I think this suspect definitely deserves to be checked out. He fits the physical image well...white male, middle age (40s), light brown/blonde hair colour, similar hair cut, facial hair. In some of his photos on FB he looks older, while in others he looks younger...just like BG looks different in the two shots.
In terms of a profile, it looks like he is currently single (which could explain why someone hasn't turned him in) and works for a van lines (many have suspected a trucker). Delphi is just a straight shot north of Indianapolis up the 421. Does this guy travel this road for work or other reasons?
There are likely a lot of other midwestern middle age men with a similar look, but considering what this guy is wanted for, I think a tip should be sent to LE if it has not already.