Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - Max Shacknai EMS Report
I had forgotten about this, but if true, the timing is significant? I tried to find if there were further discussion of what Nina said because I thought there were some, but haven't found them yet. Was any time pinpointed?
This is why I'm so disappointed that SDSO didn't follow up on NINA's polygraph.
NINA seems in constant contradiction based on her interviews. Lets examine this Tuesday night claim of Dr.Peterson on July 12,2011.
================================================
1-Jonah claimed in his Tuesday hearsay phone message to RZ's voicemail at 12:25am (7/13/11) that Max's condition had turned GRAVE.
2- Nina - has claimed Max's condition turned GRAVE on Thursday on several audio interviews and print articles.
3-Dina -claimed on at least 3 TV interviews during her quest to re-open Max's case this year that it wasn't until Friday that she knew Max wouldn't be leaving the hospital and never play soccer again.
================================================
TIMELINE - Tuesday Night
---------------------------------------
1- Nina and Dina told Jonah there's no hurry to come back as he left Rady Hospital to go to dinner with Adam and Rebecca.
2- Jonah returned to Rady Hospital at 8:00pm.
3- According to Nina she left Rady at 9:00pm after borrowing Jonah's car for some unexplained reason.
Based on this timeline....Dr. Peterson must've made this Tuesday night statement between 8:00pm and 9:00pm but that still doesn't explain why Jonah would wait 3 1/2 hours to phone RZ with this GRAVE news at such an hour that JS would know RZ would be asleep.This also doesn't explain why Nina and Dina have made repeated statements indicating it wasn't until days later that each knew Max was in GRAVE condition and not expected to live.
This is a KEY timeline question that Gore never released to the public to support his suicide theory....Dr.Peterson's statement to SDSO investigators that supported Jonah's Tuesday night claim that Max's condition turned GRAVE. Based on everything I've read or heard on this case.....Gore ONLY put out information to support HIS suicide theory so this silence with regards to what Dr. Peterson said or didn't say Tuesday night is a RED FLAG.I assume that this is just another KEY evidence material that Gore withheld from the Zahau family and Attorney Bremner because Ann Rule NEVER mentions any direct quotes from Dr.Peterson regarding this Tuesday night medical observation or the hospital chart for that matter.
How can we possibly know the TRUTH in this CRUCIAL KEY aspect of RZ's death investigation when the 3 people of interest have 3 different stories/days of that tragic week when Max's condition turned GRAVE? What is at stake....Gore based his entire suicide theory that Rebecca received the JS hearsay phone message at 12:50am on 7/13/11 and then proceeded in the next 2 hours to complete an intricate suicide because she was distraught. If there is NO confirmation that Dr.Peterson didn't release that GRAVE news Tuesday night and the hospital chart also didn't indicate a sudden change in Max's condition then Gore's suicide theory is history. The same could've happened to Gore's suicide theory if brash ME Lucas put RZ's time of death at 1:00am on 7/13/11 because that would've only given RZ 10 minutes to complete her intricate suicide after supposedly listening to Jonah's voicemail message at 12:50am. ME Lucas instead conveniently put the time of death at 3:00am during the Sept.2,2011 PC to "fit" Gore's suicide theory. ME Lucas in his Autopsy Report makes no mention of time of death.