2011.03.04 Motions Hearing - #1 (AM)

[strawberry]

she keeps shuffling her papers. geez

Taking lessons from her colleague ICA I see.

 

[Mendara]

They can challenge evidence at the trial. End of story.

The science is not scientific argument is ridiculous.

 

[BigFatMommyDog]

...Ok Sims arguing to dispute current position on Frye - I think,

Please correct me folks

 

[PassTheMotrin]

Wouldn't you love to know what Casey is scribbling and bibbling? Is it meaningful to her trial, or is she just doodling to look intelligent and involved?

Taking notes for a possible future book deal, perhaps? Or maybe just playing hangman.

 

[cloud9]

I'm back! Trying to clean, watch the hearing and be here. You are all great!!!

:rocker:

 

[nursebeeme]

defense trying to say halls method is a brand new technique

 

[snowshuze]

Hmmm.
This sounds like testimony that should be IN THE FRYE HEARING.
In other words, she's giving expert testimony in absence of the experts.

 

[Mendara]

Again more shuffling of papers - glasses back on and she keeps repeating herself.

Baez is day dreaming and scratching his ears. KC is trying not to fall asleep (not kidding her eyes are closing).

 

[Gnatcatcher]

Sims reminds me of the social studies teacher in "Clueless', the one the girls fix up with the debate teacher.

 

[mitzi]

ok...she talks so fast that I am not following her at all...anyone else having trouble?
:waitasec:

 

[nursebeeme]

she is making sense... I hope they straighten it out on redirect (re: dr hall plant expert for the state)

 

[TiaM]

Yep Dorothy - it's a "Brand New Technique" - so was DNA at one time.

Guess who was the pioneer for getting DNA evidence admitted?

Not Jose Baez, that's for sure.

 

[MD MOMMY]

She has a very soothing voice. I feel like I'm listening to a nursery rhyme at the library with my son.

 

[spiderlady]

Don't they have to just prove that SOMETHING was growing threw those poor little bones?

 

[joypath]

THEN.....the defense should "attack" the botany results in trial and if the good botanist is "such a fraud" it would be IN FRONT OF A JURY~ and discredit his results!

She's asking that the FRYE conditions be applied to the Ph. D's "life experience opinion"! :banghead:

 

[passionflower]

no emotion for ICA when plant growth is talked about............
I would be bawling knowing plants grew through my babies skull...........

 

[manatee]

this is a messy speach

 

[BigFatMommyDog]

Disputing methodology of expert -

I think JA is going to be ok on this

 

[Chiquita71]

ICA gives JB a little pat to his knee...BARF.

Motion to strike defense's motion to strike plant life growth.

Looks like defense filed motions to strike evidence and the state is moving to trike these motions and prove that this evidence is qualified to be included and the defense can argue the evidence in court.

Respectfully Quoted MD MOMMY and Mendara :wave:
BBM

Who can say that ten times while rubbing their belly and hitting the top of their head? LOL.

But, thank you really. The thread is moving fast and this is good info. !

(MD MOMMY: Thank you! ) :sick: ITA

:cow:

 

[BetteDavisEyes]

she's writing an "(if) I did it" a la OJ Simpson.

I wish!

ICA doesn't write across an entire line on the paper but seems to keep her margins very small. It almost looks like she's writing a task like the good sisters used to do when I was in elementary school

Jose, will you marry me?
Jose, will you marry me?
Jose, will you marry me?

That fits!