I posed this question to an Open AI model:
"Erin Patterson showed
zero emotion in court when the jury announced the verdict of her charges.
I suspect that she's a Narcissistic Psychopath. Would showing no emotion be an expected response?"
This was the answer it gave:
If — hypothetically — Erin Patterson were a
narcissistic psychopath, then yes: her showing
no emotion in court upon hearing “guilty on all charges” (3 murders, 1 attempted murder) would be consistent with how people with these traits often behave.
Here’s why:
Narcissistic psychopathy behavioural traits:
Psychopathy traits (per Hare’s Psychopathy Checklist, PCL-R):
- Lack of empathy or remorse
- Shallow affect (superficial or limited emotional response)
- Grandiosity, sense of superiority
- Manipulativeness, lying
- Callousness
Narcissistic traits (as in Narcissistic Personality Disorder):
- Fragile but inflated self-esteem
- Denial of fault or blame
- Difficulty tolerating shame, so they may mask emotion to “save face”
- Focus on maintaining control of their image
Why they might not show emotion:

Many psychopaths don’t truly feel guilt, shame, or fear the way most people do — so they don’t experience the courtroom moment the way you or I might.

Others are so invested in their self-image (“I’m smarter than everyone,” “This is unfair,” “I’ll appeal and win”) that they suppress outward signs of distress.

Some simply don’t process consequences properly — they live in the moment, or assume they’ll still “win” somehow.

In narcissistic psychopathy specifically, the shame of being seen as weak or defeated may lead to a stone-faced, blank response as a kind of defence mechanism.
-