CO - BARRY ARRESTED AGAIN - Suzanne Morphew, 49, Chaffee Co, 10 May 2020 *Case dismissed w/o prejudice* *found in 2023* #118

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #61
I've wondered about that, but I also suspect that the sheriff in that Moffat County sends out teams to practice search whenever they get a chance (or a report of disturbed land.) One thing about the high plains / mountain plateaus, because they are so dry vegetation grows slowly, so disturbed areas can be easily spotted if you know what to look for.
 
  • #62
It almost looks like someone originally wanted Suzanne's remains not to be found but then felt there was an advantage to having them found, hence the new location.

Something a random abductor isn't going to do.

I can think of only one person who'd do that.

JMO
 
Last edited:
  • #63
Would public defenders be assigned to various LE who were named in Barry's civil suit? Could that be the conflict?

LE had probable cause to arrest him the first time, nothing unlawful about it IMO. But IE sure managed to name everyone she could think creating a scramble for them to secure representation against Barry's claims. A run on defense attorneys?

I still don't see how Barry should get to have his pick of private defense attorneys, chartered by the public defenders office. Special privilege?

It feels orchestrated. Too orchestrated.

Staged.

JMO
So I'm the Colorado Public Defender Megan Ring. My staff learns they've been appointed to represent Morphew, but they have a conflict of interest (or commitment).

As required, Morphew applies for appointed counsel. I would have to have parachuted in from Guam yesterday not to know that Eytan is not available but Fisher-Byrialsen has been representing Morphew from shortly after the time of his first arrest. She knows that case inside out and upside down. This is a two-attorney case, and there is another murder-qualified attorney, David Beller. They are on the registered appointment list. They'd make a great defense team.

I don't have to appoint a lawyer at random or by any bureaucratic process. I exercise my best judgment to provide the most effective representation available. Who on that list will I approach first? "Jane, are you available and willing to accept our reimbursement rate?"

Of course, all these people know each other. But that doesn't make this decision suspicious. For the Public Defender it was a no-brainer.
 
  • #64
I think he may have been interrupted at the beach site, may have gone to the housing development, gave up on those and barried her somewhere behind PP. I believe it was at elevation, I think she was transported in a cooler. From that location, spring melt carried away some of her bones, and from there, he moved her again, this time to Moffat, though I can only guess when he did that. When the prosecution said they had a good idea where she was barried. When he sold PP. When Edna disappeared.

Busy B was very busy.

JMO
My initial guess was Pahlone Peak just south of Puma Path, which has a passable road/jeep trail to near the tree line. I thought maybe Mt. Aetna but I don' think it's as accessible. Also, the Pahlone Peak road is more conveniently located if you're making a desperate dash to Moffat.
 
  • #65
So I'm the Colorado Public Defender Megan Ring. My staff learns they've been appointed to represent Morphew, but they have a conflict of interest (or commitment).

As required, Morphew applies for appointed counsel. I would have to have parachuted in from Guam yesterday not to know that Eytan is not available but Fisher-Byrialsen has been representing Morphew from shortly after the time of his first arrest. She knows that case inside out and upside down. This is a two-attorney case, and there is another murder-qualified attorney, David Beller. They are on the registered appointment list. They'd make a great defense team.

I don't have to appoint a lawyer at random or by any bureaucratic process. I exercise my best judgment to provide the most effective representation available. Who on that list will I approach first? "Jane, are you available and willing to accept our reimbursement rate?"

Of course, all these people know each other. But that doesn't make this decision suspicious. For the Public Defender it was a no-brainer.
That’s how it works in my area since we do not have career PDs. Attorneys in the pool volunteer for a case and they get assigned or if no one volunteers then a judge picks and unless there is a huge conflict the attorneys picked just suck it up and serve.
 
  • #66
It sure looks that way.

JMO

I have been reprimanded on Websleuths - deservedly so, for naming a person I think will be involved in the trial. Will have to wait to see if I am correct. No names, no initials. Just a person BM knows well, and was I think was in a position - through no fault to be close to the action.
 
  • #67
It always looks like someone originally wanted Suzanne's remains not to be found but then felt there was an advantage to having them found, hence the new location.

Something a random abductor isn't going to do.

I can think of only one person who'd do that.

JMO

Why, oh why would someone connected to the murder want SM remains found - and why would they move them? That is a lot of risk, planning, effort. I cant make sense of moving the body at all. I do feel the murderer lived in fear and was paranoid of getting caught.
 
