Germany/Portugal - Christian Brueckner, 27 @ time of 1st crime (2004), charged with sexual assault crimes, Praia de Rocha, Portugal. #2

Welcome to Websleuths!
Click to learn how to make a missing person's thread

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
Pending:
*Charged on October 11, 2022 & arrest warrant reinstated 11/18/22 – (@ am CET) – Germany/Portugal - Hazel Behan (20 @ time/now 39) (in her home, June 16, 2004, Praia de Rocha on the Algarve coast, 10 miles from Praia de Luz, Portimao, Portugal) - *Christian Stefan Brückner (Bruekner) (27 @ time of 1st crime (2004)/45/now 46) charged (Oct. 11, 2022) with sexual assault (suspect held a knife & brutally raped her. The accused then tied & gagged the woman to a table & raped her again. He then whipped the victim on the back with a whip he had brought with him & finally forcibly performed oral sex with the victim. The accused filmed large parts of the events with a video camera he had brought with him). Braunschweig Regional District Court Case
Germany/Portugal – *Charged (Oct. 11, 2022) & arrest warrant reinstated 11/18/22 - a 14 year old teenager (assaulted/hit the naked girl with a whip. Said to have brutally forced the girl to have oral sex. The accused also videotaped this act). Took place between Dec. 28, 2000 to April 8, 2006 on the Praia da Luz, Algarve coast, Portugal.
Germany/Portugal - *Charged (Oct. 11, 2022) & arrest warrant reinstated 11/18/22 - an elderly woman 70-80 yrs old (tied up & raped the victim in her holiday apt. He then hit the victim several times with a whip. The accused is said to have recorded the entire event with a video camera). Took place around the same time (between Dec. 28, 2000 to April 8, 2006) on the Praia de Luz, Algarve coast, Portugal.
Germany/Portugal – *Charged (Oct. 11, 2022) & arrest warrant reinstated 11/18/22 - 10 year old German girl (Joana.E) (wearing only shoes & otherwise naked. He grabbed the child's wrist & began to perform masturbation movements on his naked penis). On Salema (Zalema) beach, near Praia de Luz, Portugal, April 7, 2007).
Germany/Portugal – *Charged (Oct. 11, 2022) & arrest warrant reinstated 11/18/22 - 11 year old Portuguese girl (pulled down his trousers & underpants & made masturbation movements on his naked penis in order to sexually arouse himself, until the frightened girl ran to her father for help. The suspect was arrested on the spot by the Portuguese police). Exposed himself in playpark, São Bartolomeu de Messines, June 11, 2017).
Brueckner is currently serving a 7 year sentence for the 2005 rape on a pensioner. While he is still the main suspect in Madeleine case, these above cases will be tried first & he will be charged with Madeleine later.
*Will be Charged later (maybe) (@ am CET) – Germany/Portugal – Madeleine Beth McCann (3) (May 3, 2007, disappeared from hotel room while sleeping with her younger twin siblings, while parents ate at restaurant near the Mark Warner Ocean Summer Club in Praia da Luz; not found) - *Christian Stefan Brückner (Brueckner) (30 @ time of crime/43/now 46) named suspect on Sept. 17, 2020.
7/5/22: The British investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann is being continued for another year by the Metropolitan Police. This funding runs until March 2023. Regular reviews between the MPS & the Home Office continue to take place throughout the year. Operation Grange remains open at this present time.
Oct. 11, 2022 Update: Specifically, the accused is charged with three acts of serious rape & two acts of sexual abuse of children, specifically:
1. On June 16, 2004 at around 3:00am, the accused in Praia da Rocha in Portugal is said to have gained access to the apartment of a then 20-year-old woman (Behan) from Ireland via the balcony. The sleeping woman was then awakened by the masked suspect holding a knife & brutally raped. The accused then tied & gagged the woman to a table & raped her again. He then whipped the victim on the back with a whip he had brought with him & finally forcibly performed oral sex with the victim. The accused filmed large parts of the events with a video camera he had brought with him. While the accused later fled over the balcony, the victim managed to free herself & crying to ask for help.
2. On another day between December 28, 2000 & April 8, 2006, which can no longer be precisely determined, the accused allegedly assaulted an unknown, German-speaking girl aged at least 14 naked in the house he lived in in Praia da Luz in Portugal tied to a wooden pole in the living room. First he hit the naked girl with a whip. The accused is said to have brutally forced the girl to have oral sex. The accused also videotaped this act.
3. At a point in time that cannot be determined more precisely between December 28, 2000 & April 8, 2006, surprising an unknown 70-80 year old woman in her bedroom in her holiday apartment in Portugal. Then the masked suspect is said to have tied up & raped the victim. He then hit the victim several times with a whip. The accused is said to have recorded the entire event with a video camera.
4. On April 7, 2007 at around 3:30pm, the accused is said to have ambushed a 10-year-old German girl who was playing on the rocks behind a hole on a section of beach in Salema in the district of Faro in Portugal, wearing only shoes & otherwise naked. He grabbed the child's wrist & began to perform masturbation movements on his naked penis. He asked the girl with a grin to look at his naked genitals & the masturbation movements he was making in order to sexually arouse himself. After the accused had ejaculated, he let go of the girl & fled.
5. On June 11, 2017, in the early hours of the morning at around 2am during the so-called snail festival on a playground in Bartolomeu de Messines in Portugal, the accused made eye contact with an 11-year-old Portuguese girl who was on the swings of the playground there have sat. Then, while constantly eyeing the child, the accused pulled down his trousers & underpants & made masturbation movements on his naked penis in order to sexually arouse himself, until the frightened girl ran to her father for help. The suspect was arrested on the spot by the Portuguese police. On the basis of the indictment, an arrest warrant was also requested because the public prosecutor's office believed that there was an urgent suspicion of a crime. There is also a risk of escape and repetition.

