If it really happened the way he says, I can somewhat understand why he wouldn't call police at that time. They were separated and he was not living in the house-- most of the time he was staying at his brother's place. She had been dodging his phone calls and she told her mom she didn't want to go to Thanksgiving Dinner with him. If they were arguing at that time, he probably figured she would show back up later after dinner. He didn't say anything was missing or that it looked like a break in. He said things were moved around in weird places. Now I DO wonder why he didn't call the police when he went back to the house after the Thanksgiving meal (and after that weird facebook friend request) and his wife and daughter were STILL not home. That would have been the time I would have started calling her family and friends to try to track them down and called the police shortly after if no one had heard from her. Even if they had been arguing at the time, his daughter was gone too. They could have been in a car accident. It IS strange that he didn't call around looking for his daughter that night, IMO.
This is of course assuming the day happened as he said... :thinking: