn't think he was going to do anything as serious as it turned out," Worrall replied.
Mr Ford asks Worrall why did he 'conceal his appearance' at the petrol station by having his hood up.
Worrall said he didn't want to be seen, adding: "I thought he was at least going to cause criminal damage."
11:25ANDREW BARDSLEY
Jury leaving court for a short break
The jury is leaving court for a short break.
Trial of men charged with murdering mum in fire that left children dead- updates
Worrall told 'lot of lies' in his police interview after arrest, court hears
The jury has returned to court and the trial is continuing.
David Worrall is in the witness box to give evidence for a second day.
He is being questioned by his barrister Benjamin Myers QC.
Mr Myers is asking Worrall about his interview with police after being arrested.
Worrall says he didn't admit to police that he had 'played a part' in the incident.
Worrall said he was 'scared' and that he 'wasn't ready to admit' his role.
He was crying during the interview, jurors hear.
"I was absolutely devastated about what had happened, I was terrified," he said.
Worrall says it has been 'very difficult' to admit his involvement.
He said: "It is absolutely horrendous what had happened, no one deserved what had happened."
Worrall admits telling 'lots of lies' during the interview.
10:15ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall admits he believed petrol bomb would be thrown into house
In the interview Worrall told officers he believed a bin would be set on fire.
Now Worrall admits when they got to Jackson Street he believed Bolland would throw a petrol bomb into the house.
"I was scared of admitting I knew he was going to throw it into the kitchen," he says.
Mr Myers asks: "Are you suggesting to the jury in this trial that you did things because you were scared of Zak Bolland?"
Worrall says he was acting with his 'own free will'.
Mr Myers continues: "Were you thinking through where your own free will was taking you?"
"Not really, no," Worrall says.
10:30ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall says he was 'following along' but admits persistently lying about his involvement
Worrall says he told the officers the truth when he said he was 'following along like an idiot'.
He tells jurors he didn't intend for anyone to be killed or harmed, and says 'I wasn't thinking straight'.
"I just involved myself in something that had nothing to do with me," he says.
Worrall is now being questioned by Mark Ford QC, Bolland's barrister.
Mr Ford asks: "Do you agree that following the fire, you lied persistently about your involvement?"
"Yes I did," Worrall says.
Mr Ford continues: "Do you agree that in the course of doing so, you tried to blame everything on Zak Bolland?"
"Yes I did," Worrall says.
Mr Ford says: "Do you agree that in order to avoid blame and responsibility for your actions, you did everything you could to give a misleading impression of yourself to the police?"
"Yes I did," Worrall says.
Worrall agrees that at the first trial he denied murder and manslaughter.
10:55ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall denies 'only admitting what he thinks he can get away with'
Mr Ford asks: "Isn't the reality of your position that you admit only what you think you can get away with?"
"No," says Worrall.
Mr Ford asks Worrall why he got out of the car when Bolland went to buy petrol.
"Because I didn't think he was going to do anything as serious as it turned out," Worrall replied.
Mr Ford asks Worrall why did he 'conceal his appearance' at the petrol station by having his hood up.
Worrall said he didn't want to be seen, adding: "I thought he was at least going to cause criminal damage."
11:25ANDREW BARDSLEY
Jury leaving court for a short break
The jury is leaving court for a short break.
Trial of men charged with murdering mum in fire that left children dead- updates
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
11:51ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall had axe 'for self defence, trial hears
The jury is back in court and the case is continuing.
Jurors are told Worrall says he had an axe in the early hours of December 11 for 'self defence'.
Mr Ford says: "For that explanation to work, you had to tell the police you thought there were people in the house, didn't you?"
"Yes," replies Worrall.
"I'm going to suggest you didn't think there were people in the house," Mr Ford says.
"I did," says Worrall.
12:16ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall accused of being an 'habitual liar'
Mr Ford puts it to Worrall that he is a 'habitual liar'.
"I was at that time, yes," Worrall replies.
Mr Ford adds: "As each lie is revealed, you have had to come up with an alternative explanation."
"No," Worrall replies.
Mr Ford has said that in an interview with police Worrall admitted helping Bolland lift up a fence panel at Jackson Street, and now he says it was Bolland who lifted the panel.
Mr Ford said that Worrall told police there was one bottle, while now saying there were two.
12:18ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall 'having another go' to get himself off murder charge
Prosecutor Paul Reid QC is now cross-examining Worrall.
Mr Reid puts it to Worrall: "Your reason for lying to the first jury was to try to get yourself off murder."