  • #68
My initial guess was Pahlone Peak just south of Puma Path, which has a passable road/jeep trail to near the tree line. I thought maybe Mt. Aetna but I don' think it's as accessible. Also, the Pahlone Peak road is more conveniently located if you're making a desperate dash to Moffat.
He wasn't thinking of Moffat when he was back behind the PP house however.

Did he barry her back there? One and done (until the Moffat move)?

She must not have been contained, because of the bones which I think were run off.

If Barry used 'techniques' (I'll leave it at that) like he would to preserve animal bones, did he in short order spread her bones there, staging his lion attack?

I distinctly remember him saying they drag their prey up the mountain. (And who doesn't not-wince when they refer to a missing lived one as wild game prey? Shoot, lion got her. See ya.)

The speculation gets pretty macabre but it's because of the facts as we know them --
Bleach/bleached bones
Missing bones/relocated
Decomposed elsewhere/moved
No shoes/no feet/no decomp on clothes
No sign of predation on bones/none on site/no bugs
Staging/re-staging/narrative-building

Did Barry accelerate skeletonization? In order to further a narrative?

He was awful protective of his land when the searchers were there. Just Barry being Barry? If they're was nothing on his property TO find, wouldn't he WELCOME searchers? Look hard, nothing to see here..... what was he guarding?

I have questions.

JMO
 
  • #69
I think the department had some help finding her. 'They stated that they were close to finding her after the first trial'. Then hey presto they find her will allegedly 'looking for another body'.. which they never found. In my opinion they received a tip from (I will call this person X), and the ruse - looking for another body - was to help cover up for the tipster. JMO.
They did find Edna Quintana about a week after Barry’s arrest!
Lauren Sharf posted an update

E to fix
 
  • #70
Is tonight’s 48 Hours new?
 
  • #71
  • #72
Why, oh why would someone connected to the murder want SM remains found - and why would they move them? That is a lot of risk, planning, effort. I cant make sense of moving the body at all. I do feel the murderer lived in fear and was paranoid of getting caught.
Maybe it was as simple as that, IMO, living in fear and being paranoid that the original location maybe wasn't as perfect as planned in the heat of the moment.

So after some time had gone by and the investigators were more stalwart than anticipated and were suspecting him/his stories and not just going away and were circling in too close for long term comfort, he felt it was for the best to move her remains.

Maybe he thought he had initially planned it well and it was good enough at the time. Or even planned as a temporary spot, and he intended to move her all along eventually when things cooled off.

Or he thought the first spot was good, but things change and given more time, it occurred to him moving her remains elsewhere would throw LE off the first trail to her body's first location, where evidence could put him.

And it would be better in the long run to move her somewhere else he thought they would never look and less likely to tie to him as he was more careful and calculating the second time around.

He could have had a 2 part plan, first dispose and cover up her remains well away from the scene of the crime, and if no worries from LE on finding that one for a bit, take them to the next even harder to find spot.

JMO
 
  • #73
He wasn't thinking of Moffat when he was back behind the PP house however.

Did he barry her back there? One and done (until the Moffat move)?

She must not have been contained, because of the bones which I think were run off.

If Barry used 'techniques' (I'll leave it at that) like he would to preserve animal bones, did he in short order spread her bones there, staging his lion attack?

I distinctly remember him saying they drag their prey up the mountain. (And who doesn't not-wince when they refer to a missing lived one as wild game prey? Shoot, lion got her. See ya.)

The speculation gets pretty macabre but it's because of the facts as we know them --
Bleach/bleached bones
Missing bones/relocated
Decomposed elsewhere/moved
No shoes/no feet/no decomp on clothes
No sign of predation on bones/none on site/no bugs
Staging/re-staging/narrative-building

Did Barry accelerate skeletonization? In order to further a narrative?

He was awful protective of his land when the searchers were there. Just Barry being Barry? If they're was nothing on his property TO find, wouldn't he WELCOME searchers? Look hard, nothing to see here..... what was he guarding?

I have questions.

JMO
I agree with Tragg (Post #64) that the area toward Pahlone Peak would be a very logical spot for Mr. Morphew to have selected for disposing of Suzanne’s body. The Colorado Trail and two wide power line corridors along Fooses Creek provide a cleared access route for quad or snowmobile directly from the Puma Path house to heavily wooded areas and a number of old mines. Mr. Morphew would have been very familiar with this area and would only pass 3 houses (set back from road) to reach the Colorado Trail, a well-known snowmobiling/hiking route (only a half mile).
1751781492790.webp
There was still a good amount of snow in this area in the May 8-12 timeframe: on the order of several feet up Fooses Creek (depending on elevation) and likely deeper in protected areas and north slopes. If Mr. Morphew had prepared in advance and taken advantage of the snow cover, the body would have been very difficult to find.

Significantly, a burial at high elevation (i.e. cold) and with snow cover may have contributed to some of the observations in the autopsy. Temperature is one of the most important variables affecting the rate at which decomposition occurs. Burial depth and types of coverings (snow, dirt, tarp, litter, etc.), or lack thereof, also have a significant effect on the decomposition process in cold weather conditions.
(https://www.researchgate.net/public..._of_cold_climate_on_the_decomposition_process)
Low temperatures and snow cover high up in the Fooses Drainage (elevations near 12,000 feet) could account for the lack of insects on the body, and together with snow depth (or containment, say in an ice chest) could limit the activity and access of vertebrate scavengers.

If in fact, the low temperatures at the initial burial location greatly slowed decomposition, it may also explain why there was still viable bone marrow to sample more than 3 years after Suzanne’s murder.

One final thought, the Colorado Trail extends south from Fooses Creek, passes Pahlone Peak and connects to roads that intersect Highway 285 about 34 miles north of Moffat at Mears Junction. ATVs are allowed on some sections of the CO Trail, though illegal use would also be something I could see Mr. Morphew doing. From Mears Junction there are also at least two utility corridors that would allow travel off road and only pass near a handful of residences. This route to Moffat from an initial burial site up Fooses Creek from the Morphew house would be about as good as one could hope for to avoid detection while transporting remains. Among other things it would bypass the cameras at Poncha Pass.

This scenario implies that (1) Mr. Morphew had carefully planned the initial burial site to avoid detection, and (2) law enforcement was not keeping track of Mr. Morphew for some period of time after charges were dropped and before the body was found.
 
  • #74
Why would Joan Fisher-Byrialsen not seek appointment to serve as Morphew's counsel? Iris Eytan and Joan Fisher-Byrialsen have represented Morphew when he faced these charges in the 11th JD, and in the civil lawsuit that's still pending.

@Seattle1 - I thought the civil lawsuit was dismissed - no? TIA! :)
 
  • #75
What's kind of wild about his uttersly stupid "oh Suzanne" video is that, even within such a short time almost no one believed him. I recall the convos we all had at the time. He made it so terribly obvious.
Remember the “it’s too soon” excuse? He only made this video because Trevor pressured him.
 
  • #76
The latest grand jury indictment alleges new details that are surprising even to those who've been following the case since Suzanne Morphew disappeared on Mother's Day, 2020. Barry Morphew has long stated he had nothing to do with his wife's murder, and the couple's two adult daughters have stood by their father.

In 2023, more than three years after she was reported missing, investigators discovered Suzanne Morphew's skeletal remains in a shallow grave during an unrelated search. The location — a remote area known as "the boneyard" near the town of Moffat, Colorado — was less than an hour south of the Morphew home.

"The majority of her bones were recovered," the indictment states, and a board-certified anthropologist, a botanist, and an entomologist were brought in to analyze the remains and concluded that "it was unlikely Suzanne decomposed from a fresh body to a skeleton at this location."

"48 Hours" correspondent Peter Van Sant updates the case in "The Suzanne Morphew Case: Nothing is What It Seems," now streaming on Paramount+.

"This case is incredibly unique," says Aya Gruber, now a law professor at the University of Southern California School of Law. "When you started to dig a little bit deeper, nothing is what it seems."
 
  • #77
  • #78
Looks like Barry started drinking alcohol. I remember that in the early days of the investigation, he complained that Suzanne drank.
 
  • #79
Remember the “it’s too soon” excuse? He only made this video because Trevor pressured him.
I always felt sorry for his nephew. I think he was legitimately trying to help in the only way he knew how.
 
  • #80
Looks like Barry started drinking alcohol. I remember that in the early days of the investigation, he complained that Suzanne drank.
 Keg Kettle, meet Bottle Pot.

The rules never applied to  Bruce  Lee  Moore Barry Morphew.

I'm running out of White Out.

JMO
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
151
Guests online
2,867
Total visitors
3,018

Forum statistics

Threads
632,139
Messages
18,622,634
Members
243,032
Latest member
beccabelle70
Back
Top