I am way behind, but perhaps I am the only one not surprised or confused by these actions. I am now 27, but when I was younger meeting up with friends ect... this behavior is something I could see myself as doing. It seems pretty clear to me, actually. IMO on the payphone call with SM she made plans to meet him at Long Beards, when she arrived he wasn't there as agreed upon. She tried to call him several times, no answer. Decided he wasn't there, wasn't answering either, so she went back home. Got home, tried to call his cell phone twice since he didn't answer the other phone and had made plans to meet her. Was unsuccessful on the first attempt, he answered on the second one. They spoke, made a change of plans to meet at PTL, and she drove there. She tried to call him once she arrived because, once again, he wasn't there yet as planned.
Am I missing something in the timeline that would not make this plausible?