"Yes," says Worrall.
Mr Reid claims Worrall is going through the 'same process' at this trial.
He says: "You are having another go, aren't you?"
Worrall says: "I'm not guilty of murder, so I'm not going to admit to something I am not guilty of."
12:37ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall denies throwing petrol bomb
Mr Reid asks Worrall why he had a 'change of heart' and, in a defence statement submitted in March, admitted he was guilty of manslaughter.
"Because that's what I am guilty of," Worrall says.
Mr Reid says: "Or was it really a realisation by you that it really would be asking too much to ask a second jury to find you not guilty altogether?"
"No," Worrall says.
Mr Reid is asking Worrall about a comment he made in his police interview.
Worrall said he left Jackson Street and told officers: "I can't be a part of this when there's kids in the house."
Worrall said he agreed there 'could have been' children in the house.
Mr Reid puts it to Worrall that he threw one petrol bomb, which he denies.
12:48ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall denies petrol bomb involvement - despite co-defendant's claims
Mr Reid says that Zak Bolland and Abigail Toone said Worrall had a bottle.
The prosecutor says: "In this case he (Bolland) is right isn't he, that both of you had petrol bombs when you came in the car?"
"No, he's wrong," Worrall says.
Worrall denies being involved in the preparation of the petrol bombs.
Bolland said Worrall held a bottle while he poured in the petrol.
The jury is leaving court for lunch.
Trial of men charged with murdering mum in fire that left children dead- updates
Worrall had axe 'for self defence, trial hears
The jury is back in court and the case is continuing.
Jurors are told Worrall says he had an axe in the early hours of December 11 for 'self defence'.
Mr Ford says: "For that explanation to work, you had to tell the police you thought there were people in the house, didn't you?"
"Yes," replies Worrall.
"I'm going to suggest you didn't think there were people in the house," Mr Ford says.
"I did," says Worrall.
12:16ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall accused of being an 'habitual liar'
Mr Ford puts it to Worrall that he is a 'habitual liar'.
"I was at that time, yes," Worrall replies.
Mr Ford adds: "As each lie is revealed, you have had to come up with an alternative explanation."
"No," Worrall replies.
Mr Ford has said that in an interview with police Worrall admitted helping Bolland lift up a fence panel at Jackson Street, and now he says it was Bolland who lifted the panel.
Mr Ford said that Worrall told police there was one bottle, while now saying there were two.
12:18ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall 'having another go' to get himself off murder charge
Prosecutor Paul Reid QC is now cross-examining Worrall.
Mr Reid puts it to Worrall: "Your reason for lying to the first jury was to try to get yourself off murder."
"Yes," says Worrall.
Mr Reid claims Worrall is going through the 'same process' at this trial.
He says: "You are having another go, aren't you?"
Worrall says: "I'm not guilty of murder, so I'm not going to admit to something I am not guilty of."
12:37ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall denies throwing petrol bomb
Mr Reid asks Worrall why he had a 'change of heart' and, in a defence statement submitted in March, admitted he was guilty of manslaughter.
"Because that's what I am guilty of," Worrall says.
Mr Reid says: "Or was it really a realisation by you that it really would be asking too much to ask a second jury to find you not guilty altogether?"
"No," Worrall says.
Mr Reid is asking Worrall about a comment he made in his police interview.
Worrall said he left Jackson Street and told officers: "I can't be a part of this when there's kids in the house."
Worrall said he agreed there 'could have been' children in the house.
Mr Reid puts it to Worrall that he threw one petrol bomb, which he denies.
12:48ANDREW BARDSLEY
Worrall denies petrol bomb involvement - despite co-defendant's claims
Mr Reid says that Zak Bolland and Abigail Toone said Worrall had a bottle.
The prosecutor says: "In this case he (Bolland) is right isn't he, that both of you had petrol bombs when you came in the car?"
"No, he's wrong," Worrall says.
Worrall denies being involved in the preparation of the petrol bombs.
Bolland said Worrall held a bottle while he poured in the petrol.
The jury is leaving court for lunch.
Trial of men charged with murdering mum in fire that left children dead- updates
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
14:18ANDREW BARDSLEY
Trial resumes
The jury is back in court, and David Worrall is continuing to be cross-examined by prosecutor Paul Reid QC.
14:40BENJAMIN BLOSSE
CCTV footage being played
CCTV footage is being played of two 'flashes' at Jackson Street, just before 5am on December 11.
Mr Reid is alleging that Worrall threw the first petrol bomb, which he denies.
