Hi all, a McCleary local here. I was gone for most of the summer and came back to find out something terrible happened in my small town. As is the custom of my generation, rather than getting information in person, I went online, and that's how I found this website. I have to say, it's pretty amazing to see how many people are involved and wanting to help. I've never closely followed missing person cases, so maybe it's the norm? But whatever the case, it's awesome what you're doing.
I did have one thing I wanted to add, that probably isn't any help, but may help you understand McCleary a little better. A lot of people have said they were shocked that in such a small town, and even in a neighborhood populated by houses, nobody saw anything. I just have to say it doesn't shock me at all. A few years ago, when I was about Lindsey's age, two teenagers attacked a friend and me in McCleary. I won't go into details, but we escaped and went for help, with the guys following us. It was a long walk through McCleary to get home, so we stopped at many places (the school, a friends' parents' house, etc) to find a trusted adult who would help protect us, explaining what happened. We were turned away everywhere by adults who didn't want to get involved.
I guess the point of that story is that I don't have much faith in a lot of the residents of McCleary. I think that if someone saw something happen to this girl, they wouldn't have done anything. Maybe they're ashamed of that now, who knows. My gut feeling is that someone probably knows more than they're letting on (even if they aren't responsible for her disappearance) but feels too guilty to fess up.
Like I said, that's probably no help at all, but as I was reading stuff on here, I couldn't help feeling that it needed to be said. This may be a small town, but it seems to have more of a big city attitude.