Gilgo Beach LISK Serial Killer, Rex Heuermann, charged with 3 murders, July 2023 #8

[marble]

I understand you have heard about a situation where there was no water left for cats.

That does not demonstrate that LE was negligent in their search of Rex Heuermann's home. Nor does it demonstrate neglect for the family pets.

(snipped by me)

I am sick to death of turning to this thread and seeing so much hostility towards LE's investigation, which has been successful and productive since the task force was formed. I for one am proud of their progress. I think that acting like taking the reasonable step of putting cats in a shelter is some kind of special horror the family has been subjected to is no more than an attempt to discredit LE.

MOO

I did not *hear* about this situation, I was directly involved in it and it was awful.

I am not discrediting the recent investigation, far from it. I fail to see how these can't be two separate things- Asa and family are facing trauma which included having their cats put in a shelter where they could not immediately track them down, a shelter that does euthanize animals, and LE and detectives needed to search and open up every inch of the house.

All these "I'm sure the cats were fine" posts are in retrospect. The family did not know that at the time and there are *many* real life stories of pets being harmed in the midst of procedures and investigations. It happens and I was a first-hand witness to this. Police are not infallible (um, hello look at all of the people who were in charge before this latest task force).

I understand that lack of more details and evidence being forthcoming these past few weeks creates a vacuum but why fill it with attacking an innocent family and denying the obvious trauma they are experiencing? Nobody is helping get justice for the LISK victims and their families by going after the suspect's family. That's not how justice works.

 

[dotr]

''Aug 27, 2023 #CourtTV #btknews #rexheuermann
The Long Island Serial Killer suspect, Rex Heuermann, appeared to be an average man at first until he was arrested and charged with 3 of the Gilgo Beach Murders. #CourtTV analyzes how serial killers blend in and why the public is fascinated by them. MORE HERE: https://www.courttv.com/news/suspect-..''

 

[Ruminations]

I did not *hear* about this situation, I was directly involved in it and it was awful.

I am not discrediting the recent investigation, far from it. I fail to see how these can't be two separate things- Asa and family are facing trauma which included having their cats put in a shelter where they could not immediately track them down, a shelter that does euthanize animals, and LE and detectives needed to search and open up every inch of the house.

All these "I'm sure the cats were fine" posts are in retrospect. The family did not know that at the time and there are *many* real life stories of pets being harmed in the midst of procedures and investigations. It happens and I was a first-hand witness to this. Police are not infallible (um, hello look at all of the people who were in charge before this latest task force).

I understand that lack of more details and evidence being forthcoming these past few weeks creates a vacuum but why fill it with attacking an innocent family and denying the obvious trauma they are experiencing? Nobody is helping get justice for the LISK victims and their families by going after the suspect's family. That's not how justice works.

This is the thing:

Nobody is attacking the family.

Nobody wants the family separated from her cats.

Some posters, such as I, call BS on the cats being brought to a shelter as an example of mistreating the family by LE.

And since it is a BS accusation against LE, it is discrediting them, not fair and constructive criticism.

Calling out a BS accusation against LE is not an attack on the family.

MOO

 

[Forest_Wood]

What a terrific interview with Sheriff Toulon and the interviewer was great too. He came across as being very transparent and illustrated how the Task Force is working together on this, and other, cases. Very informative!

 

[Jurisprudence]

I am a very strong supporter of LE. And a case of multiple deaths like this -- they can do almost no wrong. BUT cat litter boxes strewn???? Even if you have to check the bottom of the boxes, come on LE folks -- scattering it about is too nasty for your own crew to have to work in even if you are wearing hazmat suits. I understand the couch being ripped apart. Trophies could have been hidden in the cushions. As for the cats - where I come from adult cats are not easily adopted. I'd think if Asa wanted them back, they may still be with rescue and available to her.

I will say what others may not. It is my opinion only. Please consider the source. This is a person who filed a claim and is currently trying to receive a settlement. The best thing that could happen would be to learn that LE PHOTOGRAPHED that home as it was when they entered it because I believe maybe 1/10th of what I've been seeing. It seems to get more and more ramped up.

This is MOO.

ETA: After I made this post I came to see that some other have in fact said the same.

 

[Jurisprudence]

what right do they have to take her pets to a shelter? I would never have allowed that I don't care what all went on..mOO

Respectfully, we don't know the facts surrounding this. They could have been sick, malnourished, neglected.

MOO

 

[Jurisprudence]

At this point, I don't believe anything that Asa or her attorneys are saying about what LE did when they searched Rex's home. Nothing negative, I'm just reserving judgment until more is known.

ETA: The reason I'm reserving judgment is that I'm still not certain of all of Macedonio's motives when it comes to his legal representation of Rex H's wife. I don't recall any other murder case I've followed where an attorney representing the killer's wife set up an aggressive legal and PR campaign to bash the police who arrested the killer, using the wife as a tool.

He's also doing this with the knowledge that LE can't respond without compromising their case against his client's husband.

THANK YOU, Betty!

Moo (too)

 

[Jurisprudence]

ARE there any kill shelters in NY? That's where Macedonia claimed they were taken.

MOO

Edited to add: Took my lazy fingers to google. Yes. Even the ones that claim no kill have rising healthy pet euthanasia rates. And they outsource it sometimes to move around statistics. Very depressing.

I'd like to see him swear to that in papers filed with a court.

jmo

 

[Jurisprudence]

I am personally sick to death of coming here to read news of what else may have been discovered only to see pages upon pages of posts criticizing his family and saying things like the report of cats being moved to a kill shelter a ploy to "pull on heart strings". If my pets were removed from a crime scene to a shelter where I wasn't sure whether I'd get them in time before they were euthanized and I didn't understand what was happening my being distraught over this wouldn't be an overreaction. There's no shortage of stories of innocent people's pets (or just innocent pets) being harmed by Law enforcement or neglected. I have some stories of my own with a friend whose father was murdered and they were not allowed in the apartment for days to rescue his three cats. LE and detectives were in and out of the apartment during that time and none of them even left WATER for them. It took heroic measures for her to rescue them and they were extremely near death and dehydrated when she finally forced her way in. Please leave this poor family alone. It's sick the abuse that's being poured on them and I'm surprised these posts are allowed to stay up.

In order to take that position you have to take what has been said to you as fact. I don't think that can be done at this time.

I also don't believe LE has a right to kick homeowners out when executing a warrant on their premises. Maybe someone in LE can check on this. If this is the case, there was nothing stopping AE from going to the home to take her pets out which begs the question: If she had no plans to be in the home during the search did LE ask her if she planned to come get them? And more importantly, if not, did LE OFFER to take them to a shelter for the duration of the search and did she take them up on this?

Remember too, they are trying to preserve evidence.

jmo

 

[Betty P]

THANK YOU, Betty!

Moo (too)

It's not that I don't feel some level of sympathy for Rex Heuermann's family, but I don't believe everything their attorney is saying. Rex's wife has actually said very little. I'm just waiting to see what comes.

Since the arrest of Rex and the searching of the home, we've heard very little from LE and the DA. They're the main source information about the case, evidence, etc. Anything new to be learned is probably going to come from them.

 

[Jurisprudence]

What a terrific interview with Sheriff Toulon and the interviewer was great too. He came across as being very transparent and illustrated how the Task Force is working together on this, and other, cases. Very informative!

Interesting that the approx 5 visitation requests that RH denied were from media and possible podcasters. He's not taking any chances that what he'll say will be used against him.

jmo

 

[Ruminations]

With all due respect in order to take that position you have to take what has been said to you as fact. I don't think that can be done at this time.

I don't believe LE has a right to kick homeowners out when executing a warrant on their premises. Maybe someone in LE can check on this. If this is the case, there was nothing stopping AE from going to the home to take her pets out.

jmo

I think they can kick homeowners out in most cases. Especially if there is a risk to the evidence or a risk to the officers conducting the search.

Often enough, police will allow homeowners to stay in, say, the living room if they are searching the bedroom. Or they will retrieve a specific item or escort someone to get it. AFAIK, that is just a courtesy.

When it comes to the cats, I believe the phrasing was that Asa was not able to locate them.

MOO

 

[Ruminations]

Respectfully, we don't know the facts surrounding this. They could have been sick, malnourished, neglected.

MOO

Its possible they were unable to have the cats released to their alleged home in a rental car.

 

[Forest_Wood]

It's not that I don't feel some level of sympathy for Rex Heuermann's family, but I don't believe everything their attorney is saying. Rex's wife has actually said very little. I'm just waiting to see what comes.

Since the arrest of Rex and the searching of the home, we've heard very little from LE and the DA. They're the main source information about the case, evidence, etc. Anything new to be learned is probably going to come from them.

Their chosen attorneys, unfortunately, are not the best advocates for their clients imo.

They've portrayed the family poorly by seeking sympathy and money from the public from the beginning, without so much as empathizing with or even acknowledging the murder victims or their families.