Mr Reid says there is a nine second gap between the first flash and Worrall leaving the garden at Jackson Street.
The prosecutor says: "You have thrown this bottle in, and you want to see what happens.
"You see what happens, it's an explosion, not a big one, it may have shocked you.
"It is after that explosion that you run away."
Worrall says: "It was when the petrol bomb was thrown in the house, that's when I went."
Trial of men charged with murdering mum in fire that left children dead- updates
Trial resumes
The jury is back in court, and David Worrall is continuing to be cross-examined by prosecutor Paul Reid QC.
14:40BENJAMIN BLOSSE
CCTV footage being played
CCTV footage is being played of two 'flashes' at Jackson Street, just before 5am on December 11.
Mr Reid is alleging that Worrall threw the first petrol bomb, which he denies.
Mr Reid says there is a nine second gap between the first flash and Worrall leaving the garden at Jackson Street.
The prosecutor says: "You have thrown this bottle in, and you want to see what happens.
"You see what happens, it's an explosion, not a big one, it may have shocked you.
"It is after that explosion that you run away."
Worrall says: "It was when the petrol bomb was thrown in the house, that's when I went."
Trial of men charged with murdering mum in fire that left children dead- updates
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
15:01BENJAMIN BLOSSE
Jurors heard all evidence in the case
Mr Reid says: "Each of you threw a lit petrol bomb into the house."
"That's wrong," says Worrall.
Mr Reid continues: "When you threw yours, you had done your bit and you left."
"That's incorrect," Worrall replies.
Mr Reid says: "Although Zak Bolland was the leader of events that night, you were a willing accomplice weren't you."
"Yes I was," Worrall said.
Worrall agrees he didn't feel 'scared' or 'coerced' by Bolland, saying he 'assisted him willingly'.
Worrall has now completed his evidence.
Jurors are told they have now heard all the evidence in the case.
They are being sent home for the day, to return tomorrow.
Trial of men charged with murdering mum in fire that left children dead- updates
Jurors heard all evidence in the case
Mr Reid says: "Each of you threw a lit petrol bomb into the house."
"That's wrong," says Worrall.
Mr Reid continues: "When you threw yours, you had done your bit and you left."
"That's incorrect," Worrall replies.
Mr Reid says: "Although Zak Bolland was the leader of events that night, you were a willing accomplice weren't you."
"Yes I was," Worrall said.
Worrall agrees he didn't feel 'scared' or 'coerced' by Bolland, saying he 'assisted him willingly'.
Worrall has now completed his evidence.
Jurors are told they have now heard all the evidence in the case.
They are being sent home for the day, to return tomorrow.
Trial of men charged with murdering mum in fire that left children dead- updates
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
12:18REBECCA DAY
Jury back in court
The jury are back in court, and the trial is continuing.
They have now heard all the evidence in the case.
The next stage is for the judge, Mrs Justice McGowan, to deliver legal directions to the jury.
12:37REBECCA DAY
Judge explains what prosecution need to prove to jury
The judge says the prosecution must make the jury sure for the defendants to be found guilty of murder.
Both Bolland and Worrall admit manslaughter but deny murder.
The judge tells jurors that murder involves the killing of another person by the use of unlawful violence, where the intention is to kill or at least to cause some really serious harm.
Manslaughter involves killing someone using unlawful violence with the risk of subjecting the victim to some harm.
12:47REBECCA DAY
Prosecutor gives closing speech
Prosecutor Paul Reid QC is now giving his closing speech.
He says the 'one issue' in the case of both defendants is his intention 'when he took part in the unlawful petrol bomb attack at Jackson Street'.
"That issue has already been decided against these defendants by the jury in 2018," he said.
"We invite you to come to the same conclusion."
12:55REBECCA DAY
"Having been convicted on overwhelming evidence at the first trial, they are trying their hand again, hoping however faint that hope might be, for a different result"
Mr Reid says this trial is not just for the Pearson family, but is also of 'public importance' and of 'public interest'.
He says: "You might have expected that these two men might have pleaded guilty this time. Courtney Brierley has.
"But each of these two men has chosen to fight, and to fight again.
"The reason is not to put the record straight, not to give the family answers as Zak Bolland said, to give them some sort of closure.
"They are here to give it another go.
"Having been convicted on overwhelming evidence at the first trial, they are trying their hand again, hoping however faint that hope might be, for a different result."
Mr Reid claims that they want to 'challenge' their convictions in 2018 and the life sentences both men are facing.
"Each of them has changed his story, each admits lying to the first jury," the prosecutor says.
