Cal, am I reading your "catch 22" paragraph as a general statement, not just an account of sanctuary hunting? Why do you oppose sanctuary hunting?
(I'm honestly interested. Not trying to start an argument.)
Right, the catch 22 paragraph was relating to REAL, actual hunting. I am telling you guys, there are few greater feelings than to hunt and provide food for yourself and your family. However, I am leery of the bloodthirsty hunters that I often meet in hunting clubs. They are, without exception, NOT bowhunters. Bowhunting is an extemely religious experience, so to speak. There are so many things you have to do right (scent control, sound control, wind direction, tuning of the equipment, etc.) that one small thing is the difference between success and not. I like that I harvested the game so I know where it came from, what it ate, I get to handle the animal myself to ensure proper hygene practices, and ultimately cook the meat. That's full circle and there is something that is just right about that.
However, in light of what you are doing...killing something that God made. That shouldn't be taken lightly in my opinion. I guess I hold a reverence for the animals much like the American Indians did and still do. After killing a deer (I haven't hunted anything else yet), I usually just sit down beside the deer and just kind of listen to the woods around us and think about what it meant that I took that animal's life. I don't take killing lightly or jump up and down like an idiot when I kill one. I generally don't ever mount the heads, rather I put them outside and let nature clean them off and then put them in the garage on the wall. I can still walk by, look at a skull, and remember the hunt and very specific minute details of the hunt....yet can't remember why I was coming out into the garage to begin with. It really is just something in your blood or not...an amazing experience all around.
As for hunting the preserves, I will never hunt them. Now an outfitter say in Utah that hunts private and public land for Elk, let's say, is okay. The difference is that many preserves are high fenced areas of low acerage and often the animals become accustomed to people. In fact, some I have seen have trucks that scatter corn and then when the animals hear the truck start up, they come running right up to the back of the vehicle. Animals are easily patterned and follow established game trails to where you often can be told "sit on this stand and he should come out from behind that tree". As we have seen here, some of these animals are even bought from farmers and put out there. I don't consider that hunting. I only hunt free ranging animals that aren't in pens or fences and those that aren't acclimated to people.
If I am going to hunt, I am going to hunt wild animals. I am going to locate them myself using animal sign, unless it is on a friend's land where he already has stands placed. I am going to get as close to that animal as possible before taking a shot, I am only going to shoot at an animal that is completely broadside to me, I am going to retrieve that game at all costs, and then I am going to eat that animal or give it to friends. That, for me anyway, is the only way to hunt.
I can't explain it but there is a longing in the soul to be self sufficient for REAL hunters. It isn't about killing, in fact, I enjoy the hunts where a deer heard me or saw me move and busted out of there like a freight train. Without exception, the best hunts have been deer where I decided early on not to take the animal and just sat and watched them. My pet peeve is killing a mother when she has yearlings with her. Yearlings are deer that aren't nursing any longer but are staying with mom. I just can't do that and will not. But I have seen some amazing sights watching them still try to nurse and mom running them around trying to teach them to eat grass, etc.
I know a lot of people are repulsed by hunting but hopefully some of those will come to realize that REAL hunters aren't what they are made out to be.
Cal