CARIIS
Former Member
- Joined
- Jun 8, 2012
- Messages
- 25,470
- Reaction score
- 10,693
I'm so baffled by this case. He just doesn't seem like a Scott Peterson. He's more awkward than cocky and arrogant. Shanann's love and thankfulness and praise for her husband on SM feels really genuine to me. Could this really have been completely out of the blue?
The third baby seemed pre-planned and wanted by both, confirmed by close friends. Though his reaction video didn't seem overly genuine.
I'm very curious to know what it was that raised alarm bells so quickly for her friend Nicole. So far it seems it's thanks to her that he is in custody so fast. I really do think he had plans to stage something that Monday afternoon and she ruined his plans, essentially blowing this case wide open. Good for her for acting on her instincts.
yeh i dont get this cunning manipulative bright guy (like peterson ) either
i actually get a rather simple slow thinking southern man
his presentation certainly did not portray this sharp witty even smart dude
i don't think premeditation either
feels more like a horrible out of control impulse thing - that might not have even started with intent to murder -- i think she told him that night she was in love with someone else and WAS leaving .
and he shoved her and she was dead or seriously injured and he totally freaked out
the kids came running in
he was berserk
then what does he do - inconsistent stuff - if your digging a grave why not put all three in
the notion that he put the kids in to prevent smell why not put the wife in she was petite
i just think he totally lost it
a sociopath generally does not confess in what 36 hours
i think the confession ( if he did) was much more out of remorse and shock at what went so out of control
with the passage of a little time the thought of them in the gas tanks wore on him
dropping deceased kids into a giant oil thing does not really seem premeditated it seems more panicky
if anything seems like a guy that would avoid conflict
his neighbors description of him is congruent with the above notions
i found the females reporter with them stunning ( at the time I did not know about the weight stuff and how he looked before )
she asked him did the exercising seem to give him more confidence -- which makes sense now - and they said no
even coming up with that question seems at some level the female reporter there had some sense that he was an shy introverted quiet man if that makes sense
also somewhat bewildered by the neighbors two totally opposite responses to an affair in one interview adamant no (her husband corroborated ) in the next possibly
apparently the two guys jogged together
i think males would share an affair with one another
generally speaking of course
at this point ( him in jail for the rest of his life ) and them deceased at this point in time i would think the male if he knew would chime in
those two and him seemed very homey ( tgiving dinners playing uno etc)
i did not get a sense of the four of them bar hopping
at the same time it would make some sense that a guy that looked the way he did in the presentation and probably his whole life prior might want to see if his new look was attractive also makes some sense
I also think a month and half away from spouse is a trial separation
I think getting back from that would indicate that she had made some decisions and they were revealed that night
his description ( as a male ) of an emotional conversation and "lets leave it at that " is reflective of finally realizing it is over
I also think if the separation also included that she had fallen in love with someone else - might add to stuff that night
does anyone deserve this of course not
its just does not feel like this planed event
jmo
Last edited: