Trying to keep local Macon news coverage of the year-ago mark updated here. Here's another from FOX24 NewsCentral. (They're trying, I think, but I dunno ...)
The Mind of a Murderer: The Lauren Giddings Case
print article and video at:
http://www.newscentralga.com/news/local/The-Mind-of-a-Murder-The-Lauren-Giddings-Case-160586755.html
Sounds just like Stephen McDaniel to me , or at least the way he has been portrayed in the media.
The article points out some of the same characteristics we speculated about here last summer, socially awkward, isolated, daydreamer, misanthrope. Since then we've learned that McD has used these traits to describe himself. It doesn't make him a killer, but he certainly seems to fits the profile.
I have a couple of problems with this coverage.
To me, it comes across as biased and misleading. (And I will add that I truly believe I would see it that way no matter what my current personal assessment about whether Stephen McDaniel is Lauren's killer might be. But yes, I am still on the fence.) I am not sure that I believe it was
intended to be either biased or misleading; I rather think that here is a second-tier news outlet trying to provide some anniversary coverage and, commendably, going for an angle that really has not been used much by local media in this case. But I think they missed the mark in professionalism.
The clinical psychologist being interviewed starts by saying (I'm paraphrasing) that several possibilities exist for a psychological profile for someone who might have committed the crime (I'd like to hear more about those, too), but she and/or the coverage (it is hard tell which) then zooms in to only the psychopathic/sociopathic model and, interestingly, yes, mostly to those traits of that model which ring familiar, at least to some extent, from LE/media/internet/gossip/self reports about Stephen -- a little from all those sources.
I'm not too sure that the expert being interviewed is super-qualified to make this kind of assessment. Oh, she's more qualified than me, no doubt! But I can't find any evidence that she has special training in criminal profiling. (She doesn't claim that, either, but the way she and her comments are showcased in the coverage seems to attempt to put her in that role.) If I knew she were a practiced criminal profiler, and one working with the type of unreleased, unknown-to-the-public information about this specific murder, crime scene, etc. that would be needed to create a profile, I would be very interested in hearing what she has to say. (But if she were that, I don't think she would be giving this interview at this time.)
Here's info about her background from her website:
http://www.daphnestevens.com/about.html
I'm pretty much an advocate for mental health issues and public education about them, including stigma reduction, so I try not to take too much offense when she briefly dumbs down some psychiatric lingo to ward off any thinking from the masses that the sociopathic personality profile she has lingered over fits those with some diagnoses such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. I think she means well.
Problems here are: (1)Truth to be told, there
are some similarities in presentation between some personality disorders and some "mental disorders", and also, while I want as much as anyone to dispel the myth that persons with mental illness are
more likely to commit violent crimes than others, the fact is, sometimes, untreated or improperly treated features of those disorders DO contribute to violent behavior. (2) In the print article, the web site sort of bungles what she had to say.
I also don't think it a good practice to run
continuing video footage of the accused while recounting the "most damning" traits spouted off by the good doc! That is just not good objective journalism.
But I do think this station is trying, I honestly do. I look to see some more "anniversary" coverage from them, and I hope it is less flawed.
And no matter what, it was this station that brought us the original "full Stephen McDaniel interview". That one will never be forgotten.