AJ_DS
Former Member
- Joined
- Jun 18, 2014
- Messages
- 836
- Reaction score
- 0
For anyone interested posting my visual timeline, ( "Oscar Pistorius - Timeline 14 February 2013 - 1.56 am to 3.30 am" ), I finally managed to finish in time for closings based on all the ear-witness testimonies (not Motshuane since she gave no times). I worked on it as I went listening and transcribing bit by bit earwitness testimonies over the past months so I think I have most times, details, etc., correct and where I had to approximate or calculate I've given the whys and wheres but also tried to keep my opinion to a minimum as it was not to create a debate but to help visualise how from my workings the testimonies piece together.
Obviously there will be things I missed or got wrong so welcome any corrections or anything of real importance I missed (if I can fit anything else on it!) but please PM me any corrections or additions with a link and/or post number so I can check it out first as I don't always have time to keep up with the thread so may not find anything until past judgement, if ever!
The upload here is just a preview to show what it's about because it is unreadable so included link to it in photobucket with it's title title at the beginning of the post where it can be viewed and read by scrolling along but unfortunately AFAIK there are no options for enlarging or reducing so if anyone knows a better host would love to know. I already tried docdroid as a pdf which is so much better as you can select different viewing sizes but for some quirky reason the dotted time lines transfer as solid ones so it looks more like a typographic Mondrian or a constructivist artwork than a timeline so am trying to work out how to resolve the problem... any ideas? If I get the pdf problem sorted will post if anyone interested.
A few comments / corrections :
1. Silverwoods is a luxury estate, not a prison camp… the security guards are employed by the residents and view them as the Clients… The security staff would NEVER intervene or involve themselves in an argument between clients… their job is estate security, NOT domestic conflict resolution mediation… therefore the 'all clear' during the checkpoint at 2:20AM does NOT refer to what residents are doing in their homes. If Reeva was heard arguing loudly with OP, the security guard would NOT log it and considered it, as he should, as none of his business… in SA, poor black man does not meddle in the private affairs of rich white man.
2. EDVM's 'around 3AM' does not indicate exactly 3AM… gunshots occurred at 3:15AM
3. The sequence EDVM related to the Court is : 4 loud bangs, no other bangs, no other noises, no screams, complete silence, some time after a commotion, call to security, OP crying loudly. Therefore the commotion CANNOT be OP screaming for Reeva. The commotion heard and seen by EDVM's husband is Security buggy and Stander's arriving at OP's house.
4. DrJS tried to call many numbers after the first set of bangs but could not get through… therefore there is no 'waiting 13+ minutes' doing nothing as you suggested
5. MN an EN's 'early hours' does not mean 3:03AM… they only heard the last bang… no other bangs after that so it was at 3:15AM
6. MN was not leisurely doing a walk-about in his house after he heard the bang… he rushed to his daughter's bedroom door to make sure it was still locked then he took a quick look in his house if anything was wrong…then he called security at 3:16… therefore last gunshot at 3:15AM, 1 minute to check and phone call to security.
7. CJ's 3:16AM time is NOT from a server but from his own phone… it does NOT contradict the time that the gunshots were heard : 3:15AM
8. Correct time-duration-sequence of calls of OP's phone
03:19:03 (24s) Outgoing Johan Stander
Idle 38s between voice calls
03:20:05 (1m6s) Outgoing Netcare
Idle 22s between voice calls
03:21:33 (9s) Outgoing Pieter Baba
Idle 6s between voice calls
03:21:47 (7s) Outgoing Voicemail access
Idle 11s between voice calls
03:22:05 (12s) Incoming Pieter Baba
9. If a panicked OP can wake up a sleeping JS in the middle of the night and get him to come to his house with a 24-second phone call, Dr.JS can certainly get security to come to his house in a 16-second phone call.
10. 3:12AM seems to be a pivotal time in your chart… why and where does it come from ???
11. Interesting how you attempt to place most of the testimony evidence before the 3:15AM gunshots… I see that you question all of the witnesses with what they were doing between 3AM and 3:15AM, why they did not call security earlier, etc… EXCEPT MN and EN !!!
12. Interesting that the 'crying and can't speak' is mentioned but the 'everything is fine' is absent from your chart… bias anyone ?!?