I do worry about boyfriend, but first thoughts were does she have a computer? It was reported that a lady saw the two girls and a strange male walking in town. Its a small town, right? If the lady is not a loon, she probably knows what she saw. If this is true. Possibly a guy she met online that came to see her, and take her away from her "misery." No teenaged girl likes the step=dad, boyfriend. They love their daddies. The key is in the girlfriends answers....when I was that age, we snuck out to see the boys up the street all the time and walked the streets of my small town all hours of night.
The problem is, what kind of guy did she meet???
If boyfriend did harm her in that time, where is the crime scene? Did he leave after he came home? Where is his cell phone pinging?
Dad..he is going to hurt someone. I heard on Nancy Grace the mom admit that she was told she failed the polygraph, as did her boyfriend (per mom). The question she failed was did she know who harmed Hailey (a variation of that). When people suspicion someone, such as the boyfriend, I would guess that she would automatically become suspicious herself, as would anyone...just doubts, reasonable, so that would be enough to cause you to fail that question. I really dont think mom was involved.
I may be way off base, but Im banking on that witness that saw them walking, the internet, and a meeting. Hopefully a meeting that doesnt end tragic.
I hope she is home safe soon.