AE seemed defiant from the beginning, giving the finger, and so on. She seemed to come around slightly after someone asked if she'd welcome donations.

Now she's back to shoo-shooing reporters, according to this article. “Shoo, shoo,” she said, extending her hands as if dismissing a dog. “We’ve got too much work to do.”

Her lawyers have done her a grave disservice imo from the get-go.

Once Rarely Seen, Gilgo Beach Suspect’s Family Now Barbecues on the Lawn (Published 2023)

After Rex Heuermann was charged in a notorious string of murders, neighbors assumed his wife and children would vanish. They haven’t.

www.nytimes.com

 

[Jurisprudence]

Their chosen attorneys, unfortunately, are not the best advocates for their clients imo.

They've portrayed the family poorly by seeking sympathy and money from the public from the beginning, without so much as empathizing with or even acknowledging the murder victims or their families.

AE seemed defiant from the beginning, giving the finger, and so on. She seemed to come around slightly after someone asked if she'd welcome donations.

Now she's back to shoo-shooing reporters, according to this article. “Shoo, shoo,” she said, extending her hands as if dismissing a dog. “We’ve got too much work to do.”

Her lawyers have done her a grave disservice imo from the get-go.

Once Rarely Seen, Gilgo Beach Suspect’s Family Now Barbecues on the Lawn (Published 2023)

After Rex Heuermann was charged in a notorious string of murders, neighbors assumed his wife and children would vanish. They haven’t.

www.nytimes.com

Agree. They have made it worse for her imo.

 

[Jurisprudence]

Its possible they were unable to have the cats released to their alleged home in a rental car.

LE asking her what she plans to do about her pets and if she has no intention to return to the home to care for them I could see them offering up the shelter and I could see her taking them up on it.

We just don't know. All we know now is that we have a claimant who is trying to make out a case for monetary damages and a potential settlement suddenly making a lot of statements about the injustices done to her. It doesn't sit well with me. And, as you know, I'm a lawyer for decades. I am appalled at the way Macedonia has handled this case. It's self-serving to the detriment of his client.

And, this is jmo. Others are free to love him.

ETA: And, all of this is in the midst of a quadruple homicide investigation that may eventually expand exponentially if other states are involved. This isn't about her.

 

[minazoe]

they have a conclusive DNA sample now. once he is convicted it will go into CODIS, hits will come up no doubt.it really could
be time for him to accept he will never go home again. he's not going to get off and if he did something in a DP state...if he killed in SC.where ever isn't it best if he ends it now ? they better keep a real close eye on him. mOO

 

[minazoe]

LE asking her what she plans to do about her pets and if she has no intention to return to the home to care for them I could see them offering up the shelter and I could see her taking them up on it.

We just don't know. All we know now is that we have a claimant who is trying to make out a case for a monetary damages and a potential settlement, suddenly making a lot of statements about the injustices done to her. It doesn't sit well with me. And, as you know, I'm a lawyer for decades. I am appalled at the way Macedonia has handled this case. It's self-serving to the detriment of his client.

And, this is jmo. Others are free to love him.

there are people who have been inside that house and can testify as to the condition of that house prior to LE tossing the place. mOO

 

[Forest_Wood]

there are people who have been inside that house and can testify as to the condition of that house prior to LE tossing the place. mOO

I am certain they took photos before, during and after of every nook and cranny in that home.

 

[Ruminations]

Their chosen attorneys, unfortunately, are not the best advocates for their clients imo.

They've portrayed the family poorly by seeking sympathy and money from the public from the beginning, without so much as empathizing with or even acknowledging the murder victims or their families.

AE seemed defiant from the beginning, giving the finger, and so on. She seemed to come around slightly after someone asked if she'd welcome donations.

Now she's back to shoo-shooing reporters, according to this article. “Shoo, shoo,” she said, extending her hands as if dismissing a dog. “We’ve got too much work to do.”

Her lawyers have done her a grave disservice imo from the get-go.

Once Rarely Seen, Gilgo Beach Suspect’s Family Now Barbecues on the Lawn (Published 2023)

After Rex Heuermann was charged in a notorious string of murders, neighbors assumed his wife and children would vanish. They haven’t.

www.nytimes.com

I didn't really mind her flipping off the press or shooing away gawkers at her BBQ.

I'd be like, "This isn't the story, dudes. F-off and cover the victims! I've got mouths to feed."

But because of her attorneys, people assume the worst in her attitude."

MOO