To me, when LS hit her head (more than once), it adds yet another dimension. She had every reason to be confused upon arriving or leaving 5 North. The fact that she kept falling and had a noticeable black eye just kills me, not to mention CR dragging her around. IMO, she needed medical evaluation after hitting her head and falling more than once. So yes, you could be right ...
But considering all of the above, I still wonder if she was able to walk out JR's door.
If you look at every statement that is known or officially attributed to JR, don't you get the sense that he thoroughly interrogated and prosecuted himself?
He let her supposedly walk home because he had her prove she could walk inside of his apartment. Sure, within 1 hr of being drunk and or drugged and slamming her head at least 2 times on concrete and having to be carried because her legs were useless, she suddenly can pass a walking test in JR's apartment. To me this is something conjured up in the mind of someone who knew that they would be questioned and worked out their story.
Knowing full well that at some point it would come to light that she was far more messed up than CR that she may not sprung up and walked back to JR's but maybe was actually carried or dragged there from CR/MB's he would have to explain how it is that she left. So he comes up with this goofy walk test. Have you ever heard of anyone checking to see if your friends could walk before allowing them to leave? It's just not believable that she went from that state to a walking state in 1 hr. It's more like JR wants people to believe that is possible. Can't get convicted if there is enough doubt... and even to thwart a wrongful death suit would need angles to create doubt. What do you think? Was she crashing or was she recovering from 3:00 to 3:30?
Another revelation JR saw her getting a black eye, so he knew she had been injured or fallen. Another reason, to the piles of other reasons not to let her leave so soon or alone. Medical Experts, how long does it take for a black eye to start forming? I thought a black eye took several hours to form, so wondering how that is possible. Shouldn't it instead be all red and puffy? Why would you not take someone to a hospital or call an ambulance if they clearly had a significant head trauma and were not able to stand?
At the very least you would not let them stumble down the the street, it's just not believable. It feels like a carefully crafted story to already have an explanation for everything. So JR passes the "hot potato" situation off to alternative theories because he says he saw her leave, and after all he gave her the walking test first. odds of her being able to walk 1 hr later are very slim, in fact odds of her being conscious are slim. Unless... JR tried to keep her awake. Why would he do that? How would he do that?
How about this scenario - she's going down hard and fast in CR/MB's place, JR gets brought over by MB, JR sees it's not good, and quickly goes and gets Person X, or Person X is already there with JR. Perhaps the idea is to run her over to the hospital... but for one thing JR is also unable to drive but clear enough to know what is going on. so Person X is tasked with getting her to the ER, perhaps just dropping her off there and quickly exiting (I've heard of this situation several times when people don't want to be involved). But what if she died on the way? Now what? It's a lot harder to drop off a dead body and exit than a person in trouble. So now they have to drive somewhere else to cover their butt. Then come back and tell JR what happened because of phones records. This may have taken 30 to 45 minutes and JR then thinks of the phone calls. (Could this be the role of the possible houseguest?) Also during this time JR may have wanted to clean up his place of anything incriminating whether related to her demise or not. this could also explain why Cadaver dogs did not smell anything - she may have been taken out while still alive or as she was dying. Similarly the car used was not one the police had checked.
As a test by the way, see if anyone 20 years old who relies on their smartphone for everything... knows 2 random people's phone numbers from their contact list (other than home and bf/gf) Most people do not memorize phone numbers these days who use smart phones. And trying to recall those numbers in this mental state when you can't tell an ipod from your iphone... uh not plausible.
This is it in a nutshell:
CR = AMNESIA - off the hook
MB = PASSES THE BUCK to JR - off the hook
JR = PROVIDES "Walk Test" and watches her miraculously walk just fine barefoot after being unable to stand up 1 hr prior. - off the hook
Nah!
CR's Amnesia story is in conflct with his characterization of events that he was the one messed up and LS was helping him (making her seem to have her faculties) when really he was able to carry her and she was not able to stand or hold herself upright. - BIG LIE CR!
MB says CR pukes and LS helps MB put CR to bed, when in fact she couldn't even stand or sit upright, and had her head slammed twice on the concrete in addition to what made her so out of it in the first place. Then MB says she wants to party more. - BIG LIES MB!
JR - claims she was at his place about 1 hr (few details yet about that supposed miracle hour) except that she mistakes an ipod for a phone, and supposedly calls 2 people and then passes the "walk test".
When instead it's far more likely that she slipped off into a coma, cardic event, or seizure, or combination or at the very least passes out.
So, she's just fine after 1 hr and walks down the street? - BIG LIE JR!
These 3 Liars know more and probably at least one of them knows all.
