Newthoughts
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Feb 21, 2019
- Messages
- 2,158
- Reaction score
- 14,055
But why would she make anything up and why lie?PF also wouldn't have known that the occupants of 5B had closed & locked their patio door that night. IMO she made an assumption about the source of the alleged crying & sound of the patio doors based on what she later learned about events on Thursday 3rd May.
She said she was clear it was the flat below, she says it sounded like a child not a baby. She had a period of time to clearly define direction - it was a prolonged period of crying not a sudden scream - and she was clearly worried enough to listen out and remain alert until she heard doors opening and the crying stop. Something you wouldn't normally be alert to.
She is also clear that she was out on the 2nd so heard nothing. And heard nothing on the 3rd - the night in question. Probably because there was no crying to alert her
As far as I can see it was MSM that altered the date she said she heard crying to the 2nd to make it more dramatic.