AZ - Lori Vallow Daybell charged w/ conspiring to kill ex-husband Charles Vallow and another relative, Brandon Boudreaux, Chandler, Maricopa County #3

Status
Not open for further replies.
Perhaps the gun was already in the kitchen, awaiting Charles arrival? I am in agreement with your scenario.
I think Alex took the first shot. Charles wasn’t dying fast enough. I think Lori took the second shot, laughing all the while. I could see her laughing then telling Alex to stay until he died and then call police.
 
I know it's a small detail but I'm still puzzling over why there was a pair of flip flops/sandals just inside the front door, looking like they'd just been stepped out of. I think they look like Lori's. I don't know why anyone would make the choice to go outside barefoot. I'm wondering if she left them on purpose, or took them off on purpose, in case they had gsr or blood on them, as if she wasn't going to claim she was there initially but the shoes would belie that. Then she could say it was transfer from others.
My theory is that this is an element of poor scene staging. I can imagine Lori thinking the interpretation would be that she always takes her shoes off in the house and she was so scared by the "conflict" she didn't have time to put her shoes on before fleeing. I think I'd make sure to snag my shoes if I was trying to run out onto the hot concrete quickly to elude someone.

My mom lives in Phoenix (near Chandler!) and I don't walk anywhere barefoot outside her house. In addition to the hot concrete, there is lots of pointy gravel and cactus that make it painful to walk around the hot concrete. There is an awkward hopping dance you do the first time you try, and then never again will you try. The concrete is hot all day there, including the am.

Also, wouldn't you ask Tylee to get your shoes if you sent her back for your purse/wallet? I think I've driven maybe once without shoes in 40+ years of driving, and it would feel very noticeably weird immediately upon getting in the car. I think the shoes also gave her an errand to run to kill time for the killing to "take".
 
I think Alex took the first shot. Charles wasn’t dying fast enough. I think Lori took the second shot, laughing all the while. I could see her laughing then telling Alex to stay until he died and then call police.
Are there any area videos showing what time LVD left the house with TR and JJ?
There were those 43 unaccounted for minutes after CV was killed before AC called 911 and I also read that there was a phone call between LVD & AC during that 43 minute timeline too.
 
Perhaps the gun was already in the kitchen, awaiting Charles arrival? I am in agreement with your scenario.
I've also suspected that Lori may have shot at least one of the shots at Charles and have wondered whether GSR tests were conducted on her. At the same time, I have to take into consideration that the gun was a 45 caliber which is a hefty gun.

My experience shooting guns is limited - 22 rifle and shot guns when young and taking gun safety classes and preparing for bird hunting with my dad, and handgun safety and shooting classes as an adult woman. In the handgun classes, we had the opportunity to shoot various handguns to gain familiarity with how each felt. I'd expect that Lori would have no problem shooting a 9mm, just as I had no problem doing so. But I recall that a 45 caliber handgun was quite a bit heavier to hold so made it more difficult to maintain aim and it had quite a kick.

According to this, a 9 mm semiautomatic handgun typically weighs 17-25 ounces and a full-size 45 caliber weighs 30-40 ounces, and the magazine loaded with ammunition adds further weight, with 45 caliber bullets weighing more than 9 mm:

I'd like to know more about the size and weight of Alex's fully-loaded 45 caliber handgun and about Lori's experience with handguns and whether she had much experience shooting that large a caliber before.
 
Recap of yesterday


[…]

An employee of Banner Life Insurance took the stand as a recording played, hearing her tell Vallow Daybell she was not Charles' beneficiary immediately following his death.

Vallow Daybell trial: Jurors hear about insurance

The motive of greed was on display in the courtroom on April 14, as the Lori Vallow Daybell trial entered its second week. In Arizona, the so-called Doomsday Mom is accused of conspiring to kill her then-husband, Charles Vallow. FOX 10's Lauren Clark has more.
"I can tell you the beneficiary was changed in March of this year," the employee was heard saying in the recording.

"OK. OK. Trying to figure out what he was doing, since we have five kids, and have been married for 15 years," Vallow Daybell was heard saying.

[…]

 
Are there any area videos showing what time LVD left the house with TR and JJ?
There were those 43 unaccounted for minutes after CV was killed before AC called 911 and I also read that there was a phone call between LVD & AC during that 43 minute timeline too.
There's a great, detailed timeline HERE in the Media, Maps, Timeline subforum that shows all the contradicting accounts of that morning. It doesn't include the Burger King or Walgreens timestamps, though. I pulled that from the probable cause document HERE.

"Following the murder of Charles Vallow, Lori took his rental vehicle and cellular phone. The GPS data associated with the phone indicated that the phone left the residence at 0749 hours. Lori then went to Burger King to get food for JJ, Walgreens to get flip flops for her and Tylee and finally returned home at 0848 hours. Alex Cox would not call 911 until 0832 hours to report the shooting."
 
There's a great, detailed timeline HERE in the Media, Maps, Timeline subforum that shows all the contradicting accounts of that morning. It doesn't include the Burger King or Walgreens timestamps, though. I pulled that from the probable cause document HERE.

"Following the murder of Charles Vallow, Lori took his rental vehicle and cellular phone. The GPS data associated with the phone indicated that the phone left the residence at 0749 hours. Lori then went to Burger King to get food for JJ, Walgreens to get flip flops for her and Tylee and finally returned home at 0848 hours. Alex Cox would not call 911 until 0832 hours to report the shooting."
Interesting that Alex calls 911 at 8:32 am. When LVD was interviewed by Detective Ynclan, LVD told her that she had told CV not to get JJ to the school too early because the school opened the gates at 8:20 am. (Edited to correct time from the interview.)

Had LVD instructed AC not to call 911 until LVD would be in the presence of witnesses (other parents of students, teachers, staff)?
 
Last edited:
I've also suspected that Lori may have shot at least one of the shots at Charles and have wondered whether GSR tests were conducted on her. At the same time, I have to take into consideration that the gun was a 45 caliber which is a hefty gun.

My experience shooting guns is limited - 22 rifle and shot guns when young and taking gun safety classes and preparing for bird hunting with my dad, and handgun safety and shooting classes as an adult woman. In the handgun classes, we had the opportunity to shoot various handguns to gain familiarity with how each felt. I'd expect that Lori would have no problem shooting a 9mm, just as I had no problem doing so. But I recall that a 45 caliber handgun was quite a bit heavier to hold so made it more difficult to maintain aim and it had quite a kick.

According to this, a 9 mm semiautomatic handgun typically weighs 17-25 ounces and a full-size 45 caliber weighs 30-40 ounces, and the magazine loaded with ammunition adds further weight, with 45 caliber bullets weighing more than 9 mm:

I'd like to know more about the size and weight of Alex's fully-loaded 45 caliber handgun and about Lori's experience with handguns and whether she had much experience shooting that large a caliber before.
Yesterday Prosecutor Kay asked detective CY if tests were done on AC and LVD and she answered "no" because AC already said he was the one who shot CV with the gun.
 
Yesterday Prosecutor Kay asked detective CY if tests were done on AC and LVD and she answered "no" because AC already said he was the one who shot CV with the gun.
Thank you - I was watching that testimony but had a few interruptions and I missed that.

HOW in the world was a man who'd ordinarily be considered "low risk" shot with so little reasonable inquiry into the truth about how that occurred?

LVD had the victim's cellphone and rental car and FLED the scene for an hour WITH 1-2* of the other witnesses to the event, and the victim lay there without emergency medical response for nearly all of that time. Red flag, red flag, red flag, red flag.

*ETA: I have always wondered whether JJ also witnessed the shooting given the words a RING camera recorded him exclaiming when playing with a friend at the Rexburg apartments months later: "Get the hell outta here!" Sounded exactly like what AC might yell after shooting CV and given the ferocity with which it was likely yelled in the middle of a violent event, probably left quite an impression on JJ.
 
Yesterday Prosecutor Kay asked detective CY if tests were done on AC and LVD and she answered "no" because AC already said he was the one who shot CV with the gun.
Just have to wonder if she realizes how bad this sounds? She doesn't appear embarassed at her shoddy work at all. I sure do hope there have been policy changes in Chandler AZ!!
 
