"Not sure how that is different from anyone else's opinions here" ....I think that's the point. No one here is really trying to bash the guy. But objectively his knowledge of the case is a couple months behind on some things well-known here, he's not an attorney or detective or someone with some special perception in the way he thinks, he's not getting feedback from others like happens here, so I think we're just saying that we shouldn't give him any more value (or maybe even as much) as we give people at WS who are on top of the details and give real insight. But at the same time, if you have the time and interest, he has an opinion to share on what he has seen of the case.
I agree with you Steve, I enjoy reading peoples opinions and different angles. I certainly don't bash anyone
JMO