This is so chilling, to me. What's going on is that your daughter has been missing for an entire day. Instead, JS launches into the very-obviously-rehearsed story. I realize I may be being too particular about this, but it's like when the killer calls 911: they do a CYA story, not the most important facts. They start with "I was at work, and my wife went out to walk the dog and hasn't come back." The people who are genuinely scared start with "My wife is missing and I can't find her anywhere," or whatever, if you get what I'm trying to say. I realize it's not an exact science, but it certainly skews towards sketchy.