Gilgo Beach LISK Serial Killer, Rex Heuermann, charged with 3 murders, July 2023 #4

[elephant29]

Being that they’re investigating properties in other states I have a theory. What if peaches and the toddler were transported from NC (I read somewhere that peaches had DNA matches in Alabama) and came and dumped their bodies in NY

 

[Knitty]

MOD NOTE

Please keep the conversation about THIS CASE.

Generalized opinions about womens’ safety issues as a whole and the legalization of sex work in the U.S. and other countries are important topics, but they veer the discussion AWAY from the victims in this case, and make it more about your experiences, stories and perspectives. If your post does not even mention these crimes, then you are probably off topic.

We cannot right all the wrongs of our society on this forum, and we cannot delve into a subject that will quickly (and has already) been discussed as a political issue - we all know how political discussions go and why political discussions are generally not allowed at Websleuths.

We ask that you put the attention on the victims in this case, in their threads, and on the accused in this thread. Going forward, posts that are generalized statements of the state of women’s safety, and post about the legalization of sex work in the U.S. or other countries, may be removed. Although sometimes valuable, they start a long line of replies so that at some point members and the visitors who come here may be confused about what the thread is actually about. You CAN have those chats in PMs, and as many as 20 members may participate in a PM. PMs are unmoderated and Private. Only those in the PM will see the messages.

THANK YOU for helping us keep this thread on topic.

 

[Kikalina]

The way he called called to taunt some of them and was still searching them online recently, it wouldn’t surprise me.

Did I read somewhere that the relatives he was searching were the girls children? Did I make this up?

 

[Friday13]

Did I read somewhere that the relatives he was searching were the girls children? Did I make this up?

I believe I read that as well but I don’t remember what source

 

[Eaglette]

Gilgo Beach is where the young vulnerable girls were left, raped, tortured, and dead. But where did he do this to them?????? Not on that beach. In his house????? No one could hear screams? How’d he get them all to his house? At hotels? He must have been a mess leaving. Does anyone know? Thanks. I love the research abilities some of you have, truly amazing.

I think a Killer can hone skills to gag pretty quickly & get better at it over time.

I've read most have a Rape Kit in a car.

Say.... 20sec & a Killer could insert a tea towel into a mouth. Or a tee shirt etc

I mean, look at the size of him he could overpower most females

 

[Emilie D]

Being that they’re investigating properties in other states I have a theory. What if peaches and the toddler were transported from NC (I read somewhere that peaches had DNA matches in Alabama) and came and dumped their bodies in NY

Both have been on all the doe sites and still unidentified. While your theory is possible, it’s also possible the non gb4 victims have nothing to do with RH. Anything is possible at this point.

 

[Inthedetails]

I think a Killer can hone skills to gag pretty quickly & get better at it over time.

I've read most have a Rape Kit in a car.

Say.... 20sec & a Killer could insert a tea towel into a mouth. Or a tee shirt etc

Plus, he's an architect and perhaps installed soundproofing in a room.

jmo

 

[imstilla.grandma]

Philip Walker, 56, who is incarcerated at the Suffolk County Correctional Facility, told the newspaper that inmates likely are not fans of Heuermann because of his alleged attacks on the opposite sex.

“Crimes against women and girls, especially killing them, is frowned upon here. A lot of us have sisters, daughters, mothers. No one likes guys who did crimes like that,” Walker told the Post.

The 59-year-old architect is presently being kept in isolation and is on suicide watch. The facility in Riverhead, New York, allegedly goes on lockdown when Heuermann is moved around, Walker told the newspaper.

“Everything shuts down when they move him to the yard, medical, whatever. Over the speakerphone, they said, ‘Stop all inmate movement,’” Walker told the Post. “We all know it’s for him.”

If Heuerman were to be kept with the rest of the jail inmates in the “general population,” Walker said the accused serial killer could be attacked.

“I don’t think people would be too happy if he was in population. I don’t think it would be good if he was moved into population. I could see someone doing something to him,” Walker told the Post.

Is Rex Heuermann in Danger? Inmate Has Warning For Accused Gilgo Beach Serial Killer

A fellow inmate of Rex Heuermann says the accused Gilgo Beach serial killer may be in danger while he’s in jail as the case against him proceeds, the New York Post reports. Philip Walker, 56, who is incarcerated at the Suffolk County Correctional Facility, told the newspaper that inmates likely...

www.crimeonline.com

 

[x_files]

Do serial killers study or read about other serial killers?

Most likely obsessively as if it is their career or profession and even competitive to outdo the last one.

 

[x_files]

For anyone ruling out other potential victims because they aren't his type. Note his Google searches... "mature escorts manhattan". Other descriptors used in searches - CP, black, chubby, fat, short and skinny.

I'd like to see all of the search history but guess we'll have to wait.

I think he had several types ranging in age, gender, size, and shape, so I imagine they will find other victims.

 

[Mountain_Kat]

That's my understanding, as well. I think the promise of much larger than usual payment was the enticement to go with him.

But here's the thing, Fredna... according to Dave, Amber only did incalls because she was beaten and thrown from the car on a date. She was scared of doing outcalls. Would she REALLY willingly get into the car of the john she had just the night before scammed out of his money ? Would she willingly do that for ANY amount of money ? And agree to leave her phone behind ?

I'm just not seeing that. JMO

 

[Inthedetails]

Being that they’re investigating properties in other states I have a theory. What if peaches and the toddler were transported from NC (I read somewhere that peaches had DNA matches in Alabama) and came and dumped their bodies in NY

That's an idea to consider. Good thinking.

 

[Inthedetails]

But here's the thing, Fredna... according to Dave, Amber only did incalls because she was beaten and thrown from the car on a date. She was scared of doing outcalls. Would she REALLY willingly get into the car of the john she had just the night before scammed out of his money ? Would she willingly do that for ANY amount of money ? And agree to leave her phone behind ?

I'm just not seeing that. JMO

How do you think she ended up with him that night? I think the lure of extra money made her drop her guard. jmo

 

[Emilie D]

But here's the thing, Fredna... according to Dave, Amber only did incalls because she was beaten and thrown from the car on a date. She was scared of doing outcalls. Would she REALLY willingly get into the car of the john she had just the night before scammed out of his money ? Would she willingly do that for ANY amount of money ? And agree to leave her phone behind ?

I'm just not seeing that. JMO

Maybe he was following her that night and when when she was finished with the client that picked her up, he grabbed her forcefully? Or he was able to take her by some other means while she was leaving someone else? This one is bugging me too.

 

[MinnesotaMary]

I agree. When they finish there may only be a shell of a house remaining!

I was real Creeped Out by those 4 coconut head DOLLS in their kitchen omLord!!!!!

 

[iamshadow21]

Being that they’re investigating properties in other states I have a theory. What if peaches and the toddler were transported from NC (I read somewhere that peaches had DNA matches in Alabama) and came and dumped their bodies in NY

He would have had to be speedy - Peaches' torso was found approximately three days after she died. And dismemberment isn't quick, so it would have taken a decent segment of that time to accomplish. I would also assume that disposal most likely took place at night to avoid discovery. He left her in Hempstead Lake Park, Jones Beach Park, and in one or more other places, as a significant amount of her body was never found. Also, Toddler Doe, her baby, was found on Cedar Beach, a little up the coast from Gilgo. That's killing twice, dismembering an adult, driving those bodies away from the kill site, disposing of them in a minimum of four places, in under three days.

It's possible the whole crime started out-of-state, but when would he sleep? Perhaps he didn't.

To make this post relevant to the arrestee, we know that for a time, RH worked for Jones Beach as a seasonal worker in his young adulthood. He would have known the area well.

MOO

 

[wcasewatch]

Maybe because so far, RH has only been charged with 3 of the murders. Add that to the fact that from very early on in this case to current, officials in LI and professors of psychology have yet to settle on one vs more than one killer in this case. You argue that you follow the facts but so far there is no evidence to link the remaining bodies to the gb4 except location. I for one, do not believe the remaining victims are his. They could however belong to an already caught SK that was also working in the area.

Almost every expert who has spoken about this case has said that it points to one killer. This includes the BAU, who were given access to the evidence when the investigation first started. IMO, the chances of Rex dumping the remains of women with similar victim profiles in the same area that another killer had recently stopped using are less likely.

 

[MinnesotaMary]

It'd make sense that, if Rex didn't do any of those Long Isl' murders, the reason he did searches on those, too, would be to try to find out what 'new techniques' law enf' has. I was JOLTED - Rex had the burner fone on which he searched all those 10000000s of torture *advertiser censored*/child p', and 'Task Force'/Giglo & Long Isl' N HIS PERSON!! Talk about a Smoking Gun!

 

[Emilie D]

Almost every expert who has spoken about this case has said that it points to one killer. This includes the BAU, who were given access to the evidence when the investigation first started. IMO, the chances of Rex dumping the remains of women with similar victim profiles in the same area that another killer had recently stopped using are less likely.

There are hundreds of serial killers with the same victim profiles. They choose women they believe can throw away and they won’t be missed. Not every expert agrees. There are several in both shows about this that could see it being two. I guess we shall see.

 

[NyxNY]

when did he eat the pizza?
Weeks ago, surely?
And they had the bottles

love it when a murderer judges another murderer

He will not be moved to gen pop.