whether it was a ring or one person, someone found out that police in the area didn't arrest people for sex with children. I believe it was probably two different perps who did jacob and jared. word probably got around quick within the group of people who had the same interests in children that Fr Hoefgen wasn't arrested after he confessed. If and when his activities were talked about, this would be a nice advertisement for the area to attract people like this:
In another case, Theisen allowed the Rev. Francis Hoefgen to lead a parish in Hastings after Hoefgen had sex with a troubled teenage boy. The boy had gone to live with Hoefgen in the parish house in 1983 after attempting suicide.
Hoefgen confessed to Cold Spring Police Chief Vincent Konz, a parishioner who later expressed concern about the case becoming public. He met with Hoefgen in private rather than at the police station or the rectory because he didn’t want to “cause speculation,” he told lawyers.
“There’s so many small people in a small town like this they could crucify the guy,” Konz said.
“And maybe he had it coming, but that wasn’t the way things were handled in those days. My concern was what it would do to the faith community.”
http://www.behindthepinecurtain.com/wordpress/decades-of-abuse-and-secrecy-at-st-johns-abbey/