I tend to look for patterns & I thought this was interesting. It may mean nothing, but at every crime scene where a dismembered body is found that could possibly be a victim of the Manorville Butcher, an intact murder victim is also found. What are the odds? This excludes G4 as I am convinced that is a separate killer. And I am becoming more & more convinced that Sugar Bear is a victim of Manorville Butcher, based on other excellent observations by others on here.
Manorville:
11/19/2000 – UID female – strangled – dismembered
11/23/2000 – UID male – strangled – intact
7/26/2003 – Jessica Taylor – strangled – dismembered
11/10/2003 – UID male – strangled – intact
Ocean Parkway:
All discovered in 2011:
Jessica Taylor, Jane Doe 6, Peaches, Fire Island Doe – strangled – dismembered
Asian Doe – beaten – intact
Baby Doe – undetermined cause of death – intact
Southern State Parkway:
June 2008 – Tanya Rush – dismembered
7/12/2008 – UID female - intact
One mile apart on Southern State
North Shore:
3/3/2007 – Cherries – stabbed – dismembered (found in Oyster Bay, Cold Spring Harbor & Mamaroneck)
1/23/2013 – Lattingtown Doe – trauma – intact
4 miles apart from Oyster Bay to Lattingtown
Rockaway Beach:
Dec 2002 – Sugar Bear – skull found (shot) - dismembered
2/10/2005 – John Valentine (child) – undetermined cause of death – not sure if intact or dismembered
9 miles apart
Another pattern (which again may not mean anything) - almost all females dismembered, Sugar Bear dismembered (female impersonator), males intact, if Lattingtown Jane Doe connected, then both Asian victims are beaten.