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
Jury back in court
The jury are back in court, and the trial is continuing.
They have now heard all the evidence in the case.
The next stage is for the judge, Mrs Justice McGowan, to deliver legal directions to the jury.
12:37REBECCA DAY
Judge explains what prosecution need to prove to jury
The judge says the prosecution must make the jury sure for the defendants to be found guilty of murder.
Both Bolland and Worrall admit manslaughter but deny murder.
The judge tells jurors that murder involves the killing of another person by the use of unlawful violence, where the intention is to kill or at least to cause some really serious harm.
Manslaughter involves killing someone using unlawful violence with the risk of subjecting the victim to some harm.
12:47REBECCA DAY
Prosecutor gives closing speech
Prosecutor Paul Reid QC is now giving his closing speech.
He says the 'one issue' in the case of both defendants is his intention 'when he took part in the unlawful petrol bomb attack at Jackson Street'.
"That issue has already been decided against these defendants by the jury in 2018," he said.
"We invite you to come to the same conclusion."
12:55REBECCA DAY
"Having been convicted on overwhelming evidence at the first trial, they are trying their hand again, hoping however faint that hope might be, for a different result"
Mr Reid says this trial is not just for the Pearson family, but is also of 'public importance' and of 'public interest'.
He says: "You might have expected that these two men might have pleaded guilty this time. Courtney Brierley has.
"But each of these two men has chosen to fight, and to fight again.
"The reason is not to put the record straight, not to give the family answers as Zak Bolland said, to give them some sort of closure.
"They are here to give it another go.
"Having been convicted on overwhelming evidence at the first trial, they are trying their hand again, hoping however faint that hope might be, for a different result."
Mr Reid claims that they want to 'challenge' their convictions in 2018 and the life sentences both men are facing.
"Each of them has changed his story, each admits lying to the first jury," the prosecutor says.
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
13:14REBECCA DAY
"Sorry really was the hardest word wasn't it, and you didn't hear it from either of them"
Mr Reid says Bolland and Worrall are seeking to 'present themselves as victims of a miscarriage of justice in 2018'.
Mr Reid continues: "You might have expected them to tell you and the family how sorry they were for what they had done.
"But sorry really was the hardest word wasn't it, and you didn't hear it from either of them."
Concluding his speech, Mr Reid says a guilty verdict to murder would be the 'proper' and 'inevitable' verdict.
The jury has now left court for lunch.
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
"Sorry really was the hardest word wasn't it, and you didn't hear it from either of them"
Mr Reid says Bolland and Worrall are seeking to 'present themselves as victims of a miscarriage of justice in 2018'.
Mr Reid continues: "You might have expected them to tell you and the family how sorry they were for what they had done.
"But sorry really was the hardest word wasn't it, and you didn't hear it from either of them."
Concluding his speech, Mr Reid says a guilty verdict to murder would be the 'proper' and 'inevitable' verdict.
The jury has now left court for lunch.
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
14:26REBECCA DAY
Mr Ford asks jurors to 'resist the temptation to leap to judgement'
The jury has returned to court after the lunch break.
Mark Ford QC is giving his closing speech on behalf of Zak Bolland.
Mr Ford tells jurors his client is a convicted murderer.
He says: "I don't shy away from it.
"It is a fact, it is part of the evidence in this case.
"On learning of his conviction in 2018 many people perhaps might have closed their minds to his case, and do the submissions made on his behalf."
Mr Ford asks jurors to 'resist the temptation to leap to judgement'.
"It is Zak Bolland's case that the jury in the first trial made a mistake."
Mr Ford says Bolland does not say he is 'entirely blameless'.
"He readily admits he is responsible for the deaths of those who died in the fire that he started."
14:37REBECCA DAY
Four points are 'fundamental' to Bolland's case, court hears
Mr Ford says there are four points which are 'fundamental' to Bolland's case.
Firstly he says Bolland's intention was to obtain payment for the loss he suffered.
Jurors have heard his car was burnt out.
He said if that was not forthcoming then Bolland was 'going to damage the property of those he held responsible'.
Secondly he says when he started the fire at Jackson Street, Bolland wanted to damage white goods in the kitchen, but not to kill or seriously harm anyone.
Thirdly Mr Ford says Bolland believed the house was empty.
Fourthly, Mr Ford says Bolland didn't believe throwing the petrol bomb into the house would have the 'devastating effect that it did'.
"Zak Bolland is simply repeating now what he said in 2018," Mr Ford says.
"Namely he accepts responsibility for the deaths, albeit on the basis of manslaughter."
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
Mr Ford asks jurors to 'resist the temptation to leap to judgement'
The jury has returned to court after the lunch break.
Mark Ford QC is giving his closing speech on behalf of Zak Bolland.
Mr Ford tells jurors his client is a convicted murderer.
He says: "I don't shy away from it.
"It is a fact, it is part of the evidence in this case.
"On learning of his conviction in 2018 many people perhaps might have closed their minds to his case, and do the submissions made on his behalf."
Mr Ford asks jurors to 'resist the temptation to leap to judgement'.
"It is Zak Bolland's case that the jury in the first trial made a mistake."
Mr Ford says Bolland does not say he is 'entirely blameless'.
"He readily admits he is responsible for the deaths of those who died in the fire that he started."
14:37REBECCA DAY
Four points are 'fundamental' to Bolland's case, court hears
Mr Ford says there are four points which are 'fundamental' to Bolland's case.
Firstly he says Bolland's intention was to obtain payment for the loss he suffered.
Jurors have heard his car was burnt out.
He said if that was not forthcoming then Bolland was 'going to damage the property of those he held responsible'.
Secondly he says when he started the fire at Jackson Street, Bolland wanted to damage white goods in the kitchen, but not to kill or seriously harm anyone.
Thirdly Mr Ford says Bolland believed the house was empty.
Fourthly, Mr Ford says Bolland didn't believe throwing the petrol bomb into the house would have the 'devastating effect that it did'.
"Zak Bolland is simply repeating now what he said in 2018," Mr Ford says.
"Namely he accepts responsibility for the deaths, albeit on the basis of manslaughter."
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
15:00SIMON COYLE
Mr Ford says Worrall 'lies, you may think, with such frequency that he does not appear to be able to stop himself from doing it.'
Jurors have heard Worrall says that he believed the house on Jackson Street was occupied at the time of the fire.
Bolland has said he believed no-one was in the property.
Speaking of Worrall, Mr Ford says: "He lies, you may think, with such frequency that he does not appear to be able to stop himself from doing it.
"It appears to be a compulsion. His lies are often calculated."
Mr Ford says 'everything he says must be viewed with suspicion, with caution'.
15:00SIMON COYLE
Mr Ford says Bolland didn't believe throwing the petrol bomb into the house would have the 'devastating effect that it did'.
Mr Ford addresses his point that Bolland didn't believe throwing the petrol bomb into the house would have the 'devastating effect that it did'.
The QC said: "That may have been a tragically stupid thing to think.
"But the question still stands, do you think he wanted to kill somebody for a £500 debt?"
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
Mr Ford says Worrall 'lies, you may think, with such frequency that he does not appear to be able to stop himself from doing it.'
Jurors have heard Worrall says that he believed the house on Jackson Street was occupied at the time of the fire.
Bolland has said he believed no-one was in the property.
Speaking of Worrall, Mr Ford says: "He lies, you may think, with such frequency that he does not appear to be able to stop himself from doing it.
"It appears to be a compulsion. His lies are often calculated."
Mr Ford says 'everything he says must be viewed with suspicion, with caution'.
15:00SIMON COYLE
Mr Ford says Bolland didn't believe throwing the petrol bomb into the house would have the 'devastating effect that it did'.
Mr Ford addresses his point that Bolland didn't believe throwing the petrol bomb into the house would have the 'devastating effect that it did'.
The QC said: "That may have been a tragically stupid thing to think.
"But the question still stands, do you think he wanted to kill somebody for a £500 debt?"
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
15:05SIMON COYLE
Mr Ford tells jurors that they can be satisfied on the balance of probabilites that Bolland did not intend to murder or cause really serious harm
Mr Ford says: "I know members of the jury, it is not hard to say sorry. Unless that is you are still trying to come to terms with the enormity of what you did.
"Mr Bolland may not have prostrated himself before you and given a sobbing apology to members of the family.
"You do know something about how he has reacted since he caused the death of those people.
"He tried to kill himself, he has been on suicide watch in prison."
Mr Ford tells jurors that they can be satisfied on the balance of probabilites that Bolland did not intend to murder or cause really serious harm.
15:12SIMON COYLE
Benjamin Myers QC now gives speech on behalf of David Worrall
Benjamin Myers QC is now giving his speech on behalf of David Worrall.
He is addressing the verdicts in 2018.
"Treat this as a trial, not as for example a foregone conclusion," Mr Myers said.
He asks jurors to put emotions to one side.
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
Mr Ford tells jurors that they can be satisfied on the balance of probabilites that Bolland did not intend to murder or cause really serious harm
Mr Ford says: "I know members of the jury, it is not hard to say sorry. Unless that is you are still trying to come to terms with the enormity of what you did.
"Mr Bolland may not have prostrated himself before you and given a sobbing apology to members of the family.
"You do know something about how he has reacted since he caused the death of those people.
"He tried to kill himself, he has been on suicide watch in prison."
Mr Ford tells jurors that they can be satisfied on the balance of probabilites that Bolland did not intend to murder or cause really serious harm.
15:12SIMON COYLE
Benjamin Myers QC now gives speech on behalf of David Worrall
Benjamin Myers QC is now giving his speech on behalf of David Worrall.
He is addressing the verdicts in 2018.
"Treat this as a trial, not as for example a foregone conclusion," Mr Myers said.
He asks jurors to put emotions to one side.
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
15:25SIMON COYLE
Mr Myers says there are 'very clear reasons' why Bolland has been 'attacking' Worrall during the trial
Mr Myers says: "What he (Worrall) says now is that he is involved in the attack.
"He believes it was to cause fear.
"But he never thought much beyond that until it became too late."
Mr Myers says Worrall 'lied his head off'.
He says there are 'very clear reasons' why Bolland has been 'attacking' him during the trial.
"First of all because David Worrall didn't come into line.
"Because David Worrall is a grass and has broken the code that Mr Bolland has made so much of.
"Mr Bolland is very unhappy that David Worrall will not back him up on this, that they thought the house was empty."
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
Mr Myers says there are 'very clear reasons' why Bolland has been 'attacking' Worrall during the trial
Mr Myers says: "What he (Worrall) says now is that he is involved in the attack.
"He believes it was to cause fear.
"But he never thought much beyond that until it became too late."
Mr Myers says Worrall 'lied his head off'.
He says there are 'very clear reasons' why Bolland has been 'attacking' him during the trial.
"First of all because David Worrall didn't come into line.
"Because David Worrall is a grass and has broken the code that Mr Bolland has made so much of.
"Mr Bolland is very unhappy that David Worrall will not back him up on this, that they thought the house was empty."
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
16:05SIMON COYLE
Mr Myers asks the jury to convict Worrall of manslaughter
Concluding his speech, Mr Myers says: "David Worrall was simply not thinking through the reality of what he was doing."
He says Worrall believed the intention was to 'frighten' rather than cause serious harm.
He says Worrall ran off when he realised the 'enormity' of what he was involved in.
Mr Myers asks the jury to convict Worrall of manslaughter.
The jury is now being sent home, to return on Monday.
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
Mr Myers asks the jury to convict Worrall of manslaughter
Concluding his speech, Mr Myers says: "David Worrall was simply not thinking through the reality of what he was doing."
He says Worrall believed the intention was to 'frighten' rather than cause serious harm.
He says Worrall ran off when he realised the 'enormity' of what he was involved in.
Mr Myers asks the jury to convict Worrall of manslaughter.
The jury is now being sent home, to return on Monday.
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
10:48REBECCA DAY
Jury back in court
The jury is back in court and the trial is resuming.
The judge, Mrs Justice McGowan, is now starting her summing up of the case.
10:50REBECCA DAY
"What was in each of their minds as they threw, or helped to throw, a petrol bomb into that house?"
Before the judge starts her summing up, some CCTV footage which jurors have already been shown during the trial is being replayed to them.
It is footage from Jackson Street, showing 'two flashes' when prosecutors allege Bolland and Worrall each threw a petrol bomb into the house.
The judge tells jurors the issue in the case is 'what was in their (Bolland and Worrall's) minds' just prior to the fire.
"What was in each of their minds as they threw, or helped to throw, a petrol bomb into that house," the judge says.
11:26REBECCA DAY
Judge is summarising evidence
The judge says: "A case like this is bound to cause an emotional reaction, of course it does.
"You would be inhuman if you didn't feel sympathy and emotion in the circumstances, and that's only normal.
"But you have to put that to one side, and only decide this case with your head, not your heart."
The judge is summarising the evidence of Michelle Pearson, who gave statements to the police before her death.
She says that Ms Pearson said she received texts on November 26, 2017, from a number saved in her phone as being Zak Bolland's number, calling Kyle Pearson a 'grass' and asking for £500.
Ms Pearson said that on November 26, some of the children were sitting on the sofa watching TV when the windows were smashed.
