While cross-referencing the many case files in CCAP and from other internet sources concerning the Wisconsin-Iowa murder suspects and possible serial killers, I came across circumstantial, not direct, evidence showing that they (David and Stephen Peacock) and others acquainted with them lived in proximity of the murder sites or where the victims were last seen. I'll also show that some even lived in the hometowns of several of those that were murdered. All information is taken from public records or internet webpages and is readily available to the public.
The victims were:
Crystal Arensdorf, age 20, who disappeared July 4, 2001 from a bar in Dubuque, Iowa, was never found and is presumed dead. Two suspects from Wisconsin, brothers Stephen K. Peacock & David E. Peacock lived in Dubuque at the time. Within two weeks of being contacted by police on Aug. 16, the brothers broke their lease, quit their roofing job and moved to Mount Horeb, WI.
Deidre Harm, age 23, who disappeared from a downtown bar in Wisconsin Rapids, WI June 10, 2006 and was found dead November 20, 2006 west of Wisconsin Rapids in the Town of Seneca on Blueberry Ridge. Skeletal remains were scattered over a 3 acre area.
I'll have more on Deidre later. If I list all these guys/gals together it will only confuse you (and me). I was told that she was killed by 2 unknown black males because she had been busted and had set up some drug pushers who retaliated by either killing her or having her killed. More on that rumor later. Interestingly, the Wisconsin Rapids POI I'll be listing later is a black male and once lived in Milwaukee, Madison, Marshfield and WI Rapids, not to mention Mt. Horeb & Wausau.
Kelly Nolan, age 22, who disappeared June 23, 2007 from a bar in downtown Madison, WI and was found dead July 9, 2007 in the Town of Dunn, WI. "The death scene was described as complex".
Joel Marino, age 31, who was found stabbed to death by his home in Madison, WI on January 28, 2008. A man wearing a construction jacket was seen running from the scene.
Brittany Zimmerman, age 21, who was found dead April 2, 2008 from a "complexity of traumatic injuries" in her residence in Madison. ("Complexity of traumatic injuries" like from a roofing hammer? Were there any roofing/construction projects going on in the neighborhood at the time?)
Though I have no specific information that places any of the POI's at any of the crime scenes, I believe there is enough circumstantial evidence to give LE cause to investigate their whereabouts around the time the victims disappeared and try to determine whether the POI's and the victims knew each other.
Even if investigation reveals there is no link between the POI's and the victims, I believe there is some other criminal enterprise(s) these POI's have been engaged in based on their criminal backgrounds and habits of continually moving around the state. I believe they're all part of a drug ring.
Common elements related to the POI's:
1) The POI's have lived in the area of the murders or the areas where the victims initially disappeared. Two obviously were with the victim right before she disappeared.
2) The POI's are related through blood, employment or friendship.
3) The POI's live or have lived in close proximity with each other, whether in the same house, same apartment building or same town/city.
4) The POI's continually move from city to city and have usually moved in relation to some crime that had recently been committed. One could also speculate the reason to be employment, drug distribution or pressure from LE scrutiny.
5) All POI's have extensive criminal backgrounds, habitual criminality, violent behavior, drug use and drug distribution.
6) Some of the POI's once lived in the hometowns of two of the victims.
7) Some of the victims may have been involved in drug use.
8) Three of the victims disappeared late at night after consuming alcohol.
9) Two of the victims were killed in the daytime by intruders in their homes.
10) Two victims appear to have been involved in the drug scene.
POI # 1
David E. Peacock, age 41, born 05-22-1967. Male Caucasian.
Wisconsin known criminal history (Public record): Deliver/Sell Marijuana, Possession of THC, Operating while Intoxicated (1st), Possession of Cocaine/Coca(2nd+), Battery, Battery, Battery, False Imprisonment, Disorderly Conduct, Habitual Criminality, Failure to Notify Police of Accident, Hit and Run-Property Adjacent to Highway, Fail/Report to County Jail, Operating While under Influence (3rd), Operating with PAC .08 or More (3rd), OAR (1st - Rev. due to OWI/PAC), Arrest warrant filed for his arrest in the current DUI case, Disorderly Conduct. Mail returned unclaimed/undelivered from Robertson Rd address, which is a roofing company business, not a residence.
Previous known addresses:
5124 Montgomery St # 44, Dodgeville, WI 02-05-1999
A- 1743 White St., Dubuque, 07-08-1999
721 W. 5th Street, Dubuque, IA 12-06-2000
101 S Grove St, Mt Horeb, WI 01-15-2003
813 Vista Ridge Dr, Mt Horeb, WI 11-20-2003
3120 B Old Gate Rd, Madison, WI 01-31-2005
4105 Stonehart Dr Apt 3, Saint Ann, MO
08-17-2005
4105 Stonehart Dr Apt 3, Saint Ann, MO 02-14-2006
2402 Robertson Road, Madison, WI 03-21-2008 (robertson RD is a business address)
303 Prevo Dr., Apopka, FL
1350 Field Ct., Mount Horeb, WI
725 Blue Mounds St. Mount Horeb, WI
2305 Holiday Dr., Janesville, WI
street address unk, Cuba City. WI
street address unk, Sorrento, FL
The map below shows all known areas where David Peacock lived. Red spots are where a victim disappeared or was found. I did not put in Peacocks FL or MO addresses. Feel free to Googlemap these addresses using closeup maps. If anyone comes up with other addresses, feel free to post them.
Compare with:
461 W. Gilman St. Madison, WI Lava Lounge
434 W Mifflin St., Madison, WI Nolan residence
517 W Doty St. Madison, WI Zimmerman residence
714 W. Shore Dr., Madison, WI Marino residence
Parr & Park St., Madison, WI Marino suspect seen
To Be Continued...Next POI: Stephen K. Peacock