I thought the same about the phone.I think it is possible some of her comments seam odd is she is just trying to portray her friend in the best light possible.What was she going to say she was suppose to meet up with her boyfriend but went to the bar instead.I think that is the same reason an earlier comment she made that LS left at 12:30 to go to JR to watch the same sports game (which would have been over by then) made no sense.She just did not want to say LS left at 12:30 to go party.
I agree that the students interviewed are trying to be helpful; presenting LS positively, while filling in a few personal details which may assist in locating LS.
However, the article may be slightly distorted for this same reason.
For example, in the beginning, the reader gets the impression that the group of people whom LS associated with at IU were part of a clique from younger camp days. Only at the very end of the article, does this quote change that impression:
"I wish we could go back to those camp days," she said, wondering what it would have been like if they all knew one another at the time. "We'd all be friends."
This statement may represent a clue:
Spierer volunteered with Habitat for Humanity to build homes in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina, and spent this year's spring break in Israel with her older sister, Rebecca, planting trees for the Jewish National Fund.
LS apparently traveled a lot, she was used to being on her own without her parents from a very young age, and she would have had a current passport.
Is it possible that LS was angry or depressed about something, and decided to run away to NYC or Israel? Did she have any interest (or close friends) in any other countries? If she were traveling by herself, she could have suffered an accident or health problem, and could be in a hospital somewhere; possibly shut off from media coverage of her own case.
Not sure if this comment is helpful: in college, my acquaintances included a group of five girls who all roomed together in the same dorm suite. Just as LS's associates would call her by her last name only, they would call each other by their last names, which seemed odd to me. From the same towns and nearby towns, they had known each other from high school. They all had easy majors; while they probably got passing grades, they didn't need to work hard. Loud music until 4:00 am, marihuana smoke in the hallway and non-stop visitors gave them the reputation of a clique of "party-iers," but they were also basically nice Long Island girls, not sleazy or drug dealers. Students who had to study would get very annoyed by their behavior.
One of my friends happened to run into one of these girls after graduation, and the girl spoke of needing to recover from the awful experience of being part of that group, almost as if it were a cult. She said that she felt that they were all just pulling each other down (morally), and that she never saw any of those girls anymore. We were surprised at that comment, since the clique had seemed almost like sisters.
[NOTE: I don't mean to imply that LS's roommates were the problem, just that people can have problems that are not apparent to others living in the same environment. Often the pain of an individual can be masked by one's overall impression of their group. ]
Therefore, some situation could have been upsetting to LS, which seemed harmless on the surface; upsetting enough for her to run away?