Found Deceased CO - Suzanne Morphew, 49, Chaffee Co, 10 May 2020 #81 *arrest*

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
I know that this will not be a popular opinion here, but, I really do think the judge has overstepped the mark.

In his own words, this is not a trial and if the tweets are quoting the judge accurately, BM has been found guilty by the judge. I'm afraid, I do not call that justice, nor do I call it due process.
I respectfully disagree. The findings are all specified by the judge to be under the applicable standard for probable cause. The judge anticipates a Rule 50 appeal of his decision and is leaving as little room for misrepresentation of his opinion as possible.

I suspect that the defense anticipates a decision denying bail, and sees an opportunity to argue that BM should be eligible for bond because Colorado abolished the death penalty - therefore there are no longer "capital offenses" under the state constitution and all defendants are eligible for bail. This would be the first case to offer an opportunity for the Supreme Court to provide guidance on that issue, and they may well want to take it up.

I believe the presence of distinguished appellate specialist Sean Connelly at this early stage can only mean that BM has committed all his resources in a "balls to the wall" effort to get out of jail early and stay out, and that he will appeal the judge's probable cause determination as well.

Anyone interested in how Rule 50 works may be interested in this Colorado Lawyer article, Certiorari Before Judgment, an Examination of C.A.R. 50.
 
I disagree. The judge did not convict BM today. The judge has found that based on information presented to the court that it's reasonable to believe that SM was the victim of a homicide and that BM may be responsible. The judge will not decide on his guilt -- that will be left to a jury after a full trial of evidence and testimony.
And remember the case is not strong right now. If it goes to trial and he is found not guilty it is for all practical purposes over. I was kinda hoping it might get dismissed or refiled at something that would have a higher jury probability. But trial there will be next year sounds like.
 
Imo
Barry is not only not going to run. He, with his daughters and attorneys, will do the circuit of appearances pushing that he's innocent and the real killer is still out there.

Imo

So. you think he will have free run of Colorado?

If he does try this PR campaign, I think it will truly and seriously backfire. Judge will like issue a gag order and then sanction them if they continue.
 
Wait what? I thought he was going to trial as proof IS evident and presumption IS great ……




Jennifer Hicks

@JenniferCHicks

·
6m

On the question of bail, the judge says the prosecution did not meet the standard of evidence greater than that needed for probable cause, which is what would be required to deny bail.
 
I thought he bought a condo? where was he living when arrested?

He was "renting." He was trading his landscaping services for a place to live. That deal ended. He had his stuff in a moving van.

He owns no property in CO and rents no property in CO. I presume, though, that his daughters do - and have offered him a place to stay. I hope he can keep it together while staying with them, I truly do. Perhaps it'll be just one of them (I predict it will be MM1).
 
@LaurenScharfTV

The judge does not believe the state proved enough evidence for first-degree murder so there will be a bond set. We are on a little break now. The family was all in tears hugging one another. #BarryMorphew

5:36 PM · Sep 17, 2021

I’m so confused. Why is he going to trial if not enough evidence for first-degree murder?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
171
Guests online
241
Total visitors
412

Forum statistics

Threads
608,953
Messages
18,248,034
Members
234,513
Latest member
morrie1
Back
Top