She said she saw Bolland with a hammer, and he was demanding £500, she said.
Prosecutors allege Bolland threatened to 'fire bomb' the house, which he denies.
Jurors are told that Ms Pearson had contacted the fire service who installed a 'metal plate' which sealed the letter box to stop someone from pouring petrol through it.
In an incident after midnight on December 11, she saw four people in her garden.
Bolland asked for Ms Pearson's older sons to come outside, and Bolland allegedly threatened he was 'going to do your house'.
The judge is now going over the evidence of Kyle Pearson.
She says there was an issue about damage to Bolland's car, and that after that he wanted payment to repair or replace it, the £500 which has been referenced.
Kyle Pearson said he had seen texts from Bolland which referenced fire, but Kyle Pearson said he didn't believe them and deleted them from his phone.
11:46REBECCA DAY
Jury reminded of evidence of Abigail Toone
The jury is being reminded of the evidence of Abigail Toone, who drove Bolland and Worrall to Jackson Street prior to the fire.
She had been looking for her boyfriend and went to Bolland's house in the early hours of December 11.
The judge is reminding jurors of what Zak Bolland says.
He has admitted that he is guilty of manslaughter and accepts he threw a petrol bomb.
Bolland says he believed the house on Jackson Street was empty, and thought he could limit the damage to the kitchen.
He thought the people in the house would move out, and that the debt would have been settled because of the financial loss with damage to items in the kitchen.
Bolland has said he thought people in the house at Jackson Street would have been moved out of the area for the night, due to the earlier incident in the early hours of December 11.
He said he saw police at the house.
Bolland said that he knew 'quite a few' people who he knew of that had happened to, as there was often 'trouble' on the estate.
11:49REBECCA DAY
Judge continuing to summarise Bolland's case
The judge is continuing to summarise Bolland's case.
She says Bolland said: "I wanted them to suffer financial loss, and to be rehomed out of the area, which would be the end of the feud."
Bolland says Worrall threw the first petrol bomb.
He says he didn't think the first bottle had smashed, so thought he would have to throw his 'harder'.
Bolland says after he threw his petrol bomb he 'knew it was going in the wrong direction'.
Jurors are told that Bolland denies he is contesting this trial to give himself grounds for appeal into the verdicts at the previous trial.
David Worrall's evidence is now being summarised by the judge.
He says he knew Bolland was having trouble with someone but didn't know who.
Worrall says that when he went to Bolland's house on December 11, Bolland was 'angry' about what had been done to his car.
Worrall has said he believed there were people in the house at Jackson Street.
He said he thought the occupants would have been able to get out of the house from the other side.
12:02KEY EVENT
The jury has now been sent out to consider their verdicts
The judge tells jurors that prosecutors say Bolland and Worrall are guilty of murdering Michelle Pearson.
They point to the verdicts of the jury in the first trial.
Bolland was convicted of attempting to murder Michelle Pearson, which prosecutors say shows that he intended to kill her.
Worrall was convicted of attempting to cause serious harm.
Bolland and Worrall both say they didn't intend to kill or cause serious harm and deny murder.
The judge tells jurors verdicts are needed upon which all of them are agreed.
The jury are being given a 'route to verdict' document which sets out questions they need to answer before returning a verdict.
There are two questions in the cases of Bolland and Worrall.
The first is whether they committed an unlawful act which caused the death of Michelle Pearson.
The judge says both admit this so the answer would be yes.
The second question is whether Bolland and Worrall have proved whether it is more likely than not that they did not intend to kill or cause serious injury to someone in the house.
The jury has now been sent out to consider their verdicts.
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
Jury back in court
The jury is back in court and the trial is resuming.
The judge, Mrs Justice McGowan, is now starting her summing up of the case.
10:50REBECCA DAY
"What was in each of their minds as they threw, or helped to throw, a petrol bomb into that house?"
Before the judge starts her summing up, some CCTV footage which jurors have already been shown during the trial is being replayed to them.
It is footage from Jackson Street, showing 'two flashes' when prosecutors allege Bolland and Worrall each threw a petrol bomb into the house.
The judge tells jurors the issue in the case is 'what was in their (Bolland and Worrall's) minds' just prior to the fire.
"What was in each of their minds as they threw, or helped to throw, a petrol bomb into that house," the judge says.
11:26REBECCA DAY
Judge is summarising evidence
The judge says: "A case like this is bound to cause an emotional reaction, of course it does.
"You would be inhuman if you didn't feel sympathy and emotion in the circumstances, and that's only normal.