Brueckner info from June 1, 2020 thru May. 25, 2023 reference post #7 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/...man-prisoner-identified-as-suspect-36.680100/

May 31, 2023 Update: Detectives from the Federal Criminal Police (BKA), Germany’s equivalent of the FBI, spent days searching land next to the Arade Dam last week. They used sniffer dogs, radar & search teams to scour the location just 31 miles from where three-year-old Maddie vanished in 2007. After the dig cops left behind two-foot deep bore holes & it is believed the soil they recovered from them is being forensically analysed in Germany. The results could be revealed as soon as Thursday. It still remains unclear as to exactly why investigators decided to search the land near the dam so thoroughly. Police teams were seen methodically chopping down trees & hacking away at undergrowth to expose an area just a short distance from the water. Portuguese sources point to an informant giving police a specific tip-off that Brueckner visited the site just days after Maddie went missing from her room in Praia da Luz. This tip-off is believed to have been matched with geolocation clues found in the convicted paedophile's vile stash of 8,000 of videos & images. It was claimed they were searching for a camcorder & a gun tossed into the water but Portuguese police sources were quick to dismiss that. Chief public prosecutor Hans-Christian Wolters, who is pursuing the case against Brueckner, has said in the past they have “concrete evidence” that tragic Maddie is dead & believe Brueckner killed her. Wolters confirmed that they will be making an announcement about the results of the dig soon. He suggested that his investigation team may not have discovered any crucial evidence just yet. Speaking to The Mirror, Mr Wolters said: “We will issue a short press release. But please don't expect too much, especially nothing spectacular.” Provisionally passed the case over to the region of Magdeburg (4/22/23). See post #402 on page 21 thread #38.
June 25, 2023 Update: Take with a grain of salt (from Daily Fail): German police investigating Madeleine McCann's disappearance have reportedly hit a 'roadblock' after being left 'disappointed' over the items they found during a search of a Portuguese reservoir. They said that they were hoping the items would provide new clues to follow up but that despite using some of the most high-tech forensic kit, none of the items helped their investigation. The source added: 'It feels like a bit of a roadblock has been hit. However, there are still some items to carry out checks on & the police team will continue to work hard to do all they can to try & make sure no stone is left unturned in checking every single item seized from that reservoir.'
June 30, 2023 Update: Helge Busching is the most important witness in the case and is now speaking publicly for the first time regarding Christan B. See post #615 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...soner-identified-as-suspect-37.681823/page-31

