If JP had been driving recklessly or done something like NOT pullover and sped past LE, they would have gone after him. It would have saved Jayme, but not her parents. IMO, officers saw a car that only after JP was caught did they know the car was involved. Don't forget though that JP had no record, the car belonged to his sister and he kept Jayme concealed from them too. If they did try to find out who the car belonged to, there was no connection to JP. The neighbors didn't even know JP was staying in the cabin. Even if someone had turned in that car, LE would have just looked to see who it was registered to. Even I was ready to report a red-orange Challenger I saw at my local gas station and I'm in SC.