I am not Sherlock H.
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2023
- Messages
- 1,532
- Reaction score
- 14,721
Yes it is so hard to know what is true and not true in this sad case.Oh and another thing that leaped out at me.
JS and SS both said something to the effect that Maddie didn't want to be seen dropped off at school because she was ashamed of SS's car.
Yet SS also said that he rarely took her to school--IIRC he said maybe 6 times ever--so exactly when and why did Maddie develop this aversion to being dropped off at school in his car, if it happened only rarely?
Especially considering he hadn't even been around since December, according to him.
I don't think JS was involved in Maddie's death, but she sure as hell is doing everything possible to confirm SS's story.
ETA: If Maddie were that embarrassed, why didn't he just take JS's car? Since she was so tired she asked him to take her to school, she wouldn't need it.
When I just reread that part about supposedly MS didn’t want to be seen dropped off in SS car…….. it yet again strikes as odd. Very odd, for two different reasons.
Maybe it was ‘code’ for MS didn’t want to be seen with SS…… period….. sadly, for reasons now known. And has nothing to do with the ‘car’?
And, SS was in his father’s car that day. Not his own. Which car, exactly, is the ‘embarrassing’ one? SS or his father’s car? This goes to ‘alibi’ scripts it seems IMO?
And who knew when that SS would have his father’s car? Instead of his own?
Perhaps SS needed a different and larger car? To try and avoid obvious or ready detection? Or maybe a larger passenger compartment or trunk? Which IMO might go to elements of premeditation? MOO