Just have to wonder if she realizes how bad this sounds? She doesn't appear embarassed at her shoddy work at all. I sure do hope there have been policy changes in Chandler AZ!!
I was amazed at CY's "lackadaisical" attitude in answering the questions by Kay that proved her incompetence.
Ironic that it's what she claimed LVD's demeanor was.
 
I've also suspected that Lori may have shot at least one of the shots at Charles and have wondered whether GSR tests were conducted on her. At the same time, I have to take into consideration that the gun was a 45 caliber which is a hefty gun.

My experience shooting guns is limited - 22 rifle and shot guns when young and taking gun safety classes and preparing for bird hunting with my dad, and handgun safety and shooting classes as an adult woman. In the handgun classes, we had the opportunity to shoot various handguns to gain familiarity with how each felt. I'd expect that Lori would have no problem shooting a 9mm, just as I had no problem doing so. But I recall that a 45 caliber handgun was quite a bit heavier to hold so made it more difficult to maintain aim and it had quite a kick.

According to this, a 9 mm semiautomatic handgun typically weighs 17-25 ounces and a full-size 45 caliber weighs 30-40 ounces, and the magazine loaded with ammunition adds further weight, with 45 caliber bullets weighing more than 9 mm:

I'd like to know more about the size and weight of Alex's fully-loaded 45 caliber handgun and about Lori's experience with handguns and whether she had much experience shooting that large a caliber before.
I can’t speak to LVD’s shooting experience but can tell you from my own experience that she would probably not have a problem with the size or weight of a gun for a single short range shot. I’m a 60+ woman and have several handguns - revolvers & semi-automatics - the weight of the weapon is not a factor for me unless I am target shooting many rounds and then after a few with the heavier weapons my hands and arms do become fatigued. But I’m also a better shot with the heavier handguns than I am with the lighter ones when shooting only a few rounds. And keep in mind at that range LVD would not have had to actually aim and fire but only to point and shoot.

As for GSR, it is my understanding that neither AC nor LVD were tested because AC admitted to being the shooter.
 
Just have to wonder if she realizes how bad this sounds? She doesn't appear embarassed at her shoddy work at all. I sure do hope there have been policy changes in Chandler AZ!!
Adding insult to injury CY had been in homicide for years before she interviewed LVD.


Officer of the year 2013.

 
Are there any area videos showing what time LVD left the house with TR and JJ?
There were those 43 unaccounted for minutes after CV was killed before AC called 911 and I also read that there was a phone call between LVD & AC during that 43 minute timeline too.
I don’t know that. I am sure there is a timeline from their phone records. Surely LE has all that.

The charges didn’t come for years and they waited until after the other trials before they even brought the charges.

It leaves me dumbfounded as to why LE fumbled this case so bad. Why was this case not important to them? They have said they were investigating all along. I don’t believe it. In fact, if JJ hadn’t gone missing, Charles would have been forgotten.

I have so many questions. Like why isn’t Charles’ oldest two boys not testifying? Or Melani Boudreaux Pawlowski or Melani Gibb or Zulema Pastenes? Is the prosecutor afraid someone will open the door to the other murders and cause a mistrial?

I am very afraid she will be found not guilty.
The prosecution hasn’t proven conspiracy to commit murder. They’ve only proven she committed adultery.
 
Adam Cox testified that after CV arrived at LVD's house and sent him a text that Alex was there he texted back to CV that "they have a plan" and CV responded "absolutely".
Adam continued texting CV after that and never heard back from him.
What I don't get is if Adam was so concerned about CV's safety did he ever say why he didn't make sure that CV was alright before he and his son left to visit a relative and then a friend?
imo
 
@Tanager excellent insight. I always wondered about LVD going to buy shoes. Didn't she have any shoes? She didn't want to go into the house.

I used to live in Las Vegas, and in the summer, I even put "booties" on our dog, the cement was so hot.
 
We are live.

LVD is violating victim's rights. Subpoeanaing family members whose addresses she apparently shouldn't have, shouldn't be contacting, and aren't on her witness lists.

LVD claims she didn't subpoena them, says it was an oversight.

State says she SIGNED THEM.

LVD says she didn't see who all she was signing, signed a stack.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
137
Guests online
5,723
Total visitors
5,860

Forum statistics

Threads
622,096
Messages
18,444,645
Members
239,899
Latest member
Alpinelady
Back
Top