"But you have to put that to one side, and only decide this case with your head, not your heart."
The judge is summarising the evidence of Michelle Pearson, who gave statements to the police before her death.
She says that Ms Pearson said she received texts on November 26, 2017, from a number saved in her phone as being Zak Bolland's number, calling Kyle Pearson a 'grass' and asking for £500.
Ms Pearson said that on November 26, some of the children were sitting on the sofa watching TV when the windows were smashed.
She said she saw Bolland with a hammer, and he was demanding £500, she said.
Prosecutors allege Bolland threatened to 'fire bomb' the house, which he denies.
Jurors are told that Ms Pearson had contacted the fire service who installed a 'metal plate' which sealed the letter box to stop someone from pouring petrol through it.
In an incident after midnight on December 11, she saw four people in her garden.
Bolland asked for Ms Pearson's older sons to come outside, and Bolland allegedly threatened he was 'going to do your house'.
The judge is now going over the evidence of Kyle Pearson.
She says there was an issue about damage to Bolland's car, and that after that he wanted payment to repair or replace it, the £500 which has been referenced.
Kyle Pearson said he had seen texts from Bolland which referenced fire, but Kyle Pearson said he didn't believe them and deleted them from his phone.
11:46REBECCA DAY
Jury reminded of evidence of Abigail Toone
The jury is being reminded of the evidence of Abigail Toone, who drove Bolland and Worrall to Jackson Street prior to the fire.
She had been looking for her boyfriend and went to Bolland's house in the early hours of December 11.
The judge is reminding jurors of what Zak Bolland says.
He has admitted that he is guilty of manslaughter and accepts he threw a petrol bomb.
Bolland says he believed the house on Jackson Street was empty, and thought he could limit the damage to the kitchen.
He thought the people in the house would move out, and that the debt would have been settled because of the financial loss with damage to items in the kitchen.
Bolland has said he thought people in the house at Jackson Street would have been moved out of the area for the night, due to the earlier incident in the early hours of December 11.
He said he saw police at the house.
Bolland said that he knew 'quite a few' people who he knew of that had happened to, as there was often 'trouble' on the estate.
11:49REBECCA DAY
Judge continuing to summarise Bolland's case
The judge is continuing to summarise Bolland's case.
She says Bolland said: "I wanted them to suffer financial loss, and to be rehomed out of the area, which would be the end of the feud."
Bolland says Worrall threw the first petrol bomb.
He says he didn't think the first bottle had smashed, so thought he would have to throw his 'harder'.
Bolland says after he threw his petrol bomb he 'knew it was going in the wrong direction'.
Jurors are told that Bolland denies he is contesting this trial to give himself grounds for appeal into the verdicts at the previous trial.
David Worrall's evidence is now being summarised by the judge.
He says he knew Bolland was having trouble with someone but didn't know who.
Worrall says that when he went to Bolland's house on December 11, Bolland was 'angry' about what had been done to his car.
Worrall has said he believed there were people in the house at Jackson Street.
He said he thought the occupants would have been able to get out of the house from the other side.
12:02KEY EVENT
The jury has now been sent out to consider their verdicts
The judge tells jurors that prosecutors say Bolland and Worrall are guilty of murdering Michelle Pearson.
They point to the verdicts of the jury in the first trial.
Bolland was convicted of attempting to murder Michelle Pearson, which prosecutors say shows that he intended to kill her.
Worrall was convicted of attempting to cause serious harm.
Bolland and Worrall both say they didn't intend to kill or cause serious harm and deny murder.
The judge tells jurors verdicts are needed upon which all of them are agreed.
The jury are being given a 'route to verdict' document which sets out questions they need to answer before returning a verdict.
There are two questions in the cases of Bolland and Worrall.
The first is whether they committed an unlawful act which caused the death of Michelle Pearson.
The judge says both admit this so the answer would be yes.
The second question is whether Bolland and Worrall have proved whether it is more likely than not that they did not intend to kill or cause serious injury to someone in the house.
The jury has now been sent out to consider their verdicts.
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2015
- Messages
- 8,845
- Reaction score
- 44,054
16:21REBECCA DAY
Jury sent home for the day
The jury has been sent home for the day. We will resume our coverage tomorrow.
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
Jury sent home for the day
The jury has been sent home for the day. We will resume our coverage tomorrow.
Live updates as two men on trial charged with murdering Michelle Pearson
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
Staff online
-
BreezyflavorModerator
Online statistics
- Members online
- 67
- Guests online
- 4,081
- Total visitors
- 4,148