Aug. 8, 2023 Update: CB will find out in three weeks if he is likely to be released through a complex legal loophole after he was convicted of raping an American woman in Portugal in 2005. Lawyers for Brueckner appeared before a panel of five judges at the European Court of Justice, arguing that his detention is a breach of international law. They claim because this was not the crime he was extradited for from Portugal in June 2017 he should be freed.
Aug. 31, 2023 update from April, 2023 Update: CB was charged last year by German prosecutors in Brunswick with three offences of aggravated rape of women & two offences (regarding) children. The offences took place in Portugal between December 2000 and July 2017. They are not linked to MM’s disappearance. The regional tribunal in Brunswick, north Germany, said on Thursday it had decided it was “not competent” to hear the case against him because his “last known address” in Germany was in another state, Saxony-Anhalt. The trial had been due to start imminently.
Sept. 18, 2023 Update: A German higher regional court ruled on Tuesday that a state court can hear a sex offences case against Brueckne overruling the state court’s earlier decision that it did not have jurisdiction. The higher regional court in the northern city of Braunschweig said that the state court had wrongly declared itself without jurisdiction when it said in April that it was not responsible for hearing the case, arguing at the time that the region where it is located is not the last place where Christian Brueckner lived in Germany. The Braunschweig state court said in April its supposed responsibility for the case had been based on the suspect’s last residence before he went abroad & then to prison. But it said that was not valid, because the suspect produced evidence of a later residence in the neighbouring state of Saxony-Anhalt, where he was registered as the owner of a property that he kept after going abroad. However, on Tuesday the higher regional court said that the last domestic residence of the accused is to be determined on the basis of a multiplicity of different indications & proofs — in particular earlier statements of the accused — in Braunschweig.
Sept. 19, 2023 Update: In response to the public prosecutor's complaint, the 1st Criminal Senate has, with today's decision, overturned the decision of the Braunschweig Regional Court in the case 2 KLs 213 Js 52790/18. The regional court wrongly declared itself incompetent. Rather, the Braunschweig Regional Court has local jurisdiction over the charges and has to decide whether to open the proceedings. At the same time, the Senate reinstated the arrest warrant of November 18, 2022, which was revoked by the regional court in this context.
Thanks for all this
 
Not important but the twitter posts from the lay judge go back to August 2019 , I thought they were recent .
 
Not important but the twitter posts from the lay judge go back to August 2019 , I thought they were recent .

*snipped
Duration of the term of office of a lay judge

Lay judges are elected for a period of five years. They are eligible for reelection. However, after two consecutive terms of office they cannot be reelected for a third successive term of office.​
 
I was just about to post that Hazel has been incredibly brave to come forward and I hope she gets Justice. Appalling what she went through, absolutely appalling all these horrific crimes.
Why should she not get justice? Her case is actually going to trial , which is more than many rape cases do.
 
Why should she not get justice? Her case is actually going to trial , which is more than many rape cases do.
Justice will only happen if CB is found to be guilty, many seem assured of his guilt.imo
 
I am not sure why the mail reported this as a win for the defence. No one should want such a lay judge on the case as it could create an appealable error

The judge adjourned the court after just nine minutes to consider the request, before returning 40 minutes later and duly removed Ms Thielen-Donckel from the panel, scoring an early win for Brueckner's defence team.
 
But presumably the judges use the prosecution/defence arguments in their questioning of the witnesses? In the same way that when they give the go ahead to a charge and a trial, that it's fed by what the prosecution/defence presents to them?

The lawyers can make arguments and question the witnesses as well, but this really is different to a UK/US adversarial trial. The judges organise the proceedings and ask most of the questions.
 
The lawyers can make arguments and question the witnesses as well, but this really is different to a UK/US adversarial trial. The judges organise the proceedings and ask most of the questions.
I was a huge fan of the French television series shown in the UK , Spiral . This demonstrated to me how their system worked with the judge, as you've described . Is the German way exactly the same ?
 
I am not sure why the mail reported this as a win for the defence. No one should want such a lay judge on the case as it could create an appealable error
Sound better than just it being a procedural issue.
 
The lawyers can make arguments and question the witnesses as well, but this really is different to a UK/US adversarial trial. The judges organise the proceedings and ask most of the questions.
Do they ask what the defence or prosecution wish to ask?
 
I think people may recognise him from the thousands of photographs in the media, regardless of what they think they can remember from 17 years ago.

FF will obviously make this point.
There will always be a counter argument regarding any element of CB’s case & the evidence against him. I acknowledge that but I think in this instance you’re reaching just a tad too much.

People who came forward at the time, or people who worked there at the time or people who lived their at the time or people who stayed there at the time, may very well recognise CB. They may be able to substantiate that in other ways & they’ll obviously be assessed as to whether they’re a credible witness. IMO people will have known him, have seen him, tourists will have taken pictures with him in the background & people will undoubtedly see his face in the news & remember him. His pitted-skin/pocked-marked face is a rather unusual & no doubt an easy feature to remember.

Chalking future witnesses off because CB’s face has been in the media, may, as I said, be a bit too much of a reach.
 
Last edited:
I was a huge fan of the French television series shown in the UK , Spiral . This demonstrated to me how their system worked with the judge, as you've described . Is the German way exactly the same ?

God, I loved that series, it was so grittily good!
 
How very dare them to speak in German, in a German court involving a German accused of sexual crimes, no German press?


Speaking in German, the gathered English press pack, plus journalists from Spain, Portugal and Ireland, only managed to pick up the words ‘Twitter’, ‘X’, ‘Bolsonero’ and ‘James Palmer'
 
I am not sure why the mail reported this as a win for the defence. No one should want such a lay judge on the case as it could create an appealable error
The prosecution are going to be storming back.

It will be better for us with a substitute judge and gives the defence the belief they have had a small early victory, but we’ll come storming back next week.
 
Just don't get involved that deep into the layjudge-gate.

It's really not a big deal! It just shows, that the german judicial system uses to take things seriously!

The defence tries to remove the focus to technical circumstances, so the substantive circumstances shall not be that interesting to everybody!

Everything still seems to be fine!
 
There will always be a counter argument regarding any element of CB’s case & the evidence against him. I acknowledge that but I think in this instance you’re reaching just a tad too much.

People who came forward at the time, or people who worked there at the time or people who lived their at the time or people who stayed there at the time, may very well recognise CB. They may be able to substantiate that in other ways & they’ll obviously be assessed as to whether they’re a credible witness. IMO people will have known him, have seen him, tourists will have taken pictures with him in the background & people will undoubtedly see his face in the news & remember him. His pitted-skin/pocked-marked face is a rather unusual & no doubt an easy feature to remember.

Chalking future witnesses off because CB’s face has been in the media, may, as I said, be a bit too much of a reach.
In relation to these five cases, I think there were only witness statements at the time for the indecent exposure crimes.

Even HaB said he wore a mask.

The fact that CB was on the Algarve during the time of these crimes is no evidence - he lived there.

The same goes for the existence of photos.

My point is that the three rape cases are likely circumstantial. If witnesses have only come forward now, which seems likely, the media exposure defence is likely.

It’s been reported that a witness saw CB leaving HaB’s apt. IMO, this statement is less credible if the witness came forward now rather than at the time.

Memory is not reliable and while statements could be used to support forensics it going to be more difficult if that all HCW and team have.
 
In relation to these five cases, I think there were only witness statements at the time for the indecent exposure crimes.

Even HaB said he wore a mask.

The fact that CB was on the Algarve during the time of these crimes is no evidence - he lived there.

The same goes for the existence of photos.

My point is that the three rape cases are likely circumstantial. If witnesses have only come forward now, which seems likely, the media exposure defence is likely.

It’s been reported that a witness saw CB leaving HaB’s apt. IMO, this statement is less credible if the witness came forward now rather than at the time.

Memory is not reliable and while statements could be used to support forensics it going to be more difficult if that all HCW and team have.
Probably so, but when the rape occurred there may have been little detailed publicity, so the witness might not have been aware that a crime had taken place around that time and area.
Sounds weak though, as how can anyone be sure about time and date almost twenty years later ?
 
I was a huge fan of the French television series shown in the UK , Spiral . This demonstrated to me how their system worked with the judge, as you've described . Is the German way exactly the same ?

The biggest difference in my opinion is that in an adversarial system the jury start knowing nothing about the case and then each side presents their theory, evidence and witnesses. It's a battle between two competing theories of the case, in which the judge controls the proceedings and decides what things the jury can hear about. Then the jury decides.

In the german inquisitorial system, the judges already know everything about the case so far. Now is their chance to ask questions and get closer to the truth. Prosecutor and defence lawyers are participants in that process who can also ask questions of witnesses for example. But they are not presenting a case like in the UK.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
272
Guests online
749
Total visitors
1,021

Forum statistics

Threads
607,034
Messages
18,214,370
Members
234,023
Latest member
GlennOthram